Tesla risks losing CEO Musk if $1T pay package isn't approved, board chair says(cnbc.com)
cnbc.com
Tesla risks losing CEO Musk if $1T pay package isn't approved, board chair says
https://www.cnbc.com/2025/10/27/tesla-musk-pay-shareholder-vote.html
11 comments
Isn't everything beyond a certain dollar amount so colossal that it's one of the most major financial decisions which require more due diligence than average, and if it's a record amount (even within a single org) way more diligence and careful consideration than that? Not necessarily a compensation package, but any huge outlay, over a number of years or not.
Isn't the ideal way to gauge where something big sits in the market, before making a giant leap?
Has anybody seen what other companies are offering Musk in case Tesla does not measure up?
Isn't the ideal way to gauge where something big sits in the market, before making a giant leap?
Has anybody seen what other companies are offering Musk in case Tesla does not measure up?
Why not special voting shares or a re-structure like Alphabet/Meta have done to deliver additional votes or control? Seems like a cash grab and a bet against the US dollar. As long as Tesla continues to exist and inflation erodes enough value from the dollar Elon gets a regular infusion of additional stock to borrow against and the dollar value will just keep rising. As things get worse for the world at large they'll get better and better for Elon and only Elon.
Tesla shareholders get to lose twice, first to inflation just like the rest of us but also their share in Tesla will be regularly diluted specifically so Elon can keep borrowing on favorable terms.
Tesla shareholders get to lose twice, first to inflation just like the rest of us but also their share in Tesla will be regularly diluted specifically so Elon can keep borrowing on favorable terms.
The Tesla dilemma:
Fire Musk and Tesla gets valued for what they are, and stock will plummit.
Keep Musk and continue the downward trajectory where inevitably reality will catch up with the stock and it will plummit.
Short-term there's and argument for keeping Musk but long-term getting rid of him is likely better.
But there doesn't seem to be a way to avoid massive pain mid-term either way.
Fire Musk and Tesla gets valued for what they are, and stock will plummit.
Keep Musk and continue the downward trajectory where inevitably reality will catch up with the stock and it will plummit.
Short-term there's and argument for keeping Musk but long-term getting rid of him is likely better.
But there doesn't seem to be a way to avoid massive pain mid-term either way.
boo frikkin hoo - let the man-baby go dig a hole or something
My theory is that this is sort of a suicide pact where if Musk isn't there then maybe the market evaluates Tesla stock like any other stock and that would dramatically shift the valuation downward...
At the same time I'm not sure if that matters, how long is the market willing to treat Tesla stock as a sort of aspirational stock?
At the same time I'm not sure if that matters, how long is the market willing to treat Tesla stock as a sort of aspirational stock?
Yeah, I mean there’s no transition plan here right? Which means he’s not building for the long term, whatever he does has to manifest during his life.
I bet the stockholders will approve it!
I think Tesla would be better off for the long-term if they cut Elon loose. Elon served his purpose and did a great job showing the value of EVs and that they didn't have to be econobox cars. Job well done! But as a mature company facing intense global competition, Tesla would benefit from someone at the helm knowing how to manage the storm and not engaging in political antics that are hurting the brand. Let Musk go.
Not plausibly of course - can't imagine Musk getting on a call "yeah I would have kept leading Tesla but they wouldn't give me $1T".
$1T being literally more money than any person has ever had.