HackerTrans
トップ新着トレンドコメント過去質問紹介求人

_raz

no profile record

投稿

A Critical Look at MCP

raz.sh
2 ポイント·投稿者 _raz·昨年·0 コメント

Weaponizing SSO for Profit – a rage blog post

raz.sh
8 ポイント·投稿者 _raz·2 年前·0 コメント

[untitled]

1 ポイント·投稿者 _raz·2 年前·0 コメント

[untitled]

1 ポイント·投稿者 _raz·2 年前·0 コメント

[untitled]

1 ポイント·投稿者 _raz·2 年前·0 コメント

コメント

_raz
·昨年·議論
Thanks, very nice! A very explanatory write-up
_raz
·昨年·議論
A RPC standard that plays nicely with LLMs?
_raz
·昨年·議論
I had to take a break from extending, our go LLM wrapper, https://github.com/modfin/bellman with mcp to write the blog entry. So some sort of server-like-thing will be added soon
_raz
·昨年·議論
Idk, I'm kind of agnostic and ended up throwing it in there.

Regurgitating the OAuth draft don't seem that usefull imho, and why am I forced into it if I'm using http. Seems like there are plenty of usecases where un-attended thing would like to interact over http, where we usually use other things aside from OAuth.

It all probably could have been replaced by

- The Client shall implement OAuth2 - The Server may implement OAuth2
_raz
·昨年·議論
Once I published the blog post, I ended up doing a similar thing the other day. https://github.com/modelcontextprotocol/modelcontextprotocol...

From reading your issue, I'm not holding my breath.

It all kind of seems too important to fuck up
_raz
·昨年·議論
Kind of my fear exactly. We are moving so fast and that mcp would create an accept a transport protocol that might take years or decades to get rid off for something better.

Kind of reminds me of the browser wars during 90s where everyone tried to run the fastest an created splits in standards and browsers what we didn't really det rid of for a good 20 year or more. IE11 was around for far to long
_raz
·昨年·議論
Well put
_raz
·昨年·議論
Glad to here, also thought I was alone :)
_raz
·昨年·議論
toml-rpc anyone? :)
_raz
·昨年·議論
Yes, the protocol seems fine to me in and of itself. It's the transport portion that seems to be a dumpster fire on the HTTP side of things.
_raz
·昨年·議論
That's kind of my point, that the protocols complexity is hidden in py sdk making it feel easy... But taking on large tech dept
_raz
·2 年前·議論
a rage blog post to be able to move on with my life
_raz
·2 年前·議論
Building a blogging tool to explain the different parts in getting something online, the old school way, in a blog entry. meta...