Show HN: YTT Tech – My curated database of instructional YouTube Videos(ytt-tech.com)
ytt-tech.com
Show HN: YTT Tech – My curated database of instructional YouTube Videos
https://ytt-tech.com
49 comments
Great idea, thanks. One potential problem I see is that categories seem too broad, you cover a lot of area here. There's so much good content out there that very quickly just 2 levels won't be enough to categorize it into a browsable lists. The same problem most of us have with bookmarks, at some point there's so many of them that you can't find anything anymore.
Yes, definitely. As the database grows I would have to add a third level, at least. Probably sections within the large pane that would fold out.
Creating a useful hierarchy and keeping it balanced is one of the bigger challenges of the project.
Creating a useful hierarchy and keeping it balanced is one of the bigger challenges of the project.
I wonder if this shouldn't be in some wiki-format instead...
This is fantastic, you have a great curation so far. Would it be possible to create an RSS feed of new videos/categories that are added?
Thanks, I'm open to it, but I have no experience with that. Any pointers on where to get started with that?
RSS and atom are simple xml formats that encapsulate information about posts or items on a site. They are linked on the site with meta tags or in direct a links. Here's a link to some documentation: https://www.xul.fr/en-xml-rss.html#structure
Your framework will also likely have helpers to generate those. And you can contact me directly for help, email is in my profile.
Your framework will also likely have helpers to generate those. And you can contact me directly for help, email is in my profile.
I love the look of this page. Great job.
I love curation projects.
Here's a tip if you want to get people to submit more videos. Include a "Submit Video" button in each area. When someone knows of a great video for a category, having to sign up for an account is a huge hassle and de-motivator. So just turn the onboarding upside down. Make it easy to submit a link first.
Once the link is submitted, THEN ask them to fill out the Username/password/email. At that point, they're already invested in the process, already submitted the link, and it's a lot easier to finish.
Here's a tip if you want to get people to submit more videos. Include a "Submit Video" button in each area. When someone knows of a great video for a category, having to sign up for an account is a huge hassle and de-motivator. So just turn the onboarding upside down. Make it easy to submit a link first.
Once the link is submitted, THEN ask them to fill out the Username/password/email. At that point, they're already invested in the process, already submitted the link, and it's a lot easier to finish.
> At that point, they're already invested in the process, already submitted the link, and it's a lot easier to finish
As a user I really (!!) hate this, and consider it a grey pattern at best.
I greatly prefer to know up front whether I'll have to register.
As a user I really (!!) hate this, and consider it a grey pattern at best.
I greatly prefer to know up front whether I'll have to register.
I wasn't logged in to hacker news, but I logged in just to comment this that yes I also absolutely hate it when I discover later on in a process that I'll have to sign up and that just puts me off.
Whenever I see this kind of practice, I see it as an indication that I will encounter similar UX all over the place, so I leave immediately and never go near it again.
Honestly, if you're thinking this is a grey pattern, then you're going to be easy pickings for any competition you may have. By all means, respect your users, but there's no need to tie your hands behind your back when most users are not HN users. If they were, javascript would probably be disabled on most sites.
Note that the optional version of this works fine, but the more sites hide a requirement this way, the more users are justified in assuming that anything they do on a new site may shove random things in their way and get fatigued on doing so entirely except in places they already know. Save the trust environment!
I apologize for being pessimistic about this. Curation does not scale due to Metcalfe's law [0] and socializing it does not work properly due to the differences of interests. What works is curation for subtrees, then you have a social network. Good luck!
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalfe's_la
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalfe's_la
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalfe's_law
The link was broken from a typo.
The link was broken from a typo.
Thank you, my thought here was to make the registration as quick and easy as possible - no email or confirmation is required.
I figured that someone would have to be somewhat invested in order to want to make submissions anyway - it takes longer to get the video URL and go through the submission form than to register.
I figured that someone would have to be somewhat invested in order to want to make submissions anyway - it takes longer to get the video URL and go through the submission form than to register.
An OAuth2/"login with your YouTube account" might streamline this for you, and facilitate sharing of collections already created on YouTube through their Data API.
That's a lot of hassle just to submit a youtube url, isn't it?
Maybe we're talking about different things.
If I (as a user) am sharing a video link from YouTube, in many (most?) cases I will already be logged in to YouTube, and reusing that credential would be easier for me than creating a new account registration on the third party site.
