New Dell XPS 13 developer edition now available(bartongeorge.io)

488 pointsby sahaskatta7 anni fa472 comments

New Dell XPS 13 developer edition now available

https://bartongeorge.io/2019/01/23/the-new-dell-xps-13-developer-edition-now-available-in-the-us-europe-and-canada/

481 comments

Wonderful! I was excited when they announced they had finally moved the camera to the top, and was hoping for a Dev Ed soon. Didn't expect it so quickly! Good job Barton & team!

Weight-wise, it's under the Macbook Air... Feature-wise (and pricewise), it's closer to the MBP.

Starting weights:

  * XPS13: 2.7lbs/1.23kg
  * MBA: 2.75lbs/1.25kg
  * MBP (13.3"): 3.02lbs/1.37kg

Screen resolution:

  * XPS13: 13.3" 3840x2160 (or 1920x1080)
  * MBA: 13.3" 2560x1600
  * MBP: 13.3" 2560x1600

Ports:

  * XPS13: 3xUSB-C 3.1 (TB3, PD, DP USB3.1 Gen??), headset, MicroSD
  * MBA: 2xUSB-C 3.1 (TB3, PD, DP, USB3.1 Gen2), headset
  * MBP: 4xUSB-C 3.1 (TB3, PD, DP, USB3.1 Gen2), headset

And pricing (for closest equivalent HW I could find, not quite equal, XPS with 4k screen, 8GB RAM, 256 SSD):

  * XPS13: i7-8565U (GPU Intel UHD 620): $1590 (+tax)
  * MBA: i5-8210Y (?) (GPU Intel UHD 617): $1400 (+tax)
  * MBP (no Touch Bar): I5-7360U [1] (GPU Intel UHD 640): $1500 (+tax)

And with 16GB Ram, 512 SSD (max for XPS13):

  * XPS13: $1840
  * MBA: $1800
  * MBP (no TB): $1900

[1] https://everymac.com/systems/apple/macbook_pro/specs/macbook...

zapnuk7 anni fa

German prices are (512GB SSD, 16GB Ram, i7, UDH):

* XPS13 - Ubuntu: 1599€ / 1819$

* XPS13 - Windows: 1729€ / 1967$

* MBA - i5 - 2089€ / 2377$

* MBP - i5 - 2489€ / 2832$

* MBP - i7 - 2849€ / 3242$

Entry models (256GB, 8GB, i5): * XPS13 - Ubuntu - HD : 1289€ / 1467$, has a i7 instead of an i5 !?!

* XPS13 - Windows - HD: 1309€ / 1490$

* XPS13 - Windows - UHD: 1479€ / 1683$

* MBA - i5 - 1599€ / 1820$

* MBP - i5 - 1999€ / 2275$

* MBP - i7 - 2359€ / 2685$

I noticed that dell doesn't offer customization. They have many different configurations but some combinations are missing e.g. no 256-16-UHD option.

That being said I find it difficult to rationalize Apple's prices. I'd like to replace my ancient MBA but I'm not willing to pay 400€ for their new MBA, just to get an inferior CPU. Not to mention the huge price difference for higher-end configurations.

I'd be very interested how well dell notebooks last - do they have similar 'design flaws' as the current gen Apple notebooks (keyboard, display cable)?

Illotus7 anni fa

> I'd be very interested how well dell notebooks last - do they have similar 'design flaws' as the current gen Apple notebooks (keyboard, display cable)

I have 9360, it has pretty annoying coil whine. The touchpad has some play which is extremely annoying, for almost a year I always used a trackball instead. Now I've gotten used to it somewhat, but still it irks me every day when I have to use it. Headset port stopped recognizing dedicated microphones at some point, probably some driver/software problem on the Windows side.

For work it is okay and I chose it basically because the Macbook Pros of the time already had the horrible keyboards and touchbar. In retrospect I should have gone with Lenovo, at least their keyboards are much better and they have actual docks, which are very convenient for work. Touchpads are still crap, though they may have improved since T440s.

Compared to the late 2013 Macbook Pro I have the MBP has better hardware, but I prefer Windows and Linux to OSX.

Macha7 anni fa

Irish prices:

(512GB SSD, 16GB Ram, i7, UDH)

* XPS13 - Ubuntu: €1820

* XPS13 - Windows: €1899

* MBA - i5: €2119

* MBP - i5: €2589

* MBP - i7: €2949

Entry model (256GB, 8GB, i5):

* XPS13 - Ubuntu - HD (with i7): €1429

* XPS13 - Ubuntu - UHD: Not offered in this config

* XPS13 - Windows - HD (with i7): €1399

* XPS13 - Windows - UHD: €1599

* MBA - i5: €1629

* MBP - i5: €1800

* MBP - i7: €2159

Apple is a bit more competitive here, mostly because Dell raised their prices, though interestingly the high end Apple options cost more here and the low end Apple options cost less.

My current laptop is a 2017 XPS 15. The Windows wifi drivers were rubbish on launch, but they finally patched it early last year. Durability wise it's been fine (Though not yet at usage levels of lifespan that I can say much about long term wear), as were my previous Dell laptops (An Inspiron and XPS Studio in the 2000s)

caf7 anni fa

I'd be very interested how well dell notebooks last - do they have similar 'design flaws' as the current gen Apple notebooks (keyboard, display cable)?

It's just one data point, but I have an XPS 13 model 9350 that's now 3 years old (used daily) and I haven't had any faults develop yet.

beanjammin7 anni fa

Another data point, I have an XPS13 L322X that's a couple months shy of 6 years old that's also been a daily driver. I've replaced the battery, but it has otherwise stood up surprisingly well. I was amazed when I looked up how old it is.

I'll pass it onto the kids once I get one of these shiny new ones and will be replacing the keyboard and fan when I do. Some of the plastic covering on a few of the keys is starting to come off and the fan bearings are starting to go so sometimes it's louder than it ought to be.

halbritt7 anni fa

I have an XPS15 that's almost two years old at this point. It doesn't have the same flaws as an MBP but overall I feel like it may be slightly less durable.

The screen isn't covered with Gorilla Glass and gets marked up the way Macbooks used to. The monitor hinge has a little slack in it and the power connector is a bit loose.

The trackpad has been surprisingly good. The keyboard is decent. I also like the fact that I was able to swap in 32GB of memory and an NVME SSD of the make and model of my choice.

Mine came with a Fujitsu SSD, I think. I swapped in a much larger Samsung 960 Pro. I've ordered several of these for others and they all came with a Samsung OEM unit of equivalent performance.

In summary, the hardware doesn't suck and it runs Linux, which is the best part.

greenhatman7 anni fa

I'm really excited to see what the next XPS 15 will look like.

halbritt7 anni fa

Rumor is that it's a slightly reworked 9570 with a really nice screen. Comes out in March.

ayoisaiah7 anni fa

My XPS 13 9360 QHD has shown no signs of letting up since I purchased it in the middle of last year. It's been a fantastic machine for me.

na857 anni fa

My wife's XPS has been rock solid.

sammorrowdrums7 anni fa

I love my 9360 UHD I just upgraded to latest Elementary OS (Ubuntu 18.04). I have used it as my main machine for 2 years.

It runs really well, there's a minor issue with the touchpad but it does still work well enough that I haven't done anything about it.

