lifeformed

4,561 karmajoined il y a 15 ans

lifeformed.com

comments

il y a 13 heuresdiscuss

This assumes that children's learning is solely about correctness and obtaining information. There is a whole universe of other considerations, like interacting with other people, with adults, with fallible authority figures. Having a conversation with a teacher and getting the wrong answer teaches you far more about being a human being and living in a human society, than getting facts back from a screen. Yes, teachers being incorrect is something that should be improved, but reducing human interaction is not an improvement.

il y a 14 joursdiscuss

Is it actually that hard to make good models or is it just about the amount of resources you have to do training? (This is an actual question, I really don't know.) I'm sure it's not trivial but does it really take world class secret knowledge to build off of the known existing techniques? I feel like there's tons of low hanging fruit still to explore, and time and resources are the limiting factor.

il y a 20 joursdiscuss

Maybe a really lightweight fast LLM could moderate messages in realtime. Not sure how pricey that would get though.

le mois dernierdiscuss

Well I'm sure someone will tell it to.

le mois dernierdiscuss

I guess I don't understand which are the features Messenger has that Signal doesn't that requires a billion dollars a year to maintain.

le mois dernierdiscuss

But a messaging program like Signal is fairly similar in scope, but only has like a couple dozen of devs, compared to Messenger's thousands(?).

il y a 2 moisdiscuss

The truth is that if you get in early enough on a hype train and cash out in time, you will make money. That's enough of a rational basis to participate. The ostensible purpose of it all is basically irrelevant, except as a signal to participate.

il y a 2 moisdiscuss

It takes away from real human artists who do their part to slowly advance human culture. Music will not develop without human artists. Maybe for this moment in time AI can fulfill some people's musical desires, but it's not going to keep up with the times. The point of art, in a general sense, is humanity. Automating away your artistic needs is like automating away your social needs. It's a one way "relationship" that is superficial and self-indulgent. It's a step towards an empty world.

il y a 3 moisdiscuss

I think this article is agreeing with you. It's saying that it's not an "intelligence" failure in the traditional "military intelligence" sense of the word we expect, but rather it's an "intelligence" failure in "runaway idiocy" sense.

il y a 3 moisdiscuss

The whole industry is about robots telling robots what to do, why wouldn't they have expected automation?

il y a 3 moisdiscuss

That's still making assumptions based on our human understanding of the cosmos. Our "laws of physics" could be a localized understanding in our region of space, and much, much, much more powerful entities could operate outside of that, where our perception of time and scale does not meaningfully apply. It would be near-zero cost to destroy potential threats, so they might as well. It's like humans eliminating pests and pathogens. It's standard hygiene, a low cost preventative practice. Nobody is targeting a single bacterium, they're just wiping down dirty spots. It's an interesting concept in the book because of how imaginative it gets with scaling.

il y a 3 moisdiscuss

"Timescales that makes sense" may be a human reasoning but not necessarily the reasoning of inconceivably advanced timeless civilizations. Sure, that planet of fish may be harmless now, but what about in a quick three billion years when they have FTL and AGI and Von Neuman probes and Dyson spheres and antimatter bombs? Easier to click the delete button now to save the trouble later.

il y a 3 moisdiscuss

What "content of character" do you ascribe to a web scraper?

il y a 4 moisdiscuss

I guess a good way to preview things would go a long way. Merging might be unrealistic to generalize, but being able to diff on images, game engine prefabs, audio, etc would help deciding which one to use.

il y a 4 moisdiscuss

My issue with git is handling non-text files, which is a common issue with game development. git-lfs is okay but it has some tricky quirks, and you end up with lots of bloat, and you can't merge. I don't really have an answer to how to improve it, but it would be nice if there was some innovation in that area too.

il y a 4 moisdiscuss

But that's not what AGI is. Restructuring data the way they do is very impressive but it's fundamentally different from novel creativity.

il y a 4 moisdiscuss

As long as it's within the law? What if they politically control the law-making system? What if they've shown themselves to operate brazenly outside the law?

il y a 4 moisdiscuss

I buy my software by weight! Give me the biggest one you have, please. I'm talking hundreds of klocs.

il y a 4 moisdiscuss

It's not because of one incident. And the fascist part of these incidents isn't just the killing, it's the official response to it. They immediately claim the victims are terrorists and assassins and suppress investigation of it. Let's not pretend this is just some sad accident.

il y a 4 moisdiscuss

> If I had a button that would wipe out the entire Amazon jungle and replace it with a world class high technology industry, I wouldn't even think twice before pressing it.

Wow. Why, because the Amazon is just a bunch of trees or something boring? If "high technology industry" is so much more valuable without even thinking twice about it, you probably don't understand very much of the world.