> Jeff was micromanaging her citation list, which is almost unheard of
This is quite normal, even for purely technical papers [^1], and absolutely important for an expository paper like this one. Narratives are always formed by selectively including references.
> the entire AI community is now on her side
On the MachineLearning reddit, which is popular among a proportion of ML grad students at least, it's completely different. Indeed the top comment in the discussion thread there [^2] discusses this discrepancy. And the fact that I'm creating a throwaway account for this reply is telling.
[1]: The review process of ICLR 2021, a premier ML conference, is taking place on public at https://openreview.net/group?id=ICLR.cc/2021/Conference. You can navigate through the reviews and see how many requests are wrt citations.
This is quite normal, even for purely technical papers [^1], and absolutely important for an expository paper like this one. Narratives are always formed by selectively including references.
> the entire AI community is now on her side
On the MachineLearning reddit, which is popular among a proportion of ML grad students at least, it's completely different. Indeed the top comment in the discussion thread there [^2] discusses this discrepancy. And the fact that I'm creating a throwaway account for this reply is telling.
[1]: The review process of ICLR 2021, a premier ML conference, is taking place on public at https://openreview.net/group?id=ICLR.cc/2021/Conference. You can navigate through the reviews and see how many requests are wrt citations.
[2]: https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/k6467v/n_t...