U.S. Judge in Mangione Case Rules Prosecutors Cannot Seek Death Penalty(nytimes.com)

13 pointsby toomanyrichieshá 5 meses3 comments

U.S. Judge in Mangione Case Rules Prosecutors Cannot Seek Death Penalty

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/30/nyregion/death-penalty-luigi-mangione.html

3 comments

sd9há 5 meses

There are about 20-30 death penalties imposed each year [1]. In contrast, a homocide occurs roughly once every 30 minutes [2], approximately 17,000 per year.

So it is incredibly atypical for a homicide to result in the death penalty.

The death penalty is reserved for crimes involving aggravating factors - committing other felonies simultaneously, e.g. rape, or mass murder, torture, prior convictions, child victim, etc.

In other words, this news seems routine, probably designed to outrage people who are unaware exactly how _uncommon_ the death penalty usually is.

[1] https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/research/analysis/reports/year-...

[2] https://www.fbi.gov/news/press-releases/fbi-releases-2024-re...

vduprashá 5 meses

ICE is divisive. Mangione, there's a subject we can all agree about!

MisterTeahá 5 meses

Executing him would have two effects: Sending the message that killing someone with money and power carries a higher penalty than killing another pleb. Make Mangione a martyr possibly resulting in copy cats seeking to obtain a similar status.

I also think the current administration would highly favor execution to send a strong message that attacking the bourgeoisie will result in death. They would certainly turn up the propaganda to 11. I feel the judge is smart enough to recognize both situations and took that option off the table.