bachback · HackerTrans

the best agent framework in my opinion is Pi. Pi avoids MCP thats a good thing. why assume that the planet will migrate from HTTP to MCP? no, instead lets assume we have client code we can call. we already have a rich ecosystem of HTTP services and packages. and if we assume a rewrite for agents we probably wouldn't come up with MCP but something more powerful.

bachback

10 mesi fadiscuss

DNS is much more foundational and overlooked here. how does the world agree that "x.com" resolves the way it does?

bachback

2 anni fadiscuss

Deepmind is producing science vapourware while OpenAI is changing the world

bachback

2 anni fadiscuss

interesting, seems more of an enterprise offering. its OpenAI only for and you plan to expand to other vendors? anything opensource?

bachback

2 anni fadiscuss

yes, you can think of Lisp almost as an intermediate language. Lisp probably lends itself well to machine code generation but I haven't done enough assembly to really know that. its not designed for that, its just a side effect of the language primitives being very very short. you can write a basic Lisp interpreter in a few hours yourself https://norvig.com/lispy.html. Creating a decent compiled language takes a lot longer than that. Lisp only requires 5 or so primitives and it doesn't have a grammar.

it is a bit ackward for humans but machines can process it better because it has less structure. for example what I thought is that Lisp could potentially be a great choice to interop with Large Language Models with, because its potentially shorter code. Good clojure code can be 5-10x shorter than python code. With LLMs size of code matters a lot.

bachback

2 anni fadiscuss

Code thats written in Lisp is using AST differently. It makes the process of generating machine code much easier. This in turn enables macros which is meta programming not available in non Lisp languages. However on the other hand I tried this avenue and since most modern computing is not Lisp based it severely limits its potential. I'm hoping for a Rust based Clojure or variant. Clojure has the problem its based on the java ecosystem which has severe downsides. A lisp thats based on python doesnt make much sense to me personally python isnt a good language to write other languages in. I think Zig and Rust would be the interesting choices. One attempt: https://github.com/clojure-rs/ClojureRS

See also: https://paulgraham.com/avg.html

bachback

2 anni fadiscuss

for coding tasks see

https://aider.chat/docs/leaderboards/

the question is how would you define "improve" and "solve". RLHF in a way delegates this to humans.

bachback

2 anni fadiscuss

what does divided together mean? maybe your question doesn't have a good answer, because the question is not formulated well enough.

bachback

2 anni fadiscuss

how you find it better? haven't seen the benefits

bachback

2 anni fadiscuss

API not down. instead of waiting, started simple python code to interact with chatgpt. didn't see another repo for it so far, maybe someone else knows a good one

https://github.com/benjiqq/chatai

bachback

10 anni fadiscuss

What do you think of Bitcoin and use of computers for money and contracts?

bachback

13 anni fadiscuss

Bitcoin + contracts => new governments https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Contracts

Quote from Formalizing and Securing Relationships on Public Networks By Nick Szabo.

"We are now entering an era of online communications and software "literacy". The "physics of cyberspace", studied by computer scientists, are radically different from the properties of paper, to an even greater degree than paper was different from string, clay, and metal. "

bachback

13 anni fadiscuss

Read Formalizing and Securing Relationships on Public Networks By Nick Szabo and couple that with Bitcoin. Think of laws as being online documents with their own git layer, public repo infrastructure.

"We are now entering an era of online communications and software "literacy". The "physics of cyberspace", studied by computer scientists, are radically different from the properties of paper, to an even greater degree than paper was different from string, clay, and metal. "

bachback

13 anni fadiscuss

amazing potential. but in the end - out of scope. If you go through the least each org has only few repos with little interest. One of the more interesting ones is: https://github.com/opengovplatform

comments