Hey bill,
Thanks for your feedback.
We know Zest behavior is a bit weird when you pick a tab. In order to build a consistent product across all browser we didn't do any modification (yet). Ideally we should check if "one tab" has been selected and start recording automatically.
At Stories, feedback is our raw material to build a great product. Our PMs were struggling to set up a feedback generation process so they built a widget to help our users record voice + screen feedback.
We recently spin it off as a side project: http://hellozest.io/. It's free to install and works like a charm.
Hope it can help you get more contextual feedback and build better product
For now i recommend you to pick "full screen"