HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

jpatten

13 karmajoined 2 года назад
James Patten - www.pattenstudio.com - Interested in interactive and kinetic art and design, tangible interfaces, electronics, robotics and software. On the amateur radio airwaves I'm WC1A. I like to use Emacs, C++, Python, Kicad, Fusion and Blender.

comments

jpatten
·позавчера·discuss
I'm not sure I see the distinction you're making between 3D design and other spatial reasoning tasks. You can use RL to teach navigation or video game play too. Does that mean these tasks are not spatial reasoning? Additionally, 3D CAD is all about understanding how objects "interact with each one another in a highly quantitative way." I mean, not in the rabbit example, but the container Fable designed for me holds around 30 different types of objects. It figured out a way to arrange them that was more space efficient than what I'd originally described. It considered the best way to stack the fasteners in each bin to pack them as densely as possible. It identified the risk that some very thin objects could slide between compartments in transit, and modified the design to prevent that. It correctly solved for the tolerance between objects that needed to snap together. These all feel like understanding how objects interact with each other. The model didn't just talk about these concerns, but created two 3d models for the case and its lid that accurately reflected them. I hadn't seen that before.
jpatten
·3 дня назад·discuss
Out of curiosity I gave Fable (on max effort) a CAD task yesterday, which was to design a space efficient carrying case for a set of fasteners in my repair kit for work. It used CadQuery to generate a STEP file. The result was pretty much exactly what I wanted, without needing any manual edits. I did go back and forth with it on the design, but was really impressed with the result. Without prompting it included nice touches like ribs on the bottom of the lid to stop fasteners from migrating to adjacent compartments, and the right tolerance for the fit between the case and the lid. This is a dramatic improvement from Opus 4.8.
jpatten
·19 дней назад·discuss
I don't agree with the conclusion here. The issue in the sports court example could just as easily be addressed by adding granularity. If the system allowed users more granularity in the length of their sessions, the undesirable strategies in the post would no longer work.
jpatten
·2 месяца назад·discuss
haha that's right I'd forgotten about that one!
jpatten
·2 месяца назад·discuss
Reminds me of Put That There https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RyBEUyEtxQo