HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

mpavlov

no profile record

Submissions

Why Alpha Arena was a bad benchmark

borisagain.substack.com
6 points·by mpavlov·8 месяцев назад·0 comments

Show HN: Pokerbattle.ai – A week-long poker tournament for LLMs

pokerbattle.ai
14 points·by mpavlov·10 месяцев назад·4 comments

comments

mpavlov
·9 месяцев назад·discuss
(author of PokerBattle is here)

Well, you're not wrong :) Vercel is not the one to blame here, it's my skill issue. Entire thing was vibecoded by me — product manager with no production dev experience. Not to promote vibecoding, but I couldn't do it myself the other way.
mpavlov
·9 месяцев назад·discuss
(author of PokerBattle here)

You right, results and numbers are mainly for entertainment purposes. This sample size would allow to analyze main reasoning failure modes and how often they occur.
mpavlov
·9 месяцев назад·discuss
(author of PokerBattle here)

Haven't seen it before, thanks Are you affiliated with them?
mpavlov
·9 месяцев назад·discuss
(author of PokerBattle here)

I think it would've completely crush them (like any other solver-based solution). Poker is safe for now :)
mpavlov
·9 месяцев назад·discuss
(author of PokerBattle here)

I noticed the same and think that you're absolutely right. I've thought about adding their current hand / draw, but it was too close to the event to test it properly.
mpavlov
·9 месяцев назад·discuss
(author of PokerBattle here)

That’s true. The original goal was to see which model performs statistically better than the others, but I quickly realized that would be neither practical nor particularly entertaining.

A proper benchmark would require things like: - Tens of thousands of hands played - Strict heads-up format (only two models compared at a time) - Each hand played twice with positions swapped

The current setup is mainly useful for observing common reasoning failure modes and how often they occur.
mpavlov
·9 месяцев назад·discuss
(author of PokerBattle here)

That's cool! Do you have a recording of the talk? You can use PokerKit (https://pokerkit.readthedocs.io/en/stable/) for the engine.
mpavlov
·9 месяцев назад·discuss
(author of the PokerBattle here)

Depends on what your goal is, I think.

And it's also a thing — https://huskybench.com/