Ask HN: Is commercial nuclear fusion feasible in the near future?

2 pointsby astdbقبل 8 سنوات5 comments

5 comments

nukenukeقبل 8 سنوات

Not really, depending on what method is used there are several outstanding issues: Assuming magnetic plasma confinement: - plasma stability issues: it is not really know how to maintain a stable plasma in an energy efficient way that can maintain a reaction that produces a net positive energy generation. When hearing about interesting exotic fusion reactors, one should wonder about the plasma stability (ie the plasma goes into a failure mode and hits the wall or leaks out of the confinement). - materials issues: the materials don’t really exist that can sustain extended periods of radiation damage. This is also a limiter in many exotic fission reactor designs.

Laser confinement also has some issues.

So conceptually we know it should work but maybe a couple of the needed technologies are not ready. This is similar to Leonardo da Vinci knowing that helicopters should be possible in the 1400s but many of the required supporting technologies weren’t ready.

plasticchrisقبل 8 سنوات

Technically it has been feasible for some time, the challenges are really political and social. I switched majors away from nuclear engineering when I realized that; political problems are not my thing.

tlbقبل 8 سنوات

Which fusion technology do you think is most promising, if all the sociopolitical problems could be overcome? How much would it cost to make it happen?

plasticchrisقبل 8 سنوات

Oh I misread this as fission. Sorry about that.

db48xقبل 8 سنوات

We don't even know if it's possible to build any fusion plant smaller than a star, let alone if it's possible to run one at a profit.