If I understand the discussion correctly, I think tptacek is right but he's not explaining his position well, which might be why he's been downvoted.
I think he's saying: let's say the correct IP address for example.com is 192.0.2.80. Instead of hijacking the prefix containing example.com's nameservers, an attacker could just hijack 192.0.2.0/24 and immediately get a DV cert. Within seconds they would be up and running and DNSSEC wouldn't have done a thing to prevent it.
I used to regularly buy from Amazon but stopped a while back. The final straw was some razor blades that were noticeably duller and inferior to previous units of the same product.
According to Google PageSpeed Insights, your speed scores are 59/100 for mobile and 40/100 for desktop. The "optimize images" section says there are 1.3MB of image optimizations to do. That's just the image bloat, not the image content, and it's just one of the improvements to make. If you want to make AMP go away, make slow webpages go away.
I don't disagree with you. However, I think the best solutions almost always address root issues, so I'd much rather Google more heavily penalized slow sites. That gets to the heart of the issue without harmful side effects. AMP does neither.
Can anyone think of other industries where this is the case? Imagine for a moment if grocery stores injected small amounts of lead into the food, or if gas stations injected water into the fuel (for bulking).
I know this kind of thing happens in China (think about toxic products added to baby milk, for example, to cheat protein tests). But that's at the "website" level, not the "ISP" level. I suppose healthcare (at least in the US) is the most likely industry to see attacker behavior.
I think he's saying: let's say the correct IP address for example.com is 192.0.2.80. Instead of hijacking the prefix containing example.com's nameservers, an attacker could just hijack 192.0.2.0/24 and immediately get a DV cert. Within seconds they would be up and running and DNSSEC wouldn't have done a thing to prevent it.