Forgive me for not satisfying you with a nuanced treatise on a casual forum. Aristotle’s ultimate conclusion was that “for the average person” Democracy was the moral government.
He was not of average status. His nuance and negativity was, to my mind, self preservation driven. Nonetheless, he understood the benefits of Democracy to what we’d call “Main Street” life as obvious. He dismissed on those grounds as well, given the threat to his status. He got what it meant as an idea and agreed it would be a moral win for the public.
Ultimately I’m not writing a biography here. This isn’t rocket science and there’s little new territory to really be walked.
America of a generation ago had high taxes flooding communities with money. Now that generation is wielding a nations wealth against the next generation.
America is a lot of control freaks policing each other for compliance to sound economics and calling it freedom.
America does not have a stories history of being labor friendly. It’s pretty much old European pissing competitions imported anew after WW2. Identity which the country had begun to schlep off between the Gilded Age and WW1. Refugees brought it back over.
The best part of all this is Adam Smith only ever mentions markets in the context of a free labor market, buoyed by government support of equality of condition.
But Smith and Aristotle, who wrote Democracy is likely the most moral government, are cast aside for James Madison who wrote the Senate ought to protect the rich from Democracy or the people will take all the aristocrats stuff.
This is all 2,000+ years old rhetoric. Human biology hasn’t evolved so fast in that time that such concerns of the past are rendered obsolete.
He was not of average status. His nuance and negativity was, to my mind, self preservation driven. Nonetheless, he understood the benefits of Democracy to what we’d call “Main Street” life as obvious. He dismissed on those grounds as well, given the threat to his status. He got what it meant as an idea and agreed it would be a moral win for the public.
Ultimately I’m not writing a biography here. This isn’t rocket science and there’s little new territory to really be walked.
America of a generation ago had high taxes flooding communities with money. Now that generation is wielding a nations wealth against the next generation.
America is a lot of control freaks policing each other for compliance to sound economics and calling it freedom.