Dell continue to push out firmware updates. I bought a USB-C monitor (that acts as a USB-A hub) and I power it via that.

Screen is beautiful, of course in certain light conditions the gloss is a negative, but it looks beautiful often and has great brightness.

My next laptop will either be a System76 or another XPS Developer Edition. I really appreciate what they have done.

[deleted]7 anni fa

Tepix7 anni fa

If you choose the non touchbar 13" rMBP the German prices are:

512GB/16GB i5 2239€ 512GB/16GB i7 2599€

tinus_hn7 anni fa

How is it possible in Germany the Macbook Pro is 50% more expensive than the XPS13, while the parent has the Macbook Pro cheaper than the XPS13?

Are you looking at the same thing?

akoncius7 anni fa

keep in mind that in eu usually people are getting prices after import tax, vat tax. AFAIK US prices everywhere are listed before taxes.

Macha7 anni fa

Tax on a Dell laptop (manufactured in China, sold by a US company) is not different to tax on an Apple laptop (manufactured in China, sold by a US company)

vinay4277 anni fa

To clarify, US prices include import tariffs and all other federal taxes, but not state taxes (sales tax, CA recycling fee when applicable, etc.).

anotheryou7 anni fa

I got two and several problems (spread evenly between both):

bt didn't work with wifi, changed the wifi card, but still troubles

weird display dimming when reading white on black and no official patch (can link you an unofficial one)

coil whine

speaker blown (don't eq them)

battery bloated (replaced for free even out of warranty)

hard to get to sleep

very short screws, can get lost if you don't use lock tight after opening it once

claytonjy7 anni fa

Great, effort-intensive comment.

I was starting to regret my recent-ish purchase of a System76...until I saw even this new XPS maxed out at 16Gib. I specifically bought my Galaga Pro because it was the only 32GiB + matte-screen (well, not _that_ matte) laptop I could find, though it was a bit more expensive than this new XPS.

If you're looking, I think its great, though one big bummer is there's no good dock (single-connection, 2x2k displayport out), in part because its USB-C can't charge it. I literally have 6 things I plug into it at work each morning (power, keyboard, mouse, headphones, HDMI monitor, miniDP monitor). Some docks would cut that down, but I feel like if I can't get down to 1 it's not worth it.

Daneel_7 anni fa

For what it's worth, the T-Series Lenovo laptops can take 32GB and have matte screen options. I'm using a W-series at the moment that has a matte screen, and it can take 64GB, with the latest one taking up to 128.

The W-series isn't nearly as sleek as the XPS, although the T-series ones are looking pretty good these days!

weitzj7 anni fa

Be aware: only the T series without the ‘s’, e.g.:

T450 (has 2 dimm slots) but not T450s (smaller, has 1 dimm slot + 1 soldered module)

4= display size (14’) 5= cpu generation (here: Broadwell)

So an equivalent to the new XPS would be a

T480 T480s

Thunderbolt is only available from T470 onwards (not in the x270)

The Reddit ThinkPad forum is your friend here.

MisterOctober7 anni fa

T-series are great machines. Even the old T520 can do 16gb, which is pretty good for a unit you can get under $200

halbritt7 anni fa

Maybe not an option for all, but for everyone on my team, we ordered the least memory available (8GB) and swapped in 32GB of memory for less money than the 16GB unit.

I also swapped the Killer wireless for an Intel unit.

analognoise7 anni fa

I bought a System76 with a stuck pixel. It never went away, and they wouldn't do anything about it.

I've never bought anything from them since.

b3b0p7 anni fa

It's a good comparison, but I feel the best comparison is not to a MacBook Pro or Air, but to the Thinkpad X1 Carbon or X280. I haven't used either the Dell, Thinkpad, or the MacBook Air, but I do have the MacBook Pro. I'm mostly concerned about build quality. My experience with Dell is they feel cheap while my last Thinkpad was a tank and I miss it (I ran FreeBSD on it) and loved the nub and keyboard and overall feel.

krn7 anni fa

I agree. Dell XPS 13 is a direct competitor to Lenovo Thinkpad X1 Carbon[1], and is inferior in almost every way (build quality, port selection, keyboard, and screen). In my opinion, Macbooks stand on their own: you either want MacOS with the entire Apple's ecosystem, or you don't.

[1] https://www.notebookcheck.net/Lenovo-ThinkPad-X1-Carbon-2018...

Ayyar7 anni fa

Macbook Pro to X1 Carbon convert.

I could not disagree more with you as a developer.

- The X1 Carbon lets me use Nvidia GPUs using an eGPU.

- It has a much, much better keyboard. On my MBP, I hit this problem: https://youtu.be/4QDsqWkUvXQ

- The high end models don't force you to get a touchbar.

- I love having more port diversity and number of slots vs. the MBP. No dongle life for me.

- As an added bonus, I got the X1 Carbon Yoga, which has an OLED display. The display is gorgeous with fabulously dark blacks.

The one thing that I miss from the Macbook pro is it has a much better trackpad. But overall, I am very happy with the switch, and it's overly simplistic to just say "Macbooks stand on their own".

Though overall, I couldn't be happier with the switch.

Daneel_7 anni fa

Interesting - I read the parent comment as saying that the XPS was inferior to the X1, not the other way around.

I completely agree that the lenovo is a better laptop, for similar reasons to the ones you've mentioned.

I think the 'Macbooks stand on their own' comment is more along the lines of "you either operate in the macOS space, or the 'everything else' space. There isn't much crossover due to the large shift in workflow between macOS and windows". This rings true for me - I have the option of using a mac for work, but I prefer to run windows on a lenovo because the hardware is just better. I can deal with windows 10's quirks, and I just run a VM for all my linux needs - no half-assing it with the BSD terminal in macOS.

aptwebapps7 anni fa

I think you may have misread? GP said that the XPS is inferior to the Carbon and that Macs were in a different category because of the OS and ecosystem and therefore not directly comparable.

auggierose7 anni fa

So, how does iOS development work for you on the X1?

lugg7 anni fa

It works fine [1]. But if that was important what does the hardware matter?

Besides that, how does linux work on your macbook?

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/thinkpad/comments/92unvp/my_guide_f...

auggierose7 anni fa

Hackintosh is not an option for the serious developer.

lugg7 anni fa

Neither is a mac.

geoelectric7 anni fa

Yet Macs are overwhelmingly popular in Silicon Valley software companies--to the point where devs not using Windows has become a quality/dogfooding issue for multiplatform apps. Maybe it's because nowadays the platform you code on doesn't really matter if you're not a native app developer?

I think Google has swung more towards Linux laptops, but honestly, this, the T or X series from Lenovo, maybe System76 are the only realistic choices I see there personally. And at the end of the day, Linux and Mac offer pretty similar programming experiences.

johnsea7 anni fa

...or you want no longer due to keyboard etc. and have the option to move (to Linux).

[deleted]7 anni fa

killjoywashere7 anni fa

If I recall, the OpenBSD developers mainly use the ThinkPad X1 Carbon.

