bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

> what can you expect from a language that uses "+", the quintessential notation for commutative operations, for the (very non-commutative) operation of concatenation?

Is this any worse than using `+` for floating-point addition, which isn't even associative?

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

So, Envoy will be embedding WebAssembly alongside (or instead of) Lua?

Are other projects moving from Lua (or other embedded scripting languages) to WebAssembly? What are the benefits of compiling an extension to WASM rather than writing it in Lua?

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

Thanks, that makes sense.

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

> It was released just as the PS2 was announced

I think that's the point. A lot of people bought a PS2 because it was also a DVD player (same with the PS3 and Blu-ray).

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

Isn't code generation during parsing still common today? In particular, bytecode generation in interpreters (and JIT compilers) for scripting languages, e.g. Lua?

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

`range` is an example. Lack of support for overloading makes it harder to replicate its API in our own functions.

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

Well, however the `range` function is implemented, IMO its API would be better expressed as true overloading - as two functions with the same name.

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

If all we do is write Pythonic code (especially now that "Pythonic" seems to include type hints), what's the benefit of the highly dynamic CPython virtual machine?

Surely a faster VM, or even an ahead-of-time compiler, would be possible if we give up on some dynamism? Is that a direction the community should take?

(I think Guido's answer would be no, based on his apparent dislike of existing "Python compiler" projects such as Nuitka.)

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

`range(stop)` and `range(1, stop)` are both supported, but without overloading, the implementation of `range` is messy as it has to work out the meaning of each argument manually.

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

That's the thing - it's documented as overloaded, because that's the most intuitive explanation. Wren would allow it to actually be implemented as an overloaded function.

Python doesn't support overloading, and it doesn't support optional arguments before required ones, so the actual implementation in Python is a bit messy - something like:

  def range(start_or_stop, optional_stop=None):
      if optional_stop is None:
          start = 0
          stop = start_or_stop
      else:
          start = start_or_stop
          stop = optional_stop
      ...

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

The Wren scripting language supports this kind of "overloading by arity" [0].

Wren therefore allows overloads such as `range(stop)` and `range(start, stop)`. This is more intuitive than Python's `range(start=0, stop)`, which might be the only function in the language that has an optional parameter before a required one.

[0] http://wren.io/method-calls.html

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

"Distances longer than a few kilometers are measured in miles" was a direct reference to the OP's "yards to measure distances shorter than a few kilometers".

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

I think Jedd was commenting on the spelling of "meter" vs "metre".

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

The UK doesn't use the metric system for distances, at least when talking about travel. The only switching is from yards to miles.

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

That shouldn't be surprising. Distances longer than a few kilometers are measured in miles.

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

> an engineer in silicon valley

Good point. The biggest factor that determines an engineer's salary is location, followed by years of experience. Not whether they work on compilers/embedded/web/whatever.

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

From GitHub [1]:

  "Plans to try MIR light-weight JIT first for CRuby or/and MRuby implementation"
  "MIR is strongly typed"

Is there an explanation of how the project bridges the gap between dynamically-typed Ruby and statically-typed MIR?

More generally, I'd love to see something like MRuby+MIR be successful. It would be great to see an alternative to the aging LuaJIT.

[1] https://github.com/vnmakarov/mir

bakery2k

6 years agodiscuss

I wonder if it's similar to embedded software development (which also requires "rigorous working methods"). Salaries for embedded are generally lower than for web development because there's much less demand for embedded skills.

bakery2k

7 years agodiscuss

In a language like Python that encourages duck typing, type hints can become extremely complex [1] and can get in the way of the ideal of "executable pseudocode" [2].

[1] https://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-dev/2015-April/1392...

[2] https://twitter.com/dabeaz/status/981832805540909056

bakery2k

7 years agodiscuss

Spot on. Static typing has benefits, but it also has a cost. Python's optional type hints have all the complexity but only some of the benefits - in my experience, runtime type errors are still common.

> To me it feels like python is running as far away from simplicity as fast as possible.

Despite its reputation, Python hasn't been a simple language for a long time.

Submissions

Lua and Python

Guido van Rossum Exits Python Steering Council

Hashmaps Benchmarks – Finding the Fastest, Memory Efficient Hashmap

Ask HN: Any experience with Python-in-the-browser (Python-to-JavaScript) tools?

comments