FYI, Mike Rowe has been financially backed by the Koch brothers, and is a known right-wing commentator. Obviously this is ad hominem, but not necessarily a fallacious one: Context and financial incentives are important, after all.
Being added to the black list makes it harder to do almost everything (including making money), which then means it is very hard to get off the black list. Because of that, I'm not a fan of this system.