While I understand the merits of supporting everyone's toaster, it would be nice to see an unofficial truce around a couple of key laptop models. If I could get a ThinkPad X1 Carbon or a Dell XPS13 and absolutely know it would work, I would seriously consider moving on from my launch-day original 2012 rMBP. Unfortunately, that's still the best available option for someone who's primary job is something other than writing code but writes code and admins servers sometimes.

walterbell7 anni fa

QubesOS developers use X1 Carbon.

dlgeek7 anni fa

I have one 2 generations behind (XPS 13 9360) and I have to tell you your fears are completely justified. I was a long-time Thinkpad user (had a Z-series, T42, X1 carbon) but switched because the screen was just so pretty. While I was initially very happy, I've had tons of issues around both the build quality and support.

When my machine started refusing to charge, my "next day on-site service" extended warranty turned into "you called 20 minutes too late, so it's actually in 2 days" and then "Oh, while we confirmed the appointment time with you, we never did with the tech, we'll find out when they're coming" and then "Oh yeah, they're not actually coming today, you have to take another day off work too". Then, after the tech managed to replace my main board without any ESD protection and it started completely hard locking up every 5 minutes (even in their own diagnostic tool and the EFI setup tool) it took me several days worth of phone calls and emails before they swapped it out.

Of course, about a year later, I started having problems with the SECOND laptop they'd sent me and had to send it back to have parts replaced. A few months later, right after the warranty expired, the screen started going crazy. I've found the right place to hit it to fix it whenever that happens (about once a month).

Next machine I get, I'm going back to an X1 Carbon.

turndown7 anni fa

FWIW, I have a 2015 Dell XPS 15 that had the battery start to swell(making the trackpad unusable), I did not get next day service but was able to schedule an appointment where the tech came and fixed it, no charge. All in all I don't regret my purchase and would buy again, I think the screen is still amazing and nobody else seems to want to challenge Dell in the niche they've made.

johnsea7 anni fa

I leaned to the Thinkpad X1 Carbon initially but then bought the T480s (i5, 16 GB/24 GB later, 1 TB). Works nicely (so far;)). The XPS 13 is certainly a nice machine also.

fdm7 anni fa

MBP with no Touch Bar only has two USB ports. More importantly though, the XPS13 has a quad-core CPU, while the others are only dual-core.

cpmsmith7 anni fa

A 4K 13-inch display feels like absurd overkill to me. Am I in the minority on that?

apcragg7 anni fa

I have the older 13" 3200x1800 screen and it is amazing. I put Ubuntu 18.04 on it since it wasn't available as a developer edition. The display scaling is my only problem but that's more a gnome thing. Running it with Windows was a almost perfect (why, Xilinx can you not do display scaling...). I thought I wouldn't notice the extra resolution due to the small screen but it both looks really nice for text and allows me to scale everything slightly smaller so that I can fit more on my screen for productivity. That being said, I use it as a laptop, on my lap. The extra resolution is pretty useless if I'm using it on a desk or table. But for that I have an XPS15 + 27" 4K setup.

AsyncAwait7 anni fa

As far as I know GNOME can do display scaling, but not fractional display scaling yet.

apcragg7 anni fa

Yeah that's the problem. 2x is too big and 1x is too small on 3200x1800. Luckily there's a workaround to scale text to 1.5x which for most purposes is fine.

Tepix7 anni fa

I like 2x scale on the XPS 13 9350 (with 3200x1800). It results in a super sharp 1600x900 which is ideal for the 13.3" screen site.

heywire7 anni fa

Give KDE Neon a try. I use it as my daily driver on a Latitude 7370 with the 3200x1800 display.

mikekchar7 anni fa

4K displays eat batteries (at least driving them). I'm very nomadic in my usage and I want a computer that I can do 8 hours of work on a single charge if I have to. Pretty much impossible with a 4K display, so I've gotten used to lower resolutions. Since I have vision issues (eye strain triggers ocular migraines), I usually have a massive font -- imagine full screening a console with only 32 lines of text. In that configuration, 4K is definitely overkill because there is very little difference to see. If you are young, with super power vision (like some people I know), I think it would make a pretty big difference in really tiny fonts and might be worth the power price. However, I think if I were going that route, I would be getting a 15" not a 13" -- I can't really see the advantage of the smaller format if you are tying yourself to a power cord anyway.

tommica7 anni fa

I'm curious, what machine are you using to achieve those? And do you have some special applications to help you in doing what you do?

mikekchar7 anni fa

Currently have a Toshiba KIRA V63, which unfortunately I think was only available in Japan. Basically i5 processor with 8 gigs of memory, SSD, integrated Intel graphics. The main power saving tool is Powertop. However, I run Arch and do not install GNOME, or KDE. I've got Xmonad for a window manager and I'm usually using Kitty as a terminal emulator. Work requires me to run Chromium (I write internal web systems for a travel tour company, and we deploy to Chrome, so I only need to make sure it works on that platform). I'm mostly spending my time in tmux with Emacs (in Evil mode).

I'm pretty careful about turning everything off -- for example bluetooth, etc. For maximum power savings I use a very high contrast colour scheme and turn the backlight down using xblacklight. Indoors, in the library for instance, I can happily turn it down to 7-11%. Outdoors, I usually need 70%. If I'm on the train or bus (I often work on the go), then I'm usually about 20%. The backlight is really the biggest thing to consider. It helps to spend some time in Powertop and see what's draining the battery.

Another important thing is that I run as little disk access as possible. Even with only 8 gigs of memory, I have no swap partition or swap file. I try to stay out of the browser and do as much as possible with TDD -- files will be cached by the OS. As much as possible I have no VMs running (obviously with the lack of memory) and as we've pretty much moved over to Docker this has helped out.

Apart from that I'm pretty anal about my machine. I don't allow anything to run that I'm not completely aware of. I've got a processor monitor running and if I notice it spike when I'm not doing anything, I track down what's going on. Same thing with memory.

Ah.. One more thing. I almost always have the WIFI turned off, unless I'm actually communicating with someone. I tend to work using pomodoros and spend 5 minutes every half an hour checking my email, etc. But I try to keep offline documentation, etc available.

I'm going to be replacing this machine soon (I think it's 3-4 years old now). I'll probably end up buying the V63's replacement (I forget the model number). It's supposed to have about 10% more battery, so I'm looking forward to seeing if I can relax some of my habits. If I'm not grinding the machine too much I can usually get 9-10 hours. However some days I only manage 6, which is a pain.

hellcow7 anni fa

Agreed. I would have preferred a 2K screen, but I needed the better specs of the 4K model, and in practice having 4K didn't affect me. With TLP I get 8-10 hours of battery life on Ubuntu with the 4K display, and Ubuntu/Gnome handles the high DPI well.

What does affect me is the glossy display...

mikekchar7 anni fa

Do you actually get 8-10 hours of working battery life with that? If so, that's amazing to me. What do you use for backlight percentage?

hellcow7 anni fa

Yup. Thanks to TLP I have 9 hours and 35 minutes left at the moment (88% battery) with 70% screen brightness, bluetooth and wifi enabled, several local dev servers running light workloads, and Firefox, Slack, Libreoffice and various other smaller apps open.

jammygit7 anni fa

I have the 4k screen on older model. It makes the ui a bit sluggish unless I downscale it. I would have preferred a less fancy screen tbh for that reason (battery would be better too)

Mostly though, I'm jealous of a friends' macbook keyboard and trackpad. My particular xps is not amazing in those areas

Foivos7 anni fa

I use both a last gen macbook and an xps 13 9360 every day. Even after three iterations of the new keyboard style, the macbooks do not have a decent keyboard. The keyboard of the xps is better (still not as good as the perfect keyboard of an X1 or a yoga) and way more quiet.

