HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

erklik

no profile record

comments

erklik
·3 bulan yang lalu·discuss
> I am not the person you are asking, but (to me personally) it just says that Saudi Arabia had made massive strides to become a modern 21st century society, as opposed to some of their regional neighbors who still practice FGM on a notable scale.

That assumes that Saudis did use to do FGM.. and that's not true either.
erklik
·3 bulan yang lalu·discuss
> Let's call a cat: of these 230 mutilated women, a vast majority are muslims. There are 900 million muslim women on earth and nearly 1/4th of them have been mutilated by their community.

If the point here is that this is an Islamic/Muslim issue, then you'd find this in other Muslim populations. It's an Africa issue. Ethiopia is 60% Christian, yet had a 65 percent rate of FGM. Look at Pakistan, and the levant in general. Very Muslim populations yet very low levels of FGM.
erklik
·4 bulan yang lalu·discuss
> I am not a journalist and even I would question the "good journalism would include" assertion given the source provided.

You've misunderstood. I was saying good journalism would include both sides, and hopefully primary sources alongside the reporting, so readers can evaluate both.

> If the above is "overblown", then the SVP has done so. I have no evidence to believe this is the case however.

It says "at least one of those disruptions were tied to Amazon's AI coding assistant Q, while others exposed deeper issues." You initially cited this article as evidence that coding agents don't produce working code. But the SVP is describing a broader trend of deployment and control plane failures, most of which are classic infrastructure problems that predate AI tooling entirely. You're attributing a systemic operational failure to AI code generation when even your own source doesn't support that.

More fundamentally, your original argument was that the premise "software can write working code" is flawed. One company having incidents, where some of those incidents involved AI tooling doesn't prove that. Humans cause production incidents every single day. By your logic, the existence of any bug would prove humans can't write working code either.
erklik
·4 bulan yang lalu·discuss
Good journalism would include : https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/company-news/amazon-outage-...

I find it somewhat overblown.

Also, I think there's a difference between working code and exceptionally bug-free code. Humans produce bugs all the time. I know I do at least.
erklik
·4 bulan yang lalu·discuss
Shows how although AI is great, good ol' issues that we had in human-coding times are still persistent and problematic even during the AI-age.
erklik
·4 bulan yang lalu·discuss
https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/company-news/amazon-outage-...

About All Hands :

> Much of the coverage of the service incidents has focused on a weekly Amazon Stores operations meeting and a planned discussion of recent outages. Reviewing operational incidents is a routine part of these meetings, during which teams discuss root causes with the goal of continuing to improve reliability for customers.

This is something that's a part of every FAANG afaik. I know for a fact that there's no prohibition on pushing AI-assisted code. How would that even technically work? It'd basically mean banning Kiro/CC from the company.

> Only one of the incidents involved AI-assisted tooling, which related to an engineer following inaccurate advice that an AI tool inferred from an outdated internal wiki, and none involved AI-written code.

and this doesn't seem as "AI caused outage" as it was portrayed.
erklik
·5 bulan yang lalu·discuss
and include the fact that vast majority of other commenters are brand new accounts/never commented before -- doesn't make it look rather genuine
erklik
·5 bulan yang lalu·discuss
> Unable to display PDF directly.

So :shrug:

Edit: Downloaded the pdf, started reading it. So much slop. I think something of value could be surfaced much earlier.
erklik
·6 bulan yang lalu·discuss
> the US military has made contingency plans for a decapitation strike and seizure or destruction of nuclear weapons in Pakistan in case the situation turns really bad there. Real deterrence requires a credible second-strike capability on survivable platforms such as submarines.

The existence of a plan does not equate to the feasibility of its execution. A submarine-based deterrent is indeed the "gold standard" for survivability, but it is not the only standard. There is enough pain for the US that they wouldn't actually attack Pakistan.
erklik
·4 tahun yang lalu·discuss
Ahh. You mean your "in-group" of people who don't believe in "in-groups".

This is tongue-in-cheek. :)
erklik
·5 tahun yang lalu·discuss
> If you turn the iCloud Photos feature off, no more scanning is happening.

Yet.

A few years later, [Insert gov agency here] will force Apple to scan all photos and compare hashes to material banned by the government.

This ability to scan photos on the device simply should not exist. If they only want to scan photos being uploaded, just scan them on the server itself. It really isn't that hard.

Apple has turned a steel barrier that's capability focused, into a policy barrier that can be changed by influencing people. That's simply much more insecure and much less privacy focused.
erklik
·7 tahun yang lalu·discuss
I find that it has too many magic commands built-in so no-one really gets to learn the under-side of what's actually occuring so when it eventually breaks like everything does, you have no idea what you did wrong. An example would be how the git pull command is basically a bunch of different git fetch and merge commands.
erklik
·7 tahun yang lalu·discuss
Not necessairly. My point was that he/she was using an example that painted the Watch/Modern Phones in a bad light, while you can find examples that paint them in a good light as well.

Also, Telephones do not have nearly the same connection that video calls create. I call my younger sister, who is around 9ish, in a different country twice a day, and she regularly asks me to video her because she wants to give me kisses and wants to see me. That is possible in a normal voice call as well but its not nearly as connecting and personable as video calls are.
erklik
·7 tahun yang lalu·discuss
> it's still ridiculous that people today strap two supercomputers to their wrist so their wife on a business trip in Beijing can tell them over live high-def video to feed the cat.

Or so a person in Hong Kong can say I love you to their grandmother about to pass away in a hospital.
erklik
·7 tahun yang lalu·discuss
For me, it helps figure out if my sleep apnea is getting worse and I need to talk to somebody about my CPAP machine or not.
erklik
·7 tahun yang lalu·discuss
I disagree as well. A little while ago, my parents complained that their computer was getting too slow. I took a look and its a little old and they had Windows 10 on it. I removed it, installed Ubuntu 18.04 and since then, they have never even mentioned it.

All they do is check email, watch Netflix, and do some word documents sometimes. I had to initially show them where to find LibreOffice but other than that, they've been happy since.

Ubuntu has reached that soft spot where its perfect for anyone who is in need of a simple, easy to use computer that does not do work using some specialized software.
erklik
·7 tahun yang lalu·discuss
Interesting, by gathering data on what kills people, they inadvertently also gather data on how dangerous guns are.

Although, props to the CDC. That is some serious data gathering, cleaning etc. Most countries don't have that level of detail. At least not publically available.
erklik
·7 tahun yang lalu·discuss
> I think pretty much everyone reasonable agrees that "kill the {jews,muslims,hispanics}" (once more, folks, this was the THIRD ethnic massacre advertised on 8chan!) is intolerant, no?

I mean, saying something like "Kill the Terrorists" would be something many people agree with or find to be tolerant. This shows that there is some group of "terrorists" that people are happy to have killed.