HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

rp3

no profile record

comments

rp3
·il y a 4 ans·discuss
rp3
·il y a 4 ans·discuss
They literally linked to a study, said "this is the best study", then said "this study didn't show benefits in [any] these areas", without mentioning the benefits the study did show. Belarus is/was not a country at risk of contaminated water, even after the collapse of the USSR.
rp3
·il y a 4 ans·discuss
The author made it seem like breastfeeding had no impact, but rather they just cherry-picked the conditions to look for from the study, making no mention of things that were impacted.
rp3
·il y a 4 ans·discuss
Did this author even read the papers she cites?

> In the first camp — the randomized trial camp — we have one very large-scale study from Belarus. Known as the PROBIT trial, it was run in the 1990s and continued to follow up as the children aged.

And then later

> The researchers analyzed the impacts of breastfeeding on allergies and asthma; on cavities; and on height, blood pressure, weight and various measures of obesity. They found no evidence of nursing’s impacts on any of these outcomes.

If you go to the PROBIT trial, you see it clearly stated that they did find an impact from nursing:

> Conclusions: Our experimental intervention increased the duration and degree (exclusivity) of breastfeeding and decreased the risk of gastrointestinal tract infection and atopic eczema in the first year of life.
rp3
·il y a 4 ans·discuss
The U.S. doesn't have guaranteed maternity leave. Even 4 months is considered generous. Many people will pump breast milk during the day, and deliver it to the baby in a bottle.