The trackpad of the XPS is worse than the macbook, but at least it feels OK. Overall, I prefer the input methods of the XPS.

xellisx7 anni fa

I have a current XPS-13 for work, which I work as a developer. The size if it just makes it almost unusable by itself. When I have it docked, the laptop screen is set to a lower res and I it for my communication apps. I have two extra monitors on for everything else.

thirdsun7 anni fa

Obviously you are expected to use scaling on high PPI displays. Didn't you use any?

xellisx7 anni fa

D'oh! Forgot about scaling up. Thanks for reminding me!

rozenmd7 anni fa

I have the XPS13 running at 3200x1800 in macOS - it's absolutely gorgeous.

bdcravens7 anni fa

I would agree, though running it in FHD should be much sharper than a lower density screen.

[deleted]7 anni fa

jsingleton7 anni fa

I'm not bothered about the bottom camera as I don't use it. The specs are pretty good otherwise if you max it out.

However, the battery life is terrible after upgrading Ubuntu LTS from 16 to 18 as it doesn't sleep properly. I wrote a more detailed review of it here (2018 version, not the new one just released): https://unop.uk/dell-xps-13-ubuntu-review/

SlowRobotAhead7 anni fa

>they had finally moved the camera to the top,

Now I know where to put the tape! ;)

For the rest of the specs, seems to make the MBA look like a pretty fair deal so long as you like the Apple ecosystem.

Scaevolus7 anni fa

XPS13 i7-8565U is a 15W part running 4C/8T @ 1.8-4.6GHz, MBA i5-8210Y is a 7W part running 2C/4T @ 1.6-3.6GHz. That's a significant performance difference.

gerberus7 anni fa

The i5 version of the XPS is 70% faster than the i5 in the MBA (8250u vs 8210y) so it seems you are getting a whole lot more for your money in the XPS (or even the MBP)

abrookewood7 anni fa

I have the latest XPS13 and they really are great machines. We also have the older XPS 15, but it feels noticeably heavier, bulkier and seems to have some stability issues.

Also worth looking at the Lenovo X1. Similarly light and powerful.

Edit: My only complaint with the XPS13 is the ports ... it's definitely one short (power, monitor, USB peripherals) which forces you to get the expensive dock. Not cool.

awongh7 anni fa

nice comparison.

I am waiting for the right time to buy an ubuntu laptop, but it still seems like a MBP is the better choice. You're just much less likely to run into some weird hardware driver issue.

I guess it used to be quite a bit cheaper to get a non-apple laptop, but it seems like the other companies have figured out that you can charge more for a "premium" product..... Looking at the above comparison, price would not be a differentiator for me. ( Do I really care about what amounts to a ~$300 price difference if we were looking at literally same specs? )

It's too bad because I'd love for there to be a real, price conscious alternative to an apple laptop, but that doesn't seem to be the way the industry is going. It seems like every year dell and lenovo creep closer to apple pricing.

bhhaskin7 anni fa

I have the last gen non-developer xps 13 running Ubuntu. No driver issues what so ever. Honestly most of the hardware are pretty standard these days.

Nursie7 anni fa

Weight-wise I've been interested in the Asus Zenbook S range recently.

Similar specs to the XPS13 and weighing in at around 1KG.

But for some reason Asus don't sell the 16GB models in the UK :/

The MBA is a weird machine, to me, as it's almost as heavy and almost as expensive as the Pro, with far worse specs.

RobLach7 anni fa

Excellent breakdown for comparison. Thank you.

[deleted]7 anni fa

wjoe7 anni fa

Sad to see the XPS 13 line going the same way as Apple and removing the USB A ports. On the plus side, it's at least possible to connect two monitors to the USB C ports now (the 2017 version I have has only one USB C port), but it's less overall ports now since the power jack is also replaced by USB C. The body seems the same size as previously, so the excuse of "more thinness" doesn't really apply.

That said, the XPS 13 has been the best experience I've had with Linux on a laptop. The bundled Ubuntu install works out of the box, but even on other distros it's not difficult to set up, and I've not encountered any driver issues, which have been common on every other laptop I've installed Linux on. It helps that it's a great quality laptop in general - anecdotally in my office, we see far more hardware issues with the latest Macbooks than with XPSs.So I'd recommend it for anyone who wants a Linux or Windows laptop, or is considering switching away from Mac without compromising on hardware quality.

pdpi7 anni fa

Apple has the common decency to make all of their USB-C ports identical, and support just about every allowable feature I know of, so, in theory, there's no reason you'll ever plug a device into a Mac and have it not work because the port isn't compatible (even though it's physically the same). Great in theory, I just wish the ports were more reliable — I've now had two laptops with flaky ports.

Dell dropped the ball by giving this laptop two TB3 ports and one that only does USB.

kllrnohj7 anni fa

I have the previous gen model which also is 2 TB3 + 1 USB-C and it really doesn't matter much at all in practice. Since TB3 is isolated to the more "permanent" stuff (docks or eGPUs) it's pretty natural to just always use the same port since the cable layout is fixed. It's not like you connect random TB3 stuff to it regularly on the go.

Lio7 anni fa

One thing that threw me for a while on my 9370 was why I couldn’t get it to boot from a USB-C memory stick.

I didn’t realise at first, this was due to the difference in USB vs Thunderbolt.

Rebelgecko7 anni fa

On some MBP configurations (I think the 13 inch model?), the USB-C/Thunderbolt 3 ports on the left and right side don't have the same capabilities.

lookingsideways7 anni fa

That was the case with the 2016 and 2017 models of 13" MBP w/touch bar - the right side had reduced PCI Express bandwidth. The 2018 model has full bandwidth on all ports.

dawnerd7 anni fa

Does the 15 have the same problem?

SomeHacker447 anni fa

ISTR that the 15” of all generation had 4 lane TB3 ports on both sides. The distinction was the older 13” had two lanes on the right.

pdpi7 anni fa

It's the 2016/2017 versions of the tbMBP 13". My understanding is that the the right-hand side have all the same capabilities as the left-hand side, but lower PCIe bandwidth.

It's definitely confusing and a bit frustrating that it's different if you're in a scenario where the bandwidth matters, but at least it's just numbers rather than devices outright not working.

jen207 anni fa

I once encountered a situation where a particular projector would only work when connected to the right hand side of my 13" MacBook Pro (2016) - so it's not true to say that devices don't work.

dag117 anni fa

They're identical on the same machine, but the Macbook only has USB3.1 (+ Display Port) whereas the Macbook Pro is TB3. This isn't very obvious to users.

Dunedan7 anni fa

On the MacBook Pro 2016 and 2017 they weren't completely identical, as the TB3 ports on the right side only provided 20Gbit/s instead of the "full" 40Gbit/s. Check out https://www.macrumors.com/2016/10/28/macbook-pro-tb3-reduced... for details.

pdpi7 anni fa

Fair point, completely forgot about the Macbook.

sandov7 anni fa

Today I learned that Thunderbolt is the name of the interface/protocol, not the connector.

