Why hasn't Whoop's success been replicated?
Whoop seems to be the buzz word these days. The whole concepts seems interesting but rather expensive. Given that you can buy a smart watch for as low as $50, why would someone spend ~$30 a month for a subscription? Is there no other equivalent sleep tracker which always captures key metrics like HRV.
2 comments
Whoop targets a pretty solid demographic of people who seem to want an auxillary training coach (the app tells you when to go to sleep) and don't want a typical smartwatch experience.
I'm not sure where modern smartwatches stand in terms of accurate readings but if I remember correctly it is still a minefield of inaccuracies. A watch for 50 dollars will _probably_ not do as well at reading your vitals as a watch for 200-500 dollars. Given Whoop markets itself as backed by science and seems to take the lead in studies on accurate heart rate readings[1].
Couple the above with great marketing and a decent kit of software and you have a difficult champion to dethrone. Hardware is expensive, marketing is difficult, a good app is hard to make, and putting together all three at once _while_ fighting a niche market is a struggle!
While 30/month can be difficult to swallow for someone that runs or swims as a casual hobby, someone that already pays hundreds a month for equipment, coaching, gym memberships, can have an easier time justifying it.
[1]: https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/22/16/6317
I'm not sure where modern smartwatches stand in terms of accurate readings but if I remember correctly it is still a minefield of inaccuracies. A watch for 50 dollars will _probably_ not do as well at reading your vitals as a watch for 200-500 dollars. Given Whoop markets itself as backed by science and seems to take the lead in studies on accurate heart rate readings[1].
Couple the above with great marketing and a decent kit of software and you have a difficult champion to dethrone. Hardware is expensive, marketing is difficult, a good app is hard to make, and putting together all three at once _while_ fighting a niche market is a struggle!
While 30/month can be difficult to swallow for someone that runs or swims as a casual hobby, someone that already pays hundreds a month for equipment, coaching, gym memberships, can have an easier time justifying it.
[1]: https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/22/16/6317
[deleted]