HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

doshay

no profile record

Submissions

[untitled]

1 points·by doshay·mese scorso·0 comments

[untitled]

1 points·by doshay·mese scorso·0 comments

[untitled]

1 points·by doshay·mese scorso·0 comments

[untitled]

1 points·by doshay·mese scorso·0 comments

[untitled]

1 points·by doshay·2 mesi fa·0 comments

[untitled]

1 points·by doshay·2 mesi fa·0 comments

Show HN: Git for AI Agents

github.com
129 points·by doshay·2 mesi fa·67 comments

Show HN: Git for AI Agents

github.com
5 points·by doshay·2 mesi fa·0 comments

Make your software arch context-ready

shaylivni.com
3 points·by doshay·2 mesi fa·0 comments

[untitled]

1 points·by doshay·6 mesi fa·0 comments

comments

doshay
·mese scorso·discuss
proof you can do amazing things with only html (and some <script> tags :)
doshay
·mese scorso·discuss
[dead]
doshay
·mese scorso·discuss
Nice direction !

Just curious, how can Deliberate exactly identify the options the agent faced? and what do you consider an "option"? sometimes it can be vauge (say the agent decided to explore this way and not that way, would that be considered an option?)

anyway, i like seeing tools like that! good luck
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
seems like the link is not attached :X
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
it means using coding agents (cc) is allowed? anyway, nice idea. will give it a try
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
cool approach, i havent used jj actually in my workflow, ill try to adopt
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
sure, fair question i think the main difference is that entire are built on top of git == you would have to commit in order to track something...
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
i think you misunderstood the concept, actually . it's not built to replace git, rather to sit on top of it.
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
https://github.com/regent-vcs/re_gent
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
that's exactly what i tried in the first place, but i think it would be misuse of git protocol, git is built for files - the blobs/ tree calc & mechanism , for large contexts and linear thinking flow it's differnt, but honestly - i think you can get to a very good solution with pure git..
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
at the moment only Claude Code, i'm planning to add support for the other big 3, but at the moment it's just me ... hopefully in the near future :)
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
thanks! will do
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
cool!

actually not at the moment - would be nice to add it. i think the core of re_gent allows it very naturally, feel free to push it if want :)
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
exactly, imo - the llm should touch git only after explicit approval or after specific set of guardrails. this one of the reasons i built it actually, i think the agent workflow should be decoupled from git, until saving the code
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
super nice, indeed similar approach
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
but then you would have to commit each tool and action of the agents, which is polluting the git history and also huge overhead (at least imo)
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
absolutely right, i got this feedback from many people actually ...
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
- hopefully after a /compact. - what happens if want to undo, and then redo? i found the /rewind functionality in claude very lean in that matter.
doshay
·2 mesi fa·discuss
tnx for the honest feedback! really, appreciate it! would you mine sharing more details about your workflow with jj?