I made a competitor to GitHubs UI for Pull Requests (codeapprove.com)
It’s built in Vue. My first 5 or 6 attempts at writing the diff viewer were very slow when things got big. I optimized this a lot and now I’m pretty proud of how snappy it is.
I’m not saying this as a plug (this is mostly a passion project not a big business) but to say that it’s possible to make a snappy GitHub PR UI using a frontend framework on top of GitHub’s own APIs. You just have to care. It’s not clear that they care.
You would be surprised! I have encountered the attitude that code reviews are a waste of time. It's not common, and I have never seen this attitude "win" across a team/company but it definitely exists. Some engineers are just overconfident, they believe they could fix everything if everyone would just let them code.
Shameless plug but since you asked ... CodeApprove (https://codeapprove.com) is probably the closest thing you can get to Critique on GitHub. It doesn't help with the Piper/CitC/Code Search parts though, and I agree those were excellent.
I’m biased (I created https://codeapprove.com) but I think GitHub has let code review lag so far behind the rest of the platform. They’ve done a lot of work on project management, CI, discussions, and code authoring but code review has been the same for about 10 years.
Tools like Graphite, CodePeer, Codelantis (and of course CodeApprove) make it so much easier to have a meaningful discussion on a PR. Making sure every thread comes to resolution, knowing whose turn it is, having a fast way to navigate between code and comments, etc. The FAANG companies all have this kind of thing built in house because good code review is a key part of building high quality large software projects.
It’s built in Vue. My first 5 or 6 attempts at writing the diff viewer were very slow when things got big. I optimized this a lot and now I’m pretty proud of how snappy it is.
I’m not saying this as a plug (this is mostly a passion project not a big business) but to say that it’s possible to make a snappy GitHub PR UI using a frontend framework on top of GitHub’s own APIs. You just have to care. It’s not clear that they care.