Peer review by committee? New journal rethinks old model(nature.com)
nature.com
Peer review by committee? New journal rethinks old model
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-03039-4
3 comments
I'm all for this sort of experiment and wish them the best with it.
Just gonna leave this line here though:
> We’ve had to cap the number of reviewers on each article at seven, because that’s what our software can handle.
Maybe I can get an article published on 4 bit arithmetic? It'll be a significant breakthrough.
Just gonna leave this line here though:
> We’ve had to cap the number of reviewers on each article at seven, because that’s what our software can handle.
Maybe I can get an article published on 4 bit arithmetic? It'll be a significant breakthrough.
Also, I’m realizing that it would be pretty nice to be able to push back on the classic Reviewer 2 behavior before the authors have to deal with it