Edit: There's more: once you (as the service) have a YouTube account connected, you can offer a variety of additional services related to the YouTube Data API that a local account registration does not.
(Also: depends on what you mean by "hassle".)
If I (as a user) am sharing a video link from YouTube, in many (most?) cases I will already be logged in to YouTube, and reusing that credential would be easier for me than creating a new account registration on the third party site.
Edit: There's more: once you (as the service) have a YouTube account connected, you can offer a variety of additional services related to the YouTube Data API that a local account registration does not.
(Also: depends on what you mean by "hassle".)
First of all, congratulations on getting this project out the door! This could be a nice discovery tool for people seeking a new hobby.
I notice that each REST request you're making returns a lot of extra data in the payload that the site doesn't seem to use (submittedBy, ytTags, ytDuration, etc). You could probably improve performance by only returning the minimal set of the data the UI needs.
You commented below that this backed by Lambda & DynamoDB. I'm guessing the site is running a little slow right now because it's making a db query for each REST request. Since your list of videos is relatively small and will only be updated periodically, you might consider simply including the whole json structure in the page and making the site entirely static. It will scale much better and save you some money on hosting costs. If you prefer to keep the data loading dynamically, consider putting a caching layer in front of the lambdas.
I notice that each REST request you're making returns a lot of extra data in the payload that the site doesn't seem to use (submittedBy, ytTags, ytDuration, etc). You could probably improve performance by only returning the minimal set of the data the UI needs.
You commented below that this backed by Lambda & DynamoDB. I'm guessing the site is running a little slow right now because it's making a db query for each REST request. Since your list of videos is relatively small and will only be updated periodically, you might consider simply including the whole json structure in the page and making the site entirely static. It will scale much better and save you some money on hosting costs. If you prefer to keep the data loading dynamically, consider putting a caching layer in front of the lambdas.
Thank you for the detailed feedback!
I've removed the unused data on videos, and included the department/section list in the page, so that's one less request. I would like to add caching but haven't tackled that yet.
I've removed the unused data on videos, and included the department/section list in the page, so that's one less request. I would like to add caching but haven't tackled that yet.
I cannot overemphasize how much I like this project, as well as the design of the site.
Like sixQuarks said: "I love curation projects."
Like sixQuarks said: "I love curation projects."
Much appreciated, I wasn't sure if the design would resonate with people :)
Just submitted one of my favorite videos on basic electrical.
Feedback:
- What happens after submission? I'm assuming it goes into a review queue, or caching is involved so I'm not seeing it right away. Maybe make it clear if there is a review queue after submitting
- More detail around what the skill levels mean. I wasn't really sure how to choose. I consider it beginner, but I also saw other videos I consider beginner marked as intermediate
Feedback:
- What happens after submission? I'm assuming it goes into a review queue, or caching is involved so I'm not seeing it right away. Maybe make it clear if there is a review queue after submitting
- More detail around what the skill levels mean. I wasn't really sure how to choose. I consider it beginner, but I also saw other videos I consider beginner marked as intermediate
Thank you! Yes it goes into a queue (if you're interested you can see the queue in the demo video [0]). One thing I would like to add to the user's profile is a list of videos they've submitted and their status - I agree that it's totally unclear right now, I will try to add a note about that somewhere.
The skill level is of course going to be subjective and vary from topic to topic, part of my labeling has to do with what tools are required (if it requires expensive/specialized tools I tend to rank it higher).
If you think a video is mislabeled you can make a suggestion by clicking on the comment bubble in the header (orange part) of the selected video.
[0]https://youtu.be/EpWfvu0p5lA?t=238
The skill level is of course going to be subjective and vary from topic to topic, part of my labeling has to do with what tools are required (if it requires expensive/specialized tools I tend to rank it higher).
If you think a video is mislabeled you can make a suggestion by clicking on the comment bubble in the header (orange part) of the selected video.
[0]https://youtu.be/EpWfvu0p5lA?t=238
How/why did you choose those videos? I'm hoping to build a cabin this year and not a single video I've watched is listed here. The framing videos you have listed seem pretty old-school. Fine Homebuilding and Matt Risinger have updated videos.
I chose them based on what I've come across and searched for, and comparing several videos of the same type. The carpentry videos were some of the earliest ones I added so my process may not have been as good then.
Of course, I'm not an expert on all of these subjects. I've done my best to get things off to a good start, but ultimately the idea would be that people with more knowledge than me add videos on things they know about.
