If you are really angry and want a refund, you'd better move your domains out of godaddy(I recommend Moniker.com) quietly before you do a charge back. You know domain name is your most important property so don't put any risk on it.
IMO Plentyoffish is very good design site, it's simple and direct. And the best thing is I always look better in the real world than my photo at the Plentyoffish:)