HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

medbrane

no profile record

comments

medbrane
·3 months ago·discuss
>here's no mechanism for progressive disclosure of parts of the tool's abilities

In fact there is: https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/agents-and-tools/tool-us...

If the special tool search tool is available, then a client would not load the descriptions of the tools in advance, but only for the ones found via the search tool. But it's not widely supported yet.
medbrane
·7 months ago·discuss
Indeed, the reconnect behavior is described in the protocol and the server will simply resume from the requested sequence id.
medbrane
·8 months ago·discuss
But hey, your fridge is now more secure because blockchain (I'm not kidding, it's in the press release)
medbrane
·11 months ago·discuss
Indeed, the article would have been correct one year ago.

Now, modern LLM APIs do require the tools to be described outside the prompt [1]. This negates the whole article, although one bit where he's right is that it does not matter if those tools are MCP tools or local, the call to LLM looks the same.

[1] https://platform.openai.com/docs/guides/function-calling?api...
medbrane
·12 months ago·discuss
That was in 2022, before LLMs, and they "lost" as in they had to pay back $482 USD.
medbrane
·last year·discuss
>one of the oldest Western traditions is to demonize Russia and Russian people

Would you blame them? Who cares is something good happens now in Russia while they are brutally murdering their neighbors?

Nobody cares whether Hitler was great at drawing or not.
medbrane
·last year·discuss
>Broadly speaking, Russian historians are generally of the opinion that the Holodomor did not constitute a genocide. Among Ukrainian historians the general opinion is that it did constitute a genocide.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor_genocide_question
medbrane
·last year·discuss
No support for long, streaming interactions, like a terminal
medbrane
·last year·discuss
An endpoint implementing this protocol would describe the agent and its capabilities, including examples. So I guess you could index that and create a discovery service.
medbrane
·last year·discuss
But MCP doesn't claim to address agent to agent communication, right?
medbrane
·last year·discuss
That's dependent on the particular LLM one uses.

But it can be a json with the tool name and the payload for the tool.