It takes the limited resources of land and water from a community and sells the result for profit as food or fuel. The vast majority of profit is made downstream and outside the community.
Golf courses being a traditional green place where people gather seems a bit far fetched to me when most of them are elite private clubs.
It matters because I don't like the style. I wouldn't like it if a human wrote it. I don't like the style so much that I won't read things written with it.
So maybe she had something interesting to say, but it was not communicated to me because I bounced.
FWIW, on your own blog, the most recent post also reads as at least AI helped "Navigator Theory". This sentence in particular sticks out: "They affect what the person notices, what they dismiss, what they measure, what they trust, and what they do when reality pushes back."
The one earlier post I read does not ("toxicity of ideas").
And fwiw, online detectors seems to agree with my own judgement here.
The actual experiment is basically training a relatively large RNN (1000 units) to do a very simple copy-esque task. The weight values are constrained to be either positive or negative at the beginning of training. The RNN could probably be way smaller and still be made to solve this task.
It isn't even a spiking model.
It seems really hard to go from this experiment to "we've learned anything useful about how brains actually work."
I don't think the argument is necessarily against the use of the tools entirely. My interpretation is that it's against delegating to them all understanding.
Humans can only usefully steer LLMs if they have some understanding or context the LLMs do not.
I don't think the first position is steel manned by assuming those holding it actually believe there are no potential problems or ways to use the technology badly.
But that belief does not imply the doom rhetoric is necessary or the best way to approach those issues.
Once of those negative externalities is water usage. The parent was commenting on the also high water usage of golf courses.
Perhaps that's the connection you've missed.