HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

kdbeall_

no profile record

comments

kdbeall_
·vor 4 Jahren·discuss
> New lower level reserves will be even more expensive to the point where the LCOE of solar is around the raw uranium price.

No. From the World Nuclear Association, "doubling the uranium price (say from $25 to $50 per lb U3O8) takes the fuel cost up from 0.50 to 0.62 ¢/kWh, an increase of one-quarter, and the expected cost of generation of the best US plants from 1.3 ¢/kWh to 1.42 ¢/kWh (an increase of almost 10%)."

Uranium could easily be $300/lb and nuclear will still be competitive.

> Pre-paying for 75 years worth of electricity rather than 25

Yeah, "electricity" which is intermittent and currently requires Russian and Qatari natgas to load balance... or perhaps you can re-open some coal mines. Pick your poison.
kdbeall_
·vor 4 Jahren·discuss
> then you run out of uranium

Won't happen anytime soon. There's a lot. We have a century's worth, and the uranium price could easily be three times higher, without hardly an impact to utilities, and unlock more reserves and exploration.

> capacity factor of <50% of the french fleet

This not an indictment of nuclear power as a whole. American nuclear reactors have a ~90% capacity factor.

https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/nuclear/data-and-statist...

> Cheap storage like thermal (so the cheapest sand)

Won't be effective for producing electricity. Might only be ~30% efficient.

> far worse than new offshore wind

Wind is reasonable but don't forget that reactors can last a ridiculously long time ~75 years. Wind turbines might only last ~20 years in a corrosive environment.
kdbeall_
·vor 4 Jahren·discuss
> A 2022 PERC cell has an EBPT of about 3-6 months

Okay, so there's a new solar cell that is slightly better and perhaps can be manufactured a little cheaper. Great! So what? You have failed to take into account the burden of energy storage. The capacity factor for solar is an abysmal ~20% if not ~10% in some localities. Wind can have a superior capacity factor of up to ~50%. Energy storage is the constraint.
kdbeall_
·vor 4 Jahren·discuss
This is a mostly dumb and gimmicky idea. It will fail. If we want serious climate solutions we need either a massive build-out of nuclear power or wind plus utility-scale battery (or potentially ammonia) storage. Solar energy has a ridiculously low EROI. Solar energy on a car? Probably an even lower EROI.
kdbeall_
·vor 4 Jahren·discuss
Oh, so the Dutch government should expropriate their land?
kdbeall_
·vor 4 Jahren·discuss
Wow, this was a puff piece