In California, the maximum personal income tax rate is effectively closer to 50%, which is where my mind went, but you're right, it's different for companies.
In my example, the tax rate isn't the point though, it was used just to illustrate the math.
The main point is that it makes no sense to require amortization of software development expenses. The idea that this letter is an attempt to restore rationality in the tax code.
For folks that don't know the background on this, here's a layperson summary:
- A business is usually taxed on its profits: you deduct your revenue from the cost of producing that revenue, and the delta is what you are taxed on.
- In software businesses, this usually means if you spend $1M in software development to develop a web app, and it makes $1.1M in that year, you'd get taxed on the $100K profits.
- However, a few years ago, the IRS stopped allowing the $1M to be deducted in the year it was incurred. Instead, the $1M was to be amortized over 5 years, so now the business can only count $200K as the deductible expense for that year. So now it's going to be taxed on "profits" of $900K. Assuming the tax rate is 20%, that means the business owes $180K in taxes, even though it has a total of $100K in the bank after the actual expenses were paid. So it would have to either borrow to pay taxes or raise venture capital, meaning that VC-funded companies would be advantaged over bootstrapped ones!
- The letter's goal is to bring things back to how they were (and how they are for all other businesses): let businesses deduct their actual expenses from their actual revenue, and tax that actual profit.
I am neither a lawyer nor an accountant, this is just my understanding of this issue.
Edit: Switched the tax rate to 20%. The logic is still the same.
I’ve been helping Omar on this and one of the hardest aspects of building this product has been finding users that can give actual feedback. Any ideas there would be super helpful
He is getting a refund along with an additional $200 credit from what I can see.