Please indicate how favorable or unfavorable you are to: ICE, also known as Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
was: June 30 '25 - 8
Dec 8 '25 -14
Jan 12 '26 -20
Feb 1 '26 -22
As an added curio, among Democrats it shifted -12 points, but among Republicans it shifted -17 points. Make of that what you will. 62% of Americans say the actions of ICE are making Americans somewhat less safe or much less safe. 37% think the actions of ICE are making Americans much more safe or somewhat more safe
The following information is from Pages 14-16 of the PDF [2]. The specific question was: Do you approve or disapprove of the job Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is doing?
33% Approve
60% Disapprove
7% Unsure
The poll is extremely along the party lines in some respects (e.g. only 2% of the people who answered 'Approve' voted for Kamala in 2024), but I feel like that's to be expected. At the same time, while people who approve of ICE definitely didn't vote for Kamala, people who voted for Trump are not extremely strong supporters, with 24% of 2024 Trump voters answering either Disapprove or Unsure (18% and 6% respectively). Big city 31%
Small city 31%
Suburban 28%
Small town 40%
Rural 43%
Again, apologies for the digression, I figured maybe someone can make some sense of those numbers. Another question: How would you describe the actions of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in enforcing immigration laws? Do you think they have:
65% Gone too far
12% Not gone far enough
22% Or are their actions about right
1% Vol: unsure
This can be summarized in a bunch of different ways, but it's not dishonest to say that 2/3rds of Americans think that ICE has "gone too far", which heavily contradicts your statement. Everything after this is kind of just because I felt three is the minimum number of sources to thoroughly dismiss your assertion. 54% Gone too far [+11%]
18% Not gone far enough [-06%]
26% Or are their actions about right [-04%]
1% Vol: Unsure
Ipsos released a poll [3] on January 27th, conducted between January 23rd-25th (n=1,139) with a self-reported margin of error of +/- 3.0 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. Overall, do you think efforts by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents to deal with unauthorized immigration in the country... (Page 10)
Go too far 58%
Do not go far enough 12%
Are about right 26%
Do you approve or disapprove of the way President Donald Trump is handling the following issues? Immigration (Page 3)
Strongly approve 26%
Somewhat approve 14%
Somewhat disapprove 10%
Strongly disapprove 43%
Generally speaking, would you say the following things are heading in the right direction, or are they off on the wrong track? Immigration policy (Page 5)
Right direction 35%
Wrong track 51%
Don’t know 11%
P.S. I don't claim this comment to be unbiased, I clearly "cherry-picked" certain facts, but they were not out of context nor did I massage the numbers, the reason I phrased it this way was because it was a direct rebuttal to the claim that most Americans support ICE [even after the shootings].
[0] I was thinking of this kind of human dystopia: "overpopulation could never be a problem: if people run out of food they'll either invent a better alternative to farms or simply arrange themselves in groups where people who can achieve the highest metric that the head/quorum of their society wants the fastest will be fed and the new growth that can't be supported and can't reach that level will simply "select themselves put of existence", increasing our evolution by >10x"
P.S. ..that being said, if a confirmed traveller from the future tells me that in 100 years we discover that trees have feelings (just like we discovered that plants communicate about threats and exhibit behaviour that is definitely anthropomorphized by a tiny, but loud portion of people as selflessness), I would not be at all surprised. I mean I would be surprised, but about as surprised as I was when I learned that a captive octopus that lived in a tank kept shorting out the electrical system in his room at night. No one had any idea wtf was happening until they put cameras and found out that when it wanted to go to sleep at night, it would turn off the lights by spraying salt water into electrical outlets until the breakers tripped so he could get some nice dark sleep.
It seems to be a trait from the time we became _the_ apex predator that we are way too overconfident about our understanding of our environment, especially the other creatures that share this rock with us. Are we the baddies?
I'd add more but this already went on a huge tangent. Thanks for the link.