Of course, I'm not an expert on all of these subjects. I've done my best to get things off to a good start, but ultimately the idea would be that people with more knowledge than me add videos on things they know about.
If you want to build a log cabin, MySelfReliance is worth a watch, especially the early ones and the summary one of the first cabin build.
How about submitting whole channels? I'm thinking of the likes of BlondieHacks, Vintage Machinery, Adam Savage's Tested, Essential Craftsman, Primitive Tech: each one a whole library of instructional material in a general category area.
I've considered that, but most of them have at least some videos that are not quite as instructional, or that would go into multiple different categories. I think cherry-picking keeps it more focused.
Perhaps maybe a separate section that highlights some of those great channels would be good.
Perhaps maybe a separate section that highlights some of those great channels would be good.
I love this idea. I agree, there are platforms like SkillShare but none really curate YT videos that are actually good. If possible try to include captions bc many people use them on yt and will be a small feature people expect. I would try to build up a group of people who are avid YT viewers to help you find videos for all categories. Also including a section for beginner, intermediate, and advanced would be awesome - bc learning python from the start isn't optimal for an advanced programmer.
You should make the main content full screen or at least larger and perhaps add more fields. It took a long time before it loaded in the boxes, so is the server overloaded atm?
By more fields do you mean more departments/subjects? Those would be added over time, it takes time to find and vet videos and I didn't want to have a bunch of mostly empty ones, though I understand that it can give the appearance that many things are just left out (users can also suggest new ones when adding videos).
The backend is on Lambda and DynamoDB so it should be able to handle it, but it does seem to be slow right now, I'm increasing the ReadCapacityUnits to see if that helps.
The backend is on Lambda and DynamoDB so it should be able to handle it, but it does seem to be slow right now, I'm increasing the ReadCapacityUnits to see if that helps.
You should add an automotive section. 90% would be ChrisFix.
Also, motorcycle repair with MC Garage, Revzilla/The Shop Manual and Fortnine.
Also, motorcycle repair with MC Garage, Revzilla/The Shop Manual and Fortnine.
Yeah I had considered it, as I know it’s a popular topic, but I know virtually nothing about cars.
Would you break out the different sections by manufacturer - is most stuff specific to certain makes/models? Or is it general enough that a “brakes” section would make sense?
Would you break out the different sections by manufacturer - is most stuff specific to certain makes/models? Or is it general enough that a “brakes” section would make sense?
There's a body of general knowledge that is applicable to most makes and models, and specific knowledge for each make and model. The specific knowledge is mostly in service manuals and dedicated forums, but the general knowledge is widely available in video form. The general learning path is to get the general background online, then read the service manual for the exact procedure for your car or bike.
Would like to add that 1Aauto does great videos, at least for my 7th generation Honda Civic.
Thanks for taking this on. Are you also looking for curators or how are you planning to scale that
That's a good question, to be honest I hadn't gotten that far yet. It would be great to get some contributors on board but I haven't started. Maybe dig for some specialty forums/subreddits and reach out to people there. Open to any ideas or suggestions, email is in my profile!
Thanks! This is a great tool to “bypass” YouTube's recommendations.
Often I feel like having seen 100% of woodworking videos on YouTube. Yet, I recognize 10% channels from your tool. It gives me a good inspiration!
Often I feel like having seen 100% of woodworking videos on YouTube. Yet, I recognize 10% channels from your tool. It gives me a good inspiration!
I love this so much. It’s like youtube but without the youtubers. Thank you!
That's a neat idea, no distractions from suggested videos.
Suggested addition for woodworking: finishing. It's most people's second least favorite thing after sanding.
I really love the beautiful UX experience
Just want to say that the UI and UX is clean and effective. I really enjoyed that.
and where's https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=snz7JJlSZvw ? ;)
I love learning how to do things on YouTube. It's amazing - empowering, really - that we can instantly look up how to do so many things. When I looked around for a site dedicated to organizing and curating this content, I didn't find much, so I took a stab at it. The goal of the site is to make it easy to browse through and discover videos on different topics.
After implementing the basic experience and authoring tools, I spent weeks combing through videos to get the collection started, and I've only scratched the surface. Many areas of interest remain to be added, and to that end, users can submit videos to the database and make other contributions. If the idea resonates it could become a useful resource.
You don't need to register for the main experience of viewing the videos, only to contribute new ones, and email is optional.
A demo video can be found here: https://youtu.be/EpWfvu0p5lA
Thanks!