IgorPartola7 anni fa

Mhm. Same USB 3 is the protocol while USB C is the connector. You can totally have USB 2.0 only USB C ports.

phinnaeus7 anni fa

Many of the first phones that launched with USB-C connectors were USB 2.0.

habitue7 anni fa

Additionally, it might even make sense to have the power plug only be USB-2.0, if it's cheap. No reason to have a thunderbolt 3.0 cable plugged into the wall all the time

hiker5127 anni fa

Unless you want to use your external display as power supply and usb hub at the same time with just one cable.

Some of us do work in actual offices and not in some coffee shops down the street. ;)

habitue7 anni fa

> Some of us do work in actual offices

Whoah, what's up with that? Not sure why you're inferring this coffee shop story or why you're doing this smug posturing thing but it's pretty obnoxious.

akoncius7 anni fa

but it’s not what parent author wrote. idea was to use usb-2 cheap cable as a cable to transfer electricity between charger and laptop.

PascLeRasc7 anni fa

USB 2.0 specifies a maximum of 20AWG wire width for power transmission, which would limit you to 1.5A for charging.

http://sdphca.ucsd.edu/lab_equip_manuals/usb_20.pdf

habitue7 anni fa

We're talking about usb-2.0 data over usb-c cable. It'll still have the power delivery of usb-c

hiker5127 anni fa

And that wastes physical real estate that could be used for a more modern cable. And with more USBC / thunderbolt cables around, theyll also get cheaper.

BeeOnRope7 anni fa

Can you have USB 3.x over Type A?

dogma11387 anni fa

Yes, USB 3.X type A has additional pins, all the “blue“ type-a ports can support USB 3.0 and 3.1 gen 1/2 depending on the controller powering them.

USB-C adds additional pins for alt-mode as well as a higher power delivery allowance, but the USB data protocol part of it is the same as any other type of port of the same spec.

ac297 anni fa

Type A, Type B, Micro B, and C are all valid: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB#Receptacle_(socket)_identi...

ClassyJacket7 anni fa

Yep, before USB-C was out, Thunderbolt used a MiniDisplayPort connector.

bilbo0s7 anni fa

>Dell dropped the ball by giving this laptop two TB3 ports and one that only does USB....

That was a serious miss on Dell's part. I'm not sure why they did that?

Makes it a little annoying for users.

wmf7 anni fa

Three TB3 ports would have required an extra controller chip.

organsnyder7 anni fa

Seems like it would have been better to omit the third port entirely, then—or, better yet, put a USB-A port there instead.

colemickens7 anni fa

Having a Yubikey permanently installed, I can say that on the 9370, I don't miss USB Type A ports, but I definitely wouldn't be using this as a daily laptop if it had one fewer (two total) USB Type C connectors.

That would effectively mean I have zero ports free when charging and with my permanent Yubikey plugged in. It's never been an issue in practice, but I also wish that Dell would remove the ambiguity and make them all TB3 ports.

dzhiurgis7 anni fa

> there's no reason you'll ever plug a device into a Mac and have it not work because the port isn't compatible

You can't transfer data between two Macs using USB-C to USB-C cable that comes as a charger...

Nursie7 anni fa

Apple dropped the ball on the Macbook, IMHO, by making the one port not a TB3 port.

shakehar7 anni fa

I know everyone has a different step but I would welcome two usb C ports over a regular port just because the I can get a powered usb c dock that is connected to all my peripherals. That way all I have to plug in when I get in to work is one cable.

gumby7 anni fa

This was the #1 use case for Type C development BTW. I have friends who were working on silicon this for over a decade.

I anticipate that 2019 will be the year when we'll get monitors that are the "dock", so in practice most users will use at most a single port.

SamWhited7 anni fa

I already do this, and it's wonderful. I had to get a monitor that was way too big though to find one that had all the ports I want and which could supply enough power back to the laptop, but I assume smaller monitors are getting it by now too. Still though, it's well worth it if you need a new monitor to wait for one that has all your preferred specs and also does USB-C, I don't think I could go back.

I plug in my laptop and the monitor comes on, my keyboard and mouse start working over USB, my speakers start working because I turned the builtin soundbar off and enabled the in USB-C/3.55mm DAC that's also built into some Dell monitors, and even my printer and a synthesizer that I use as a practice (piano-)keyboard are are ready to go.

Foivos7 anni fa

They are already pretty widespread, but expensive for now. I have to regularly use at work a Dell XPS 13, a macbook and a Lenogo Yoga. The monitor I use is an HP Z27 with a built in dock, where I have a keyboard and mouse connected. Whenever I have to switch a laptop, I just unplug the usb-c cable of the monitor from the laptop I am using and plug it to the new one. It takes a couple of seconds and I have my full setup usable again. The best thing is that it also provides power to the laptops, so I do not have to plug them.

In the past, when I was connecting a laptop to a monitor I had two options:

1) Use a proprietary dock. This is as convenient as the usb-c cable, but you can use it with a single brand of devices. Also, in the case of the usb-c cable you are free to move the laptop around the desk. Not so easy with a dock.

2) Plug the monitor and the peripherals directly the ports of the laptop. When you have to switch laptops frequently, it feels like this process is taking ages. It also looks ugly to have an octopus laptop on the desk.

Having said that the dedicated usb-c docks are notoriously problematic. I have tried a lot to find a single one with more than 3 star reviews, but it seems impossible. At least, I have not heard complains about the built-in docks inside monitors. In this case though, you have to make some sacrifices in the number and variety of ports. For example, in my case, I do not have ethernet.

wlesieutre7 anni fa

There are already screens like that, and I like the idea in principle.

I'm more hesitant in practice because the USB3 hub in my current Dell display didn't get along with my computer and would cause blue screens when used. Easy to avoid, I just don't have the USB hub plugged in.

As things get more and more integrated, a problem anywhere in the system means the whole thing doesn't work and you can't avoid the busted parts.

gumby7 anni fa

> As things get more and more integrated, a problem anywhere in the system means the whole thing doesn't work and you can't avoid the busted parts.

That's a general issue: laptops are pretty integrated and even in your tower it's pretty hard to patch the mobo (and let's not get into the issue of upgrading your L1 cache.

I started computing on a machine (PDP-6) on which you could add instructions with a wire wrap pencil. That's clearly impossible today, but with modern manufacturing, increased integration typically means increased overall reliability.

wlesieutre7 anni fa

All true, but the benefits of integrating those things are more obvious to me than "you don't have a separate USB and power cable."

On the plus side, issues like mine ought to become less common with an integrated device, since it would become impossible for Dell to not test their USB hub when they plug in the display cable.

And I suppose I've considered a thunderbolt hub for the convenience and decided against it just because of what they cost. If that sort of integration were "free" with displays, yeah I'd probably take it.

jon-wood7 anni fa

I have a Dell monitor which does video, audio, power, and a couple of USB ports over USB-C. It’s easily the best setup I’ve ever had just for the convineance in being able to plug in one cable and immediately have everything I need working.

twblalock7 anni fa

Such monitors are pretty common now, at the higher end of the market, but most of them cannot charge larger laptops like 15-inchers that need more than 80 watts.

ben-schaaf7 anni fa

This is my primary concern with the whole "charge your laptop through peripherals" trend promoting usb-c. My laptop ships with a ~200W PSU, so anything that wants to reasonably charge my it needs that amount in excess power. I just don't see it being economical to stuff that king of power into everything. Not to mention I can't even find a 200W usb-c wall charger...

gumby7 anni fa

> Not to mention I can't even find a 200W usb-c wall charger...

