Ask HN: Why saving webpages on hard disk has not got better?

28 pointsby behnamoh5년 전12 comments

I use Firefox and every time I try to save a webpage, the first try fails! The second one works, but then the saved file does not look like the one you'd see online. There are workarounds such as *.mhtml extensions, but I wonder why browsers have not got better at saving webpages locally.

I've used Chrome too, same problem.

12 comments

Nikhiil_Rajesh5년 전

Try using the [Singlefile](https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/singlefile/mpiodij...) browser extension. This is what I typically use and works very well.

ggm5년 전

The odd thing is, either in shmem/mmap, or on disk cache, is most of the fetched state. A simple "tee" of the data out of QUIC would replay the load of the disparate mark-up elements.

It's all there. The problem is deciding how to add code to save it in a rational reloadable manner.

Compared to eg ZFS snapshot: low cost copy on write, saved state. (Admittedly of data on disk, which is the goal here, but then the browser cache is on disk)

toomuchtodo5년 전

https://warcreate.com/

https://github.com/webrecorder/replayweb.page

ggm5년 전

Thanks! I love proof by example.

toomuchtodo5년 전

I hope you find it helpful!

asaddhamani5년 전

Use SingleFile. It inlines any CSS and images and your saved page will look pretty close to the actual page.

S4M5년 전

I use wget (on the command line) to save a webpage. It has an option to save recursively all the links on the page as well, or only the links from a certain domain.

namaljayathunga5년 전

I use this to backup pages automatically

https://github.com/i5ik/22120

GekkePrutser5년 전

Thanks, I regularly come across cases where I read something interesting but forget to bookmark it. This could really help! I'll definitely try it.

behnamoh5년 전

Unfortunately it only works for Chrome-based browsers.

account-55년 전

I tend to use singlefile extension.

I am looking for something that saves just the JSON responses from a website. I can see the JSON in devtools network tab but can't extract it. I'm not a webdev so it may be easy I just don't know how it's done.

spsphulse5년 전

I'm happy user of Chrome extension called savePageWe