marshray · HackerLangs

4 hari yang laludiscuss

OK, so I asked ChatGPT "How do I prevent Spotify from automatically playing every time I get in my car?"

The answer looks entirely reasonable. I can't check the Android settings, but I was able to confirm that all of the suggested iPhone and Spotify and settings exist. Most of them I had already configured that way, some I didn't know about before.

marshray

4 hari yang laludiscuss

Such an inspection capability might also be used to target ads to LLMs, which would then be more likely to mention or recommend those products and services.

marshray

4 hari yang laludiscuss

Your comment seems to have little to do with the article?

Don't get me wrong - I personally "trust" an LLM as a source of facts about as far as I could throw a rack of GPUs. But this article you linked takes a whole lot of words to cast LLMs as the villian for amplifying a bit of bad information originally published by a usually reliable and widely-cited source:

"In short, either Phoronix mocked up the screenshots to demonstrate what the feature could look like, or perhaps they were testing a preview snapshot for FreeBSD 15.1 which was never shipped. Either way, it looks like other blogs and reviewers picked up on this and shared the information, presenting it as a feature which would be (or was included) in FreeBSD's latest version."

marshray

4 hari yang laludiscuss

If dirt-simple type operations like copy-paste yield useful improvements with even a small probability that would seem to open things up for adaptive reconfiguration and whole other classes of optimizations like genetic algorithms.

marshray

4 hari yang laludiscuss

It's going to be hard to explain to future generations that the demand for computer-speakers was once such that sometimes they could even decide the language in which they spoke to the computer, and that really was a big deal back then because computers couldn't just switch back and forth like they can today.

marshray

4 hari yang laludiscuss

Never underestimate the power of a catchy title that resonates with the intuitions and preconceptions of people who will never read the paper.

Cf. https://machinelearning.apple.com/research/illusion-of-think...

marshray

4 hari yang laludiscuss

What is "real understanding", and what question can we ask ChatGPT to determine whether it has it?

marshray

4 hari yang laludiscuss

Naming things using qualifiers like "large" has never aged well when transistors were involved.

For example, consider the term "short wave" radio which refers to wavelengths of at least 10 meters. Today's mobile communications use wavelengths 100x - 10,000x shorter.

marshray

15 hari yang laludiscuss

The idea entered our collective subconscious and is still going strong:

https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/my-father-in-law-is-a-builder...

Imagine growing up in Cairo.

marshray

15 hari yang laludiscuss

I'm seeing the phrases "tremendous amount of homework", "substantial amount", and "few hours".

Does anyone have an actual estimated time we can discuss?

marshray

19 hari yang laludiscuss

Well, it turned out the affiliate code linked as "the author's" actually belongs to the publisher anyway.

marshray

19 hari yang laludiscuss

It's just that such cases come down to technical advice that applies to a specific legal environment (certain states you mention), whereas I'm personally more interested in looking at such situations from the ethics, identity, and authenticity perspectives.

marshray

20 hari yang laludiscuss

You went to law school and you don't see any the difference between forging someone else's signature on a document and encoding one's own authentic signature into a digital document file in the manner needed by the recipient?

marshray

20 hari yang laludiscuss

We're discussing a blog post about a blatantly plagiarized website, and the ethical environment and professional choices that led to its creation and continued existence. We get to do that.

This isn't Reddit and we aren't "the internet". We aren't brigading and organizing harassment or whatever here.

That is why the particulars of the web designer's personal life and state of mind are mostly uninteresting.

marshray

20 hari yang laludiscuss

But there are any number of humans who will tell you that humans are bad at multithreading the codes and all but the smallest codebases are headed for heisenbug deadlock city if you do things like they told you to in that Introduction to OOP with JavaTM book.

But is Claude going to tell you "No, dear user, this project is going to follow an excessively simple and sub-optimal locking regime because experience shows that it is easier to write code than it is to reason about its exponentially-growing complexity" ?

marshray

20 hari yang laludiscuss

That comment had me reaching for the skull emoji.

marshray

20 hari yang laludiscuss

> My experience inflicted stupidity.

We've all been there.

> I find it nice that they linked to the original book. For every x earned let the original author earn many times more. > It's probably a better deal than the author got from their legal publisher.

These two statements sound contradictory to me.

> And who's fault is that? Google? Or this little slop maker that I'm (again stupidly) assuming is not a SEO hacker.

Why not both? I think there's plenty of blame to go around.

Also, the publisher who presumably convinced the author that it would be a good idea to assign them exclusive rights. The affiliate link the blog post refers to as "the author's own" actually belongs to the publisher.

marshray

20 hari yang laludiscuss

Lol! This is why they told us to properly label and provide attribution for every image :-D

marshray

20 hari yang laludiscuss

Actually he survived, he just has to turn on 39 more radio transmitter towers before he can be rescued.

(and thank you for Far Cry Primal)

marshray

20 hari yang laludiscuss

When/where I grew up (the United States), private planes were thought of as auto-un-aliving machines for Doctors and Dentists.

Boomers and older generations tended to think of them as part of rural life. E.g. farmers would sometimes put an airstrip on a spare field. There's an episode of Mayberry (The Andy Griffith Show) in which Aunt Bea gets her pilots license.

comments