I wouldn’t recommend buying one if you saw one — the power delivery spec only goes up to 100 W!

wmf7 anni fa

Some of those monitors already exist such as the Dell 38" (depending on your definition of dock; it doesn't have Ethernet).

azernik7 anni fa

I've had this setup for a couple of years. Back when I started out on it, with a Dell XPS 15 (9550) and Dell docks, reliability was pretty iffy; unusable for their TB dock and kind of flaky for their USB-C dock. The latter is the only one that has proven in the long run to be a decent implementation; when I switched to a Thinkpad (P52s) a year ago the USB-C dock ended up working just fine, and the TB dock was recalled and replaced and now is just flaky.

I'd either go with a hardware combination that you or a trusted reviewer has tested, or wait another year or so for the bugs to get worked out.

EDIT: Or just avoid Dell, they seem to be behind the curve on figuring out Thunderbolt 3.

fyfy187 anni fa

Even well reviewed devices aren't guaranteed to work. At work I had a TB3 dock from Belkin, that was one of the top sellers on Amazon. Everything worked on the MBP, but when I tried connecting my ThinkPad (T470s) all the peripherals and displays worked, however it wouldn't deliver any power. On the other hand the cheap Chinese TB3 dock (UGREEN branded) I have at home works fine with the ThinkPad.

wil4217 anni fa

Same here. My work laptop is a HP Zbook workstation. My favorite thing is my USB C doc. 4 USB ports, 2 display ports, Ethernet, USB c port, power, and a VGA port.

post_break7 anni fa

My 9360 XPS13 is the best experience I have for a macbook air replacement. I get a fan, keyboard that doesn't destroy itself, tiny bezel, i7, etc, and it runs high sierra.

MaysonL7 anni fa

How hard was the Hackintosh process?

post_break7 anni fa

Easy to get it installed, difficult to trouble shoot. But now that I figured it out I can breeze through it.

psychometry7 anni fa

How are things like external display support and sleep/wake with Linux on this laptop?

_wmd7 anni fa

Can't speak for the new models, but suspend/resume is bulletproof on the 9550, Mac-like experience installing Ubuntu

mikekchar7 anni fa

If you stick with non-bleeding edge distros, I think it will be fine. A colleague had some problems with Arch occasionally with newer kernels (especially when using Powertop since it often lags behind a bit). I've also had occasional problems with a very similarly built Toshiba laptop. By the time distros like Ubuntu were using those kernels, all of the problems were fixed. Probably in a 3 year period it only happened twice, so it wasn't a huge deal since I was expecting to have occasional problems.

turndown7 anni fa

I run Arch on a XPS 15, it was relatively painless and I have no major complaints, I am very cautious about upgrading the kernel and only do so periodically. I would 100% consider switching to something else if they manage to solve packages as Arch has.

antongribok7 anni fa

Same with the 9360 and running Fedora.

Fogest7 anni fa

You do have the option of the XPS15. My XPS15 has 2 USB 3.0 ports and one USB C port. It also has a separate power connection port, HDMI, and SD card reader.

DennisP7 anni fa

Do you run Linux on it? Apparently the XPS15 can't be ordered with Linux [1], so you're paying the $100 MS tax and as of a year ago, installing Linux was not without issues [2].

[1] https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/dell-laptops/xps-15/spd/xps-...

[2] https://medium.com/@kemra102/linux-on-the-dell-xps-15-919e6d...

Personally I want a 15-inch laptop with Linux preinstalled or perfectly supported, a great trackpad, a bright screen so I can work outdoors, and USB A so I can plug in my mech keyboards without dongles because I lose them all the time.

Fogest7 anni fa

I would assume a mechanical keyboard is not being used portably? Couldn't the dongle just stay with the keyboard?

I do not use Linux on my XPS15. It's just a personal preference but I prefer Windows on my personal machines. I use many virtual machines on the laptop, and those have no issues, but that is a bit different than running it as a OS ;).

But I do love the laptop a lot! That is quite annoying that there are some Linux problems and that you pay a bit extra for MS. I stick with using Linux at work when I am purely doing development work, and at home when doing casual stuff, like a little coding, gaming, and web browsing I prefer Windows.

DennisP7 anni fa

My previous employer got me a new macbook pro and every couple weeks I either lost a dongle or it broke. The cheap ones are really fragile, and the better ones still not great. If I had only one machine, or all machines took the dongle, I probably wouldn't lose so many at least.

I do use a mech portably...I like to carry one in my laptop bag and set up at a picnic table at a nearby park. I'll use the built-in keyboard for light work but with heavy typing I need the mech for ergonomics.

chiefalchemist7 anni fa

If you add a backlit KB I'll buy it. Room for a second HD would be a bonus but not a requirement.

wongarsu7 anni fa

And with the USB C docking station you can have two (three??) external monitors as well as regular USB, sound and Ethernet.

The only thing I'm really missing is an ethernet port on the laptop itself, but that's hard in this form factor.

wslh7 anni fa

Using an XPS 13 2-1 from 2017 and have 3 external monitors via the Dell TB16 Thunderbolt dock.

Fogest7 anni fa

Yeah I have had some cases where I wish I had an ethernet port, but not enough cases yet to make me buy a USB-Ethernet adapter.

sametmax7 anni fa

Don't. I got both, and while the xps 13 is good gear, the 15 has been nothing but pain. The name is the only thing they got in common, and dell stayed silent on numerous issues about it.

SamWhited7 anni fa

This was my experience with a previous gen version that I was given at work too; half the hardware was different, it was hit or miss whether Linux would work with the wifi hardware you got (if they make a developer edition of the 15" though I assume that one would always come with a working chipset), it was falling apart much quicker than people with the 13" versions were, the keyboard was terrible (although the keyboard on the 13" was terrible too, but it didn't stick as much as the 15" did, though that could just be bad luck), etc.

Fogest7 anni fa

I already have the XPS15 and have nothing but good things to say about it. I have had zero issues with it and love it.

What issues do you have? I do not notice a difference from the xps13 quality.

sametmax7 anni fa

Random blue screens.

Poor USB-C support (sometimes ethernet died, sometimes screens changed resolutions...). The problem kept changing from BIOS update to BIOS update.

Then the USB-C harware failed: I could use it only if my laptop stayed perfectly still.

Only a few hours of battery life.

Drunk touchpad.

Speakers died after 3 month.

The 2 first points were fixed after years of hit and miss BIOS updates. It felt like beta testing the product.

Tons of complains from many users on Dell forum, with zero help from Dell.

Given the price of the machine, it's a damn shame.

