HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

bifrost

no profile record

Submissions

“I wish I could have licensed the Id source code releases as BSD”

twitter.com
323 points·by bifrost·5 jaar geleden·447 comments

comments

bifrost
·3 maanden geleden·discuss
Age verification is a great example. We've seen what Alec Muffett has been doing around this and its telling that the EFF is doing basically nothing.
bifrost
·3 maanden geleden·discuss
When they supported the legislation called "Net Neutrality" which attempted to supplant the concept of actual net neutrality with some quasi government control of the internet. It would've enabled massive censorship on the internet, something that we've seen is a very very bad thing.
bifrost
·3 maanden geleden·discuss
Yep, great example.
bifrost
·3 maanden geleden·discuss
It was over for me when the EFF advanced the charge of government censorship of the internet. The EFF had previously been a client of mine so I was somewhat familiar with how things worked and basically once Gilmore was out, it went downhill.

They did a lot of good work (much like the ACLU) but they are now honestly unrecognizable.

My old company donated around $3k/mo of services for almost a decade which in the grand scheme of things isn't a lot but we kept them online when other ISPs would've shut them off.

I've ceased donating to them and the ACLU because they no longer stand for freedom on or off the internet. My money now goes to groups that actively pursue the government for violating our constitutional rights.
bifrost
·9 maanden geleden·discuss
Its worth it to practice people skills. Maybe try signing up for public speaking classes or some other form of story telling?
bifrost
·5 jaar geleden·discuss
Its a bit more recent than 25 years, probably 2003-2005 maybe.

When I was a young "computer nerd" who went off to college we had a pretty decent CS program but it was awfully dusty to those not into it. I think there were maybe 5-10 "great" CS programs in the US, now major cities have 2-5 real "learn to code" programs outside of colleges.

In 96, a "programmer" could make decent money but it was defo not a money printing machine.
bifrost
·5 jaar geleden·discuss
Not entirely true, the "tax them to death" crowd in SF are very envious of "Tech Workers" who are largely programmers.
bifrost
·5 jaar geleden·discuss
Yes, it is true in the way that you're talking about it.
bifrost
·5 jaar geleden·discuss
> GPL is certainly better than a license prohibiting commercial use.

The GPL prohibits some commercial use.

The BSD license does not.
bifrost
·5 jaar geleden·discuss
So valuing that his co-holders didn't want to opensource is good for the open source community? That seems backwards.
bifrost
·5 jaar geleden·discuss
And those are? The GPL is far more restrictive, I can't see anything valuable that the GPL would contribute here.
bifrost
·5 jaar geleden·discuss
Incorrect, there is zero about the BSD license that would've prevented you from reading the source if it was released with the Free-er BSD license.
bifrost
·5 jaar geleden·discuss
Sure, but you're claiming the GPL enabled "reading the source" which is patently false.
bifrost
·5 jaar geleden·discuss
You would've had the privilege of reading the source with BSD too, but the GPL prevents a variety of things from happening so its not as free as the BSD License.

If you want to read into something - he was bullied into using the GPL and not the BSD license.
bifrost
·5 jaar geleden·discuss
> It appears that the goal John was shooting for was to have as broad an impact by having the code being reused in as many situations as possible. On this metric, yes BSD would have been a superior choice.

You basically made the point on why using the BSD license would've been superior...

There are a lot of things the GPL prevents and Carmack is spot on about it.
bifrost
·7 jaar geleden·discuss
Its a saying, but since you're being pedantic I'll use my personal favorite example -> Having to use mod_perl or cgi/fcgi is awful.
bifrost
·7 jaar geleden·discuss
Yeah, I probably should update things but honestly if I'm going to do that I'm just going to write my own poller/scheduler and be done with it.

RRD is pretty efficient so I don't have much need to change.
bifrost
·7 jaar geleden·discuss
Be careful, "Spam on the Blockchain" will become a thing.
bifrost
·7 jaar geleden·discuss
Sure but there's a reason that development has moved off of Perl.
bifrost
·7 jaar geleden·discuss
Heh yeah, totally.

The only Perl I use these days is oooooooold software (MRTG) I guess with the exception of Spam Assassin and RT...