Supreme Court ruling blocks lawsuits against maker of Roundup(apnews.com)
apnews.com
Supreme Court ruling blocks lawsuits against maker of Roundup
https://apnews.com/article/supreme-court-roundup-monsanto-a7f054d80919f98bdfc5190013a8f6f1
7 comments
“State’s rights” the conservative small government supporters shouted for.
States attempt to hold a company accountable for giving its citizens cancer.
Not like that the conservative Supreme Court says.
Either the conservative movement lacks internally consistency, or it is quite consistent but around one central idea, corporations (that are willing to bend the knee to the government, see anthropic for a cautionary counter example) should be unrestrained from seeking profit.
Even the original states rights arguments around slavery were about how private enterprise shouldn’t be restrained from utilizing chattel slavery to extract profits. Seen through that lens the ruling makes perfect sense, if deferring to a big federal rule is best to protect profits, then big government. If deferring to states causes a race to the bottom ensuring profits, then states rights it is.
States attempt to hold a company accountable for giving its citizens cancer.
Not like that the conservative Supreme Court says.
Either the conservative movement lacks internally consistency, or it is quite consistent but around one central idea, corporations (that are willing to bend the knee to the government, see anthropic for a cautionary counter example) should be unrestrained from seeking profit.
Even the original states rights arguments around slavery were about how private enterprise shouldn’t be restrained from utilizing chattel slavery to extract profits. Seen through that lens the ruling makes perfect sense, if deferring to a big federal rule is best to protect profits, then big government. If deferring to states causes a race to the bottom ensuring profits, then states rights it is.
> Either the conservative movement lacks internally consistency, or it is quite consistent but around one central idea, corporations
They pay well (lobby). Why risk your career by not playing ball ?
They pay well (lobby). Why risk your career by not playing ball ?
The USA seems hellbent on speed-running the transition to banana republic.
Bayer heavily lobbied Trump to obtain this beneficial verdict:
https://usrtk.org/pesticides/bayer-lobby-tracker/
I seriously suspect that glyphosate's safety is so obvious at a population level compared to what's in roundup now, folks in power aligned who didn't want the market for other herbicides to get restricted.