HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

sielakis

no profile record

comments

sielakis
·6 ay önce·discuss
I know. It was just me being too lazy to write proper prompt.

And code size thing is not fixed by better prompt.

It also likes to even ignore reasonable plan it writen itself just to add more code.
sielakis
·6 ay önce·discuss
The thing is, it still feels like a mixed bag for me.

It's good enough for things I can define well and write okay code for.

But it is far from perfect.

It does too much, like any LLM. For example, I had some test cases for deleted methods, and I was being lazy and didn't want to read a huge test file, so I asked it to fix it.

It did. Tests were green because it mocked non-existing methods, while it should have just deleted the test cases as they were no longer needed.

Luckily, I read the code it produced.

The same thing happened with a bit of decorators I asked it to write in Python. It produced working code, tests were fine, but I reworked the code manually to 1/10 of the size proposed by Opus.

It seems magical, even thinking, but like all LLMs, it is not. It is just a trap.