HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

ctward

no profile record

Submissions

Stop using icons in data tables

medium.com
122 points·by ctward·5 bulan yang lalu·60 comments

comments

ctward
·5 bulan yang lalu·discuss
Valid point. Should I stand up my own blog or should I use a different platform? What recommendations do you have?
ctward
·5 bulan yang lalu·discuss
I agree that certain icons that are common parlance can increase cognition ( vs. x). However I think expanding a users icon lexicon and forcing memorization can actually harm cognitive experience.

Our users are context switching across dozens if not hundreds of digital experiences a day. Forcing memory recall is a tax. The question is always "whats the ROI?"

IMO color and words go just as far as an icon without relying on net new visual language.

As per your comment on horizontal scrolling, I couldn't agree more. Horizontal scrolling is booty. However, depending on the job to be done you can avoid overly wide tables with customizable columns, expandable rows, hover states, and strategic truncation.

I certainly would prefer those strategies over relying on a unique icon language that isn't part of the dozen or so immediately recognizable icon schemas already familiar to users.
ctward
·5 bulan yang lalu·discuss
Hey, author here, I'll attempt to clarify.

In a data grid or table the relative cognitive load of the page is already very high. Adding iconography to the table body content is often unnecessary and increases visual noise, processing requirements, and generally reduces readability/scanability.

I've always felt that icons in this context are a risk or liability instead of a strength. I decided to info dump my findings to my team then published it as an article.

I probably could use a good editor to help me next time!