A Harry Potter Trivia Bot, Powered by GPT-3(introductory.medium.com)
introductory.medium.com
A Harry Potter Trivia Bot, Powered by GPT-3
https://introductory.medium.com/a-harry-potter-trivia-bot-powered-by-gpt-3-b9607d93efd1
Over winter break I resurfaced an old project, a harry potter trivia bot. I rebuilt it using generative models instead of the extractive ones I had used previously. The generative approach was far easier to implement and performed better. Cheers.
11 comments
Q: Does Harry Potter have an even number of hairs on his head, or odd?
A: Odd
Q: What is Harry Potter's favorite planet? A: Mars
Q: Does Harry Potter prefer Windows 3.1, or Windows 95? A: Windows 3.1
So, yes, it's pretty cool. And caltonji is very up-front that his GPT-3 model read the internet, not the Harry Potter books. But it seems to have the same big conceptual / awareness blind spots that ~all "AI" has.
(cantonji - it took quite a while to answer that last question. Apologies if I dinged your budget.)
Q: What is Harry Potter's favorite planet? A: Mars
Q: Does Harry Potter prefer Windows 3.1, or Windows 95? A: Windows 3.1
So, yes, it's pretty cool. And caltonji is very up-front that his GPT-3 model read the internet, not the Harry Potter books. But it seems to have the same big conceptual / awareness blind spots that ~all "AI" has.
(cantonji - it took quite a while to answer that last question. Apologies if I dinged your budget.)
Lol no it’s all good. Costs are still under $1 overall, but they may be rate limiting me because I see some requests take 5 seconds or more.
It says "Ask a Trivia Question about Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone", so my question was "What was this book called in the UK?". Some basic trivia there, but pretty much my speed. The answer it gave was "Quidditch Through the Ages", which I'm fairly sure (again, no expert) is wrong.
A couple of ones it got wrong
"What is Hagrid's coat made out of?" - "Beaver fur"
"What does Harry Potter's seventeenth birthday cake resemble?" -- "Harry Potter's seventeenth birthday cake was designed to look like a red and gold Gryffindor scarf. "
"did Harry give Ron liquid luck before their quidditch match?" -- "Yes, Harry gave Ron Felix Felicis, or liquid luck, before their quidditch match."
The last one is interesting because it seems to get most of the "plot" questions correct, but failed that one.
"What is Hagrid's coat made out of?" - "Beaver fur"
"What does Harry Potter's seventeenth birthday cake resemble?" -- "Harry Potter's seventeenth birthday cake was designed to look like a red and gold Gryffindor scarf. "
"did Harry give Ron liquid luck before their quidditch match?" -- "Yes, Harry gave Ron Felix Felicis, or liquid luck, before their quidditch match."
The last one is interesting because it seems to get most of the "plot" questions correct, but failed that one.
A few more interesting ones...
Q: J.K. Rowling intended Quiddich to be a satire of what real-world English sport? A: Soccer
(If you change the question to "...sports?", it adds rugby and cricket - the latter two strike me as far more plausible answers. Even polo seems easy to argue than soccer. Though...given the English-centric context of the books, why did it say "soccer" and not "football"?)
Q: Which English King did Nicholas Flamel kill in battle in 1485? A: King Richard III
(That I know of, there is nothing whatever in real history nor even Harry Potter fanfiction which might connect Nicholas Flamel with the real-world death of Richard III at the Battle of Bosworth Field. More amusingly - if you delete the "in 1485", it answers "Vortigern". The latter was a likely-mythical English warlord of the 5th century - about 900 years before the supposed birth of Nicholas Flamel. From a quick skim of the Voltigern Wikipedia page, there is no hint of his dying in battle.)
Q: Was orphaned Harry Potter dumped on the doorstep of his mother's sister because his birth was not legitimate? A: No, Harry Potter was left with his aunt and uncle because his parents were killed by Lord Voldemort.
(Clearly the model has no conception (pun intended) of the human social concepts of bastardy, legitimate birth, etc. Nor history of those in Britain. Nor of the clear & demonstrative symbolism of placing a bastard with its mother's birth family and cutting off all contact with the family, friends, social circle, etc. of the biological father.)
Q: J.K. Rowling intended Quiddich to be a satire of what real-world English sport? A: Soccer
(If you change the question to "...sports?", it adds rugby and cricket - the latter two strike me as far more plausible answers. Even polo seems easy to argue than soccer. Though...given the English-centric context of the books, why did it say "soccer" and not "football"?)
Q: Which English King did Nicholas Flamel kill in battle in 1485? A: King Richard III
(That I know of, there is nothing whatever in real history nor even Harry Potter fanfiction which might connect Nicholas Flamel with the real-world death of Richard III at the Battle of Bosworth Field. More amusingly - if you delete the "in 1485", it answers "Vortigern". The latter was a likely-mythical English warlord of the 5th century - about 900 years before the supposed birth of Nicholas Flamel. From a quick skim of the Voltigern Wikipedia page, there is no hint of his dying in battle.)
Q: Was orphaned Harry Potter dumped on the doorstep of his mother's sister because his birth was not legitimate? A: No, Harry Potter was left with his aunt and uncle because his parents were killed by Lord Voldemort.
(Clearly the model has no conception (pun intended) of the human social concepts of bastardy, legitimate birth, etc. Nor history of those in Britain. Nor of the clear & demonstrative symbolism of placing a bastard with its mother's birth family and cutting off all contact with the family, friends, social circle, etc. of the biological father.)
This is fun! But I'm a pretty big HP fan and a lot of the answers are flat wrong.
Q: What type of potion did Malfoy steal from Professor Slughorn?
A: Felix Felicis (Liquid Luck). (Wrong, he stole polyjuice potion to disguise Crabbe and Goyle.)
Q: The entrance hall of The Ministry of Magic is lined with what?
A: Talking statues of the Ministry's previous Heads of Department. (Wrong, it's fireplaces connected to the Floo network)
Q: What type of potion did Malfoy steal from Professor Slughorn?
A: Felix Felicis (Liquid Luck). (Wrong, he stole polyjuice potion to disguise Crabbe and Goyle.)
Q: The entrance hall of The Ministry of Magic is lined with what?
A: Talking statues of the Ministry's previous Heads of Department. (Wrong, it's fireplaces connected to the Floo network)
This is neat. Would love to know how to make things like this offline apps where the knowledge base is relatively static - this kind of thing would be fun to deploy as a little webapp or client application for kids where you don't have to think about cloud budgets blowing up if something goes awry.
The accuracy on the few queries you tried is awesome! Have you come across any instances of the model hallucinating answers?
"does Harry Potter's mom know he's gay?"