HackerTrans
トップ新着トレンドコメント過去質問紹介求人

uxcolumbo

1,884 カルマ登録 9 年前

投稿

Ask HN: Why Hasn't Clojure Caught On?

12 ポイント·投稿者 uxcolumbo·3 か月前·15 コメント

Adobe is trying to kill my indie game [video]

youtube.com
1 ポイント·投稿者 uxcolumbo·5 か月前·2 コメント

コメント

uxcolumbo
·4 時間前·議論
Of course life now is better than 100 years ago.

But do you really think life has been getting better in the last 10 years say?

Do you think trickle down economics works?

Are you happy with the way things are going under this administration, which favours those BILLIONAIRES you mentioned, but couldn’t really give a damn about the rest of us or the commons?

Are you OK living in a future where there are zero checks and balances and the .1% fully controlling and owning the political and policy space, i.e. the return to the Robber Barons era?
uxcolumbo
·一昨日·議論
So what are his actual technical accomplishments? Other than marketing and promising FSD is ready tomorrow or we'd land on Mars in 2026, or getting Billions from tax payers in subsidies that allowed him to be as successful as he is ---- what are his actual technical accomplishments?

Has he invented anything, e.g. a new space bracket, or some better radiation shielding or anything that's in heavy use now at SpaceX, Tesla, xAI, etc?

EDIT: clarity
uxcolumbo
·一昨日·議論
>I've built up a huge amount of respect for his technical accomplishments

Are these his actual accomplishments or is he just taking credit for the accomplishments of others in his companies. Just like he took credit for being a founder of Tesla and pushing aside the actual founders.
uxcolumbo
·先月·議論
As a senior dev?

What sector?
uxcolumbo
·先月·議論
I believe the new libs are now all in TS and not Clojure anymore.

Does that mean TS is better suited for computational art?

Or are there other reasons why this lib was moved to TS?
uxcolumbo
·先月·議論
What makes it your favorite Clojure project?
uxcolumbo
·先月·議論
Why are iLemmings comments dead / flagged [0] [1]?

Can't even reply inline and have to reply in the main thread.

I found them informative.

Lots of Clojure haters here I guess?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48375393#48387700

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48375393#48387382
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
A bit turned off by their 'contact us for pricing' line.

Why not show your pricing like any other provider does?
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
Been a bit out of the loop.

What's wrong with using very short sentences like 'That's not X. That's Y.'?
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
What's a good source to learn how to develop like this - to create HTML / CSS structure that's accessible?

EDIT: ignore. I can see you have some links in your profile. Will check it out.
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
I'm a long time Thinkpad user and the integrated trackpoint allows my hands to stay on the keyboard and also move the mouse around and click on things.

I don't get benefit of having a trackpoint detached from the keyboard.

What's the advantage over having a mouse or a trackball?
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
Can you share your setup how to achieve what you described? I'm curious.
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
Thanks for clarifying.

> I did have some issues with how Clojure is managed

Yes there was some drama a few years back and then Rich wrote his post 'Opensource is not about you'. It was a good post.

Opensource is not easy and you might argue the reason why Clojure is so stable and backwards compatible is because of the way it's managed.

Luckily we didn't end up with a scenario where Rich completely stopped. I think there was a recent case of an opensource maintainer (who works in academia) stopping PRs due to an entitled user. Can't remember the project.

But equally, is the current form of stewardship fit for purpose for the next 10 years of Clojure, i.e. to increase adoption by businesses? Don't know. Maybe something can be learned from how Linux is managed. I think Linus experienced similar bottleneck issues back then.

> I’m actually very interested in yank

I think you mean Jank: https://jank-lang.org/ ?

I'm quite excited about Clojure for GO projects.

EDIT: clarity.
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
What made you stop using Clojure? Lack of Clojure jobs? Or something else?
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
Thanks for that. These details are important for newcomers, because it seems the original commenter isn't happy with the core team's process and 'feels like it's falling apart' is hyperbole and subjective.

For future readers: Clojure is known to be extremely stable and backwards compatible. It doesn't suffer from the same churn, fatigue and breaking changes that the JavaScript ecosystems experiences for example. To get to that backwards compatibility it requires a different process.
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
Of course. But for people not in the know and looking outside in, they don't know what's going, i.e. why is someone who's been using Clojure for years and building a business with it making these points every few months as you say?

To counteract FUD it would be useful to give a few more details.
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
Not sure this type of response helps and referring to someone who is active in the Clojure community and tries to build some cutting edge stuff as 'this guy'. (Did some digging and hyperfiddle looks pretty cool).

I think it would help to understand why he is talking about this 'every two months' and then try to address his concerns.

Would be a shame to lose people who are active in the community but not heard.
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
Cognitect is a holding of NuBank (since 2020 I believe).

Doesn't that mean the core developers are now funded by NuBank?

Isn't it in their interest that 'the core language (Clojure and Clojurescript) to not feel like it is falling apart'?

And what do you mean with falling apart?

I'm new to Clojure, so the above is a genuine question.
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
What are your prompting and general tips for using Gemini effectively?

And what use cases do you think it’s best suited for?
uxcolumbo
·2 か月前·議論
What harness would you recommend for the open-weight models?