Fogest7 anni fa

That is rather unfortunate. I have had zero of these problems you describe with my XPS15 laptop and I have had it around 5-6 months now. I hope it will stay that way.

wslh7 anni fa

Using a Thunderbolt dock like the TB16 from Dell you can connect 3 external monitors.

cft7 anni fa

They bilindly copy Apple's decisions, without realizing that Apple is in the long term death spiral without Jobs. That's a big mistake.

timeattack7 anni fa

I do own XPS 13 9360 and there are number of issues:

- coil whine under load;

- poor heat sink, under little load i7 goes to 100C and CPU throttling kicks in;

- sometimes 'w' button seems to be 'stuck' in pressed state even when it's physically un-pressed; seems to be a firmware keyboard bug, since I've seen same problem on another XPS 13;

- I've had to replace Killer WiFi card, because RTT for packets spiked up every time card was scanning for networks;

- that 'spidey-fingers' webcam;

- that 'Content Adaptive Brightness Control' when gamma-level goes off every time you switch from black to white image on the screen;

- unable to replace battery, since even when I've ordered battery from authorized service center they gave me non-official third-party battery which was not accepted by laptop;

- connecting 4K@60Hz is kinda problematic, since you need to find USB-C adapter which supports it;

kowdermeister7 anni fa

I have 9370 (the 2018 model) and I only have these two:

- that 'spidey-fingers' webcam;

lol, that's a weird one, but solved with the external keyboard

- that 'Content Adaptive Brightness Control' when gamma-level goes off every time you switch from black to white image on the screen;

that's a weird one, how to turn that off? (win 10)

kinduff7 anni fa

You can do that from the BIOS and disable Dynamic Brightness Control in the display options

EspadaV97 anni fa

I bought a 9360 and returned it because of the coil whine, it was so bad that I could hear it over music playing from the laptop. I returned it for a refund and got a 9370 about 8 months later and it has been so much better. No coil whine now. The webcam is in the same place, but I have never had to use it. I didn't have any issues with the Killer card in either the 9360 or the 9370 (and use it daily for multiple hours at a time).

I do really wish I could've got the laptop without the 4k screen because on a 13" laptop I would rather save the battery life and not have a glossy screen, alas, it wasn't available last year in Australia with 16GB RAM. It does seem that this year though it is available.

I use an external 4k screen and don't have any issues, although I am using the Dell TB16 dock. The more annoying issue is that you can use 4k@60 over HDMI since it isn't supported by the Intel GPU, you need to use a DP connector.

pja7 anni fa

Coil whine seems to be a problems with lots of current gen laptops - work colleague had to return a brand new top-of-the-line Apple laptop a month or two ago because the coil whine was ridiculously loud.

cies7 anni fa

> sometimes 'w' button seems to be 'stuck' in pressed

I've had several XPS13s with keyboard issues. I honestly cannot consider it a "developer edition" when the keyboard is wonky. Contacted HP support every time, found them trying to ignore the issue while whole support forums where mobbing up in anger over the issue. Finally they admitted, but nothing happened. I'm on a T420 now, while I really-really wanted to support suppliers that provide Linux-out-of-the-box machines.

meddlepal7 anni fa

You contacted HP support for a Dell laptop... That might be the problem ;)

capdeck7 anni fa

PEBKAC classic. But I have to second the keyboard sentiment. I can't rely on it to be decent on anything but lenovo these days, may be not even...

I have HP probook where you can replace the keyboard easily. When I got the machine with "premium" keyboard, a few keys were wobbly, made different squeaky sounds and had overall inconsistent feel to them. I went to HP website and ordered a replacement -- it came with other keys being bad. I called HP and they sent me replacement for replacement -- the same story -- their keyboards are just so cheaply made and quality control so lacking, that you have to be very lucky to get one with all keys working consistently.

Keyboards are the worst part of the laptop these days.

cies7 anni fa

Excuse. It was Dell obviously that I contacted. :)

(okay I had to contact HP several times as well, but that was a server unit, and after some calls/ceremony it got adequately serviced)

macdice7 anni fa

I have a 9360 with coil whine. So far I like everything about it (size, weight, power) except that noise. Luckily, FreeBSD powerd_flag="-a adaptive" seems to get rid of most of it. I find that it is silent when idle with low CPU freq, silent when under heavy load with high CPU freq, but noisy when idling with high CPU freq, so that a quickly dropping the speed make the problem mostly go away.

I don't use the Killer WIFI because my OS doesn't support it yet. Perhaps I'll be able to complain about that later in the year.

Sometimes I regret not picking up a Thinkpad X1 C6 (I have lifelong Thinkpad keyboard envy, since owning a T something many years ago), but they're way more expensive and I keep reading about disappointing manufacturing problems with those things, and I know that'd be a pain to deal with in my location.

jopsen7 anni fa

I've started returning laptops with coil whine.. ended up doing it last I tried XPS.

Similarly, I sent a X1 Carbon back this summer due to missing Linux support -- suspend, touchpad, CPU scaling, and lots of small bugs. (I'm quite happy with my older X1 though)

Anyways, I suggest sending it back and ask for refund next time to get a laptop with coil whine. There is only one way to teach manufacturers that this is unacceptable.

zeusk7 anni fa

> Content Adaptive Brightness Control

It is part of Intel's shenanigans to improve battery life.

CABC bothered me on my surface book too, fortunately they allow you to disable this. It previously (pre-9350) required a firmware update but can now be switched off using the latest intel display driver control panel.

touristtam7 anni fa

Personally the bezel is driving me nuts. How is the screen not flush with the top frame? Coil whining is taken care of by preventing any single core to run at 100% for any period of time. My biggest grip is still the lack of proper docking station for using it as a desktop replacement. Every single port replicator I have used fails at some point (ethernet, dual monitor, external USB device) and requires a reboot. For that reason I would personally go with a TP given the choice.

secure7 anni fa

You’re not alone: I have the 9360, too, and experienced 6 of your 8 listed problems (the battery replacement I haven’t tried, and the heat I never noticed).

dlgeek7 anni fa

I also have a 9360 and I have also experienced 1, 2, 5, and 6 off your list. I also have the monitor just go nuts every so often until I give it a whack in exactly the right place. I've also had horrible experiences with reliability and Dell's support which I posted elsewhere in this thread.

Next machine's another X1 Carbon for me (I had the 1st gen before this).

bonyt7 anni fa

I’ve been having many of these problems with my 9360 as well. I recently switched back to using a 2013 MacBook Pro Retina with Linux on it, and the much older thing just feels faster, and I can’t put my finger on why. Maybe it’s the CPU throttling? I mean, even web browsing doesn’t feel right on my 9360.

dnhz7 anni fa

Another issue is that the battery can swell. And you'll have to go through the process of ordering a third-party battery and trying to replace it yourself.

At least with Apple, you can take it to the store for authorized service.

m_rcin7 anni fa

> - sometimes 'w' button seems to be 'stuck' in pressed state even when it's physically un-pressed

Ah, so it's a common issue. I also have the 'w' problem on Dell Lattitude E7450.

switch0077 anni fa

Ditto almost all of that. The 9360 is junk (and doubly junk when paired with a TB16 dock)

nvr2197 anni fa

I have xps15 with killer wifi card and it sucks

aschampion7 anni fa

I split my development time between a 2015 rMBP and a Precision 5530 (pro model of the XPS 15). I still can not switch fully to the Dell because of a few issues:

- The touchpad is just garbage compared to the MBP, to the point I have an even more keyboard centric setup on it than my desktop, because I want to drop it out of a window every time I use the touchpad.

- Fans. I've accepted that most laptops will run active cooling more than any radiative chassis MBP, but the issues are that while the fans run constantly, they also change speeds constantly in both Windows and Ubuntu. They'd be far less annoying if they ran at a higher, but steady RPM by averaging response over a large time window. Manually managing fans feels like 1998. Also, for a $3.5K laptop that runs fans constantly, these are some of the jankiest, most rattling prone fans I've heard. Most colleagues with XPS 13/15 have sent them in for fan replacement at least once.

