HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

_mu

no profile record

Submissions

My review of Claude’s new Code Interpreter, released under a confusing name

simonwillison.net
9 points·by _mu·10 माह पहले·0 comments

comments

_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
I think on-device AI will show up more front and center but in a few more years.

A big issue to solve is battery life. Right now there's already a lot that goes on at night while the user sleeps with their phone plugged in. This helps to preserve battery life because you can run intensive tasks while hooked up to a power source.

If apps are doing a lot of AI stuff in the course of regular interaction, that could drain the battery fairly quickly.

Amazingly, I think the memory footprint of the phones will also need to get quite a bit larger to really support the big uses cases and workflows. (I do feel somewhat crazy that it is already possible to purchase an iPhone with 1TB of storage and 8GB of RAM).
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
> But I’ve seen enough repos that I know what good practices look like.

This is the danger - I get why you think it's true, but it's not true. I've mentored many many bootcamp grads. The biggest danger with y'all is you don't know what you don't know.

Even if you are a really good bootcamp grad and you have good taste and ability, you do not have experience. Software experience is measured really in years and decades, not months.
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
> committed parenthood.

I like this phrasing because that really feels like how the employer looks at it ultimately.

"Why, it's as irresponsible as calling in sick!"
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
Made me think of A City Is Not A Tree - https://www.patternlanguage.com/archive/cityisnotatree.html
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
Oh, oh okay, okay, wow, well, that's an important clarification then.
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
> rational geeks

Geeks are as emotional and irrational as everybody else. They are even worse in fact because they can rationalize their behavior even harder.
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
> now you have to be careful how and when you use the term "refactor" because the people who ought to be supportive hear "wasting time".

Programmers had a hand in this, sadly: https://martinfowler.com/bliki/RefactoringMalapropism.html

Nowadays people throw the term "refactoring" around quite loosely, usually meaning "rewrite" when that was not at all the original meaning of the term!

A little bit like how "vibe coding" quickly went from one definition to another even though people should have known better.
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
It is not a meaningless question? It is a very profound question.
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
see my profile
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
all my routers run TOMATO
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
This article is attempting to make some kind of statement about 996 and "look, now it's here!"

But this is plainly ridiculous. The Bay Area has been full of high achievers the entire time I've lived here (since the 20th century). All the startups I worked at, people would work Saturdays. Not all the time, of course, but it was quite common.
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
Why build understanding when you could be pedantic?
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
> I think this is just a natural consequence of structuring everything around engagement.

Agree - for me this leads to the conclusion that some services should not be run for-profit, or at least they should be run for public benefit. Similar to how governments in some countries own part of the railway.
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
What is really missing is good sex education in schools, especially public schools - and in particular in the United States. The state of sex education in America actually deserves the work deplorable, it's so bad.

Looking at this comment thread, I get the sense that people are coming from vastly different backgrounds and upbringings. There's no baseline established for what people are trying to discuss.

There are a lot of topics that should simply be explained to children up front from a very early age. When a topic is not shrouded in mystery, it becomes boring. So kids should learn from an early age what is sex, puberty, menstruation, homosexuality, etc. and it should be presented in a manner-of-fact way that takes the emotional charge out of the picture. When people are educated, they have more latitude to make good decisions.
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
Brazil is the end state
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
Yes, it's a very ancient idea.

"As we think, so we become."

- Buddha
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
I'm surprised more folks aren't live to this -- AI is just the scapegoat. The jobs are moving to where labor is cheaper.
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
Some of the companies in the Fortune 500 have been around for over a century, they understand everything moves in cycles.
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
It's not that Claude can't but iOS / Apple development is such a bear and beast. You could really build a whole model just to solve for that ecosystem. There are huge issues in the Apple ecosystem with documentation and so much tribal knowledge. In many cases it's hard to know what is the right thing to do, and there is keeping up with all of Apple's required changes.

So Claude could do it, it just seems like they're focusing on a different set of developers for the moment.
_mu
·10 माह पहले·discuss
> Still thinking about the endgame.

It is said by some that the endgame is agents, like Devin. The IDEs are just the start of AI coding.