HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

thomascarney

no profile record

comments

thomascarney
·vor 3 Jahren·discuss
I mean, I would agree. The EU courts have ruled pretty much every cross-border data sharing agreement with the US as illegal (e.g. Safe Harbour ruling eight years ago). The EU Commission considered that data transfers to US were not compliant back in 2000, which led to the Safe Harbour in the first place.

Despite all of this, we haven't seen any creation of an EU internet, and even in this latest ruling, they've suspended the ruling until they hope the new system comes into place that will allow cross-border data transfers to the US.

The point being that politically, there is no desire in the EU to cut themselves off from the US internet as you see in China, Russia, etc.
thomascarney
·vor 3 Jahren·discuss
Politically, stopping data transfers to the US is not viable, because it would impact the deal between the EU and the USA (US covers EU defence for access to the EU common market).

For this reason, I don't think we'll ever see a Chinese-style expulsion of US tech companies from the EU.

Therefore, we've seen over a decade of a dance between the judiciary banning data transfers to the US (Safe Harbor ruling, etc) and then politicians overturning these rulings before it actually impacts anything.
thomascarney
·vor 3 Jahren·discuss
In the case of health insurance, AFAIK the subsidies are the government paying on behalf of people who are insured but don't pay in (children, spouses out of the labour market, unemployed - "versicherungsfremde Leistungen") and amounts to about 14 billion out of the 280 billion paid in via employees.

My point is that we don't have "free healthcare" over here in Germany, as Americans often think. We pay in 15% of our income up to the limit into health insurance and we get ok, no-frills healthcare (shared rooms in hospitals, waiting times in big cities to see specialists) relatively equally distributed to the population.

German education systems scores slightly worse than US's system on the 2018 PISA score for what it is worth.
thomascarney
·vor 3 Jahren·discuss
We have get healthcare, disability pensions, pensions and care via insurance in Germany. They aren't provided via government budgets.

If you earn enough or you are self employed, you can in some case opt out of the public insurances, and get private insurance.
thomascarney
·vor 3 Jahren·discuss
I'm not sure what is dishonest about what I said.

My point is that the German system is not a magical system of free healthcare. Rather, it's financially backed by charging a considerable chunk of earnings.

As a side note, the idea that the employer pays 50% of the contribution is a political slight of hand - an employee's labor covers 100% of the health insurance payment.
thomascarney
·vor 3 Jahren·discuss
It's fairly good coverage without frills (i.e. you get a shared room in the hospital). Doctors tend to de-prioritize public insurance when giving appointments, because they earn less from them, particularly for elective or non-urgent issues, so you usually have to wait a bit longer than privately insured patients.

On the other hand, the insurance costs ~15% of income with a cap, so it has an element of solidarity to it - if you earn less, you pay less, and children and non-working spouse get covered without extra cost.
thomascarney
·vor 3 Jahren·discuss
In Germany, my wife and I pay together about ~2,000 USD per month for public health insurance. It's not cheap!
thomascarney
·vor 4 Jahren·discuss
SPD (center-left leaning party) has been junior partners in every one but one of those conservative governments.

German politics are also very collaborative/compromise driven, so it's a mistake to think the outcome would have been drastically different, had we had a SPD/Green coalition rather than a CDU/SPD coalition the last 16 years.

This is especially the case, given that parts of the SPD were and continue to be on Russian payroll.

Ultimately, renewables are very challenging from a technical perspective for a densely populated country with energy intensive industries and limited offshore wind options.
thomascarney
·vor 4 Jahren·discuss
Nuclear was 30% of the electricity generation back in 2000.

The Nordstream projects were conceived to allow Russia to exert force on Eastern European countries without endangering supply of gas to Germany.

Our energy policy has been incredibly short-sighted, focused on maximizing certain sector's economic interests at the expense of national security and EU security.
thomascarney
·vor 4 Jahren·discuss
I think mercantile is the more appropriate adjective.

It was cynical politicians and industrialists who sold the population on a clean energy revolution, all while banking on cheap Russian gas to actually deliver the energy required.