HackerTrans
TopNewTrendsCommentsPastAskShowJobs

obi1kenobi

no profile record

comments

obi1kenobi
·قبل شهرين·discuss
It's not self-cancellation in the way you're interpreting the title :)
obi1kenobi
·قبل شهرين·discuss
Author here. This! The point isn't to name and shame, but to illustrate a complex failure mode. I too could see myself writing this bug!
obi1kenobi
·قبل شهرين·discuss
Hi! Author here. You're right — but two things to consider here.

First, that quote is referring to human-made systems, not natural ones (as is the rest of the essay!) and I think our views align on whether human systems regularly work.

Second, natural systems (and all complex-enough systems) are always running in some degraded fashion. So what "working" means is ambiguous: they are broken, yet accomplishing the goal. The quote from the essay refers to "working" in the "free of faults" sense, in which I again think our views align.
obi1kenobi
·قبل 4 سنوات·discuss
Interesting detail I wasn't familiar with, and very unfortunate. I know I wouldn't have been happy to be put in that situation :(

It was published on Nov 11, 2021 so perhaps consider a (2021) tag in the submission title?