A more niche gripe is that 16:9 is the wrong aspect ratio for a professional laptop.

Pros:

- Screen quality and brightness.

- Keyboard (why I can't just get a new MBP).

- Hardware configurability.

- Many hardware issues at first, especially in linux, were quickly and effectively fixed by Dell driver and firmware updates.

adameast90007 anni fa

Ditto on the touchpad issues. Have a 2016 XPS 13 (1st or 2nd year of the new design) that I ended up sending in 3 times for repairs due to the touchpad. Jittery, can't scroll, unreliable with right clicks / two finger clicks; ruined the experience for me. I eventually gave up sending to the factory because they were all equally dysfunctional.

-Many issues with power management, where I would close the lid and it would sleep, only to wake up later randomly. I would find it in my backpack blazing hot with fans at 100%.

-This was the 4k model, and at that point windows barely supported that resolution so the experience was awful with all but the most robust apps. Any legacy app was unusable. I expect this is better now.

-The speakers on 2/3 gave off a poppy, static sound during boot.

-Network connectivity is horrible. Sometimes the adapter would just turn off, requiring a restart. Resuming from sleep would take a full 60 seconds to connect to known networks. Insane

Brigadirk7 anni fa

I also stopped sending it back in because every touchpad seemed to have the same scrolling issues. Then I tried installing Linux to see if the issues would be the same, and since then the trackpad has been working great. It's the reason I use Linux these days.

ergo147 anni fa

I have a rather high end Latitude, (model lower than XPS 13), and every mac user that used the touchpad on it says it feels on par with the one on MBP.

mrcodedude7 anni fa

I bought (and returned) an XPS 13 9360 last year. Touchpad was trash - overly sensitive, skipped, unrecognized movements, etc. I understand part of that is software, but it's embarrassing how much better the touchpads are on Macbooks.

It seems all the trackpads got worse when they went button-less to copy Apple.

ergo147 anni fa

Maybe it was broken? Were you testing under Windows or Linux? I do have buttons on my touchpad though (and a trackpoint).

mrcodedude7 anni fa

Windows. I don't think it was broken, it was a similar quality to the HP Spectre I bought (and also returned).

Maybe the Latitudes have a better touchpad? I don't mind the Lenovo T-series touchpads and they look similar.

ergo147 anni fa

I would be surprised as Latitudes are business line a bit lower than XPS, but who knows.

I also own MBP13 - and I prefer the keyboard on my Dell over it.

JCharante7 anni fa

> A more niche gripe is that 16:9 is the wrong aspect ratio for a professional laptop.

What aspect ratio is more fitting for a professional laptop? 4:3?

aschampion7 anni fa

16:10 is great, although I did briefly trial run a Surface Book 2 and loved the 3:2 screen, as well as the rest of the hardware. Only decided against it because of the amount of compromises and maintenance when running Linux on it.

anuragsoni7 anni fa

I'm hoping more device start offering 3:2 screens now. I was interested in the surface line too but decided against it for the same reasons as you. I ordered Huawei's Matebook X pro yesterday which was the only other laptop I saw which offers a nice 3:2 display. I'm hoping everything will work out of the box (this laptop uses intel wireless unlike the marvell chip on the surface) with any recent distro.

Sidenote: I've also read about decent openbsd support for the older version of this laptop. [1]

[1] https://jcs.org/2017/07/14/matebook

mixmastamyk7 anni fa

Anything taller than 16:9. Unless you like scrolling, or use the professional developer laptop for watching movies all day.

tjr2257 anni fa

Probably referring to 16:10 - which I also love. Another victim of the endless march towards cost cutting & manufacturing standardization.

awesomepeter7 anni fa

Yep, or 16:10.

nickspacek7 anni fa

I wish I could even get my HP ZBook trackpad to function as nicely in Debian as it does on Windows. I probably need to dig in the Xorg settings, but the last two attempts saw me reverting to the defaults + Gnome tweaking, which seems to be insufficient regardless of how I tweak the simple options.

improv327 anni fa

Tip: make sure you're using libinput and not synaptics. These days libinput seems to have the most reliable trackpad support.

navidr7 anni fa

Sorry for asking an unrelated question, I recently bought a XPS 15. Do you know what is the difference between Precision 5530 and XPS 15 exactly?

It is the graphics card? Or it does have better build quality or better keyboard or something? Build quality is important to me since I use my laptop all the time.

anuragsoni7 anni fa

The differences should be the different GPU (Quadro vs GTX) and that you can order the Precision 5530 with an intel wifi chip and Xeon CPUs. The actual build quality for both should be very similar considering its the same chassis.

gioele7 anni fa

Why does a "developer edition" notebook come with a glossy screen?

I sort of understand why computer makers like glossy screens: because they just look better to the causal shopper. OK. But in a laptop that is aimed at professionals? People that stare at the screen all day long are sophisticated enough to know that a matte screen is just better.

I'm often on the train and I do not envy the poor souls that work on an enterprise-bought laptop with a glossy screen and that have to swing their heads the whole time to avoid reflections from the train window.

BTW, a thorough (p)review of the 9380: https://www.ultrabookreview.com/24336-dell-xps-13-9380/

LeoPanthera7 anni fa

The matte finish has horrible optical qualities, causing ambient light to scatter ("antiglare") washing out colors, and also causing light from individual pixels to scatter and refract back into neighboring pixels. This reduces the quality of displayed images, and in high density LCD displays it causes pixel-fine details (small text) to appear smeary.

By contrast, well-designed glossy displays minimize internal refraction and also cause light at high angles to reflect, reducing the amount of ambient light which pollutes the display. The result is that the display appears much brighter in any setting, black are blacker and do not get washed out by brights. Colors show higher dynamic range, and small details are crisper. In addition, well-designed glass glossy displays (such as those on the MacBook Pro) are actually visible and easy to use outdoors in full daylight. Even when reflections show up on glass displays, it's easy to see past them because they're full optical reflections with correct depth in stereo vision, meaning that you can correctly focus on the screen without focusing on the reflection.

Glossy displays are bad under basically two conditions:

* They are warped plastic, such as on older Dell laptops, causing weird shiny glossy glare at all angles that cannot be ignored.

* You have positioned your screen so that there is a small but very very bright reflection behind you, and cannot tilt your display.

_0w8t7 anni fa

I had XPS-13 9350 with a glossy screen. The reflection of ambient light sources was terrible. Plus, as the screen max opening angle was small, I often could not just tilt the screen sufficiently to direct the reflection away. I ended up getting a filter cover. With that the experience was like on MacBook Air 2013. The screen still reflected, but not strongly enough to bother.

Now I have Thinkpad X280 with the mate screen and I really like it. Reflections are just not there and I can tilt the screen 180 degrees.

Tharkun7 anni fa

> I have Thinkpad X280

I considered getting one. But they don't come with on-site warranty in my area -- and the warranty can't be upgraded to include on-site service. Not sure what their deal is with that. Makes me think they're crappy machines that are hard to service. Or maybe Lenovo just don't want my business?

mbrumlow7 anni fa

You say all that -- regardless how superior your glossy screen is on paper; