Zerot · HackerTrans

vor 8 Monatendiscuss

I would recommend using it, yeah. You have limited context and it will be compacted/summarized occasionally. The compaction/summary will lose some information and it is easy for it to forget certain instructions you gave it. Afaik claude.md will be loaded into the context on every compaction which allows you to use it for instructions that should always be included in the context.

Zerot

vor 8 Monatendiscuss

> Why is that good advice? If that thing is eventually supposed to do the most tricky coding tasks, and already a year ago could have won a medal at the informatics olympics, then why wouldn't it eventually be able to tell if I'm using 2 or 4 spaces and format my code accordingly? Either it's going to change the world, then this is a trivial task, or it's all vaporware, then what are we even discussing..

This is the exact reason for the advice: The LLM already is able to follow coding conventions by just looking at the surrounding code which was already included in the context. So by adding your coding conventions to the claude.md, you are just using more context for no gain.

And another reason to not use an agent for linting/formatting(i.e. prompting to "format this code for me") is that dedicated linters/formatters are faster and only take maybe a single cent of electricity to run whereas using an LLM to do that job will cost multiple dollars if not more.

Zerot

vor 9 Monatendiscuss

Sorry, but no. Those functionalities fall under "functional cookies" and as such do not require consent. Also, there is no tracking needed for the dark mode at all. And "logging in" does not mean "tracking"

Zerot

vor 9 Monatendiscuss

No. You can still install apks through ADB, which is how you would do it during development. But you won't be able to distribute it without signing it through google.

Zerot

vor 10 Monatendiscuss

Seems that the url validation is broken. It says that `http://test.example` is not a valid url

Zerot

vor 11 Monatendiscuss

I think in part the issue is that the LLM does not have enough context. The difference between a bug in the test or a bug in the implementation is purely based on the requirements which are often not in the source code and stored somewhere else(ticket system, documentation platform).

Without providing the actual feature requirements to the LLM(or the developer) it is impossible to determine which is wrong.

Which is why I think it is also sort of stupid by having the LLM generate tests by just giving it access to the implementation. That is at best testing the implementation as it is, but tests should be based on the requirements.

Zerot

vor 12 Monatendiscuss

None. That is the point. 9.9 can be both bigger or smaller than 9.11 depending on context

Zerot

vor 12 Monatendiscuss

Which is the bigger version number? Version 9.9 or version 9.11? Which is the bigger dollar amount? $9.9 or $9.11?

Periods are not always used for the decimal separator but also as a separator for multiple sets of semi-independent numbers.

comments