HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

carlbrown

no profile record

comments

carlbrown
·2 वर्ष पहले·discuss
I disagree. There are no actual lies in the video itself, and I don't think that, for example, the engineer who is narrating the video is responsible for writing the description of the video (which is where the actual lie was).

The person (probably in marketing) that made the false claim is at fault, and any manager involved who did not stop the lie is at fault.

The software developers who are working on Devin's code likely had no control of or idea about how the video was going to be marketed.

There have been many times that I've been part of a team that built a product we were proud of, and had some business or sales person at our company, over our objections, make claims about it to a customer (or potential customer) that the sales person had been told were not true.
carlbrown
·2 वर्ष पहले·discuss
The company said in the description of the demo video that Devin did something in the demo video that Devin clearly did not do in the demo video.

That's a lie, pure and simple, and no statements made elsewhere can make that lie any less a lie.
carlbrown
·2 वर्ष पहले·discuss
The video doesn't claim that Devin isn't useful. The video is about the claims Devin's company is making: 1) Lying outright about Devin completing and getting paid for Upwork jobs, and 2) Declaring that Devin is an "AI Software Engineer" is, at best, a huge exaggeration.