HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

OliverM

no profile record

comments

OliverM
·le mois dernier·discuss
This is easily googled, no? It is not a twitter fight.
OliverM
·il y a 4 mois·discuss
I'm not suggesting otherwise. I'm saying that your "toy example" comment is very dismissive of something that was an extraordinary accomplishment of its day. They invented spreadsheets without it. Dependency graphs are excellent and widely useful things we should all be happy to adapt and reach for, far beyond spreadsheets. We should be grateful that they're available to all of us to build into software products so readily. I've used them repeatedly and I'm sure I will many times in the future.

What I'm trying to communicate is this: this product _invented_ spreadsheets, but you dismiss the implementation with a sneer.
OliverM
·il y a 4 mois·discuss
The clause "it's absolutely necessary for all but the simplest toy examples" is what I was disagreeing with. But I wouldn't be surprised to hear that visicalc adopted one as soon as it was technically feasible in later versions.
OliverM
·il y a 4 mois·discuss
Isn’t the existence & success of visicalc a direct counter to this?
OliverM
·il y a 4 mois·discuss
The author is an accomplished software engineer.