Built a new version of HN/Reddit
7 comments
You got one Upvote here. Shame.
I think the problem with HN and Reddit is that votes are based on a post agreeing with the voter's side of an argument, and not on a post containing supported facts relevant to the argument.
It means those relevant facts are suppressed not encouraged, and means the whole discussion is not about finding out more about an argument, but finding out how many people in HN/Reddit support one or the other side of an argument. The former is interesting and should be useful to everyone. The latter is useful to almost no-one.
I think the problem with HN and Reddit is that votes are based on a post agreeing with the voter's side of an argument, and not on a post containing supported facts relevant to the argument.
It means those relevant facts are suppressed not encouraged, and means the whole discussion is not about finding out more about an argument, but finding out how many people in HN/Reddit support one or the other side of an argument. The former is interesting and should be useful to everyone. The latter is useful to almost no-one.
I agree to some of that, however I think room could be built to change the way people use the Vote system. Our aim is to use it to showcase the best of the internet content first... what people are really enjoying, trending, looking at.
We don't have a messed up algorithm that puts what we want Infront of people, it is done by our users through key engagement.
We don't have a messed up algorithm that puts what we want Infront of people, it is done by our users through key engagement.
A mod here told me that he thought users should vote down facts they disagree with.
That attitude is bad for society, let alone this forum.
That attitude is bad for society, let alone this forum.
Yes, it looks nice. The only problem is it's entering a pretty crowded field, especially with the growing Fediverse options.
Thank you very much for your lovely feedback, we understand the field is crowded however we push to keep everyone happy, we are implementing new features that are Suttle and support the site growth. We urge people to maybe try it for a couple of weeks and see what they think to things like user experience.
Please contact me for some feedback. I've got some ideas I'd like to share.
hn @ username .com
Thanks.
hn @ username .com
Thanks.
sorry, if you want to get in touch head over to the site and comment on one of my posts will talk through that if you want.
What it does:
Submit links or text posts
Vote on content (upvotes only, no downvotes)
Comment with nested threading
Dark mode with pure black OLED-friendly theme
Mobile-optimized with floating action button
Vote points system for engagement
Tech stack:
PHP 8.3 + SQLite (keeping it simple)
Vanilla CSS with CSS variables for theming
No frameworks – just clean, fast HTML/CSS/JS
Responsive design with 640px breakpoint
Design philosophy:
Flat design, no shadows or gradients
Solid colors only for performance
Instant theme switching with localStorage
Cross-browser compatible (Chrome, Safari, Firefox, Edge)
Current status:
Fully functional with ~8 users and 26 posts in first 24 hours
38% creator ratio (users actually posting, not just lurking)
Moderation dashboard for community management
I'm particularly proud of the dark mode implementation – it loads instantly without flash and uses transparent post backgrounds for a modern look.
Looking for feedback on:
Overall UX/UI impressions
Any bugs or issues you spot
Feature suggestions
Demo: upvote.social