HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

jonasmalaco

no profile record

Submissions

A proper open-source modern zip viewer for macOS with quick look support

github.com
2 points·by jonasmalaco·12 ngày trước·0 comments

Show HN: Collect and analyze Postmark Time to Inbox data

github.com
2 points·by jonasmalaco·6 tháng trước·0 comments

comments

jonasmalaco
·4 tháng trước·discuss
Wouldn't the sender be the better judge of the accuracy of what they wanted to communicate? If they feel the LLM version more closely matches their intent, then we should accept it.

There are good arguments to get to know someone "mistakes and all", I just don't think this is a particularly good one. No matter how much you (think) you know someone, they probably know them(selves) better.
jonasmalaco
·8 tháng trước·discuss
Currently blocked in Brazil, 49/50 pings return 403/forbidden: https://globalping.io/?measurement=2acUvndlTojar3qy80001zLzv
jonasmalaco
·năm ngoái·discuss
The intent behind these mentions was to "promote the use of Copilot" and "showcase Copilot usage scenarios in a variety of different ways".

These are quotes from resolved comments in the review to a similar but slightly earlier PR[1], from the same author, to the one that introduced the specific mention referred to in the issue[2].

And that's why these suggestions to use Copilot probably don't belong in the docs: their intent was to promote a product.

(To be fair, in the first comment quoted above the reviewer asks that the Copilot section be moved to the end of the document, prioritizing teaching the user about the actual feature the article was about).

One additional problem, already pointed out by others, is that Copilot seems to be the only AI tool showcased in the docs. Besides suggesting the intent of these suggestions is purely promotional, this reflects poorly on an organization that should be independent from Microsoft.

[1] https://github.com/dotnet/docs/pull/42357 [2] https://github.com/dotnet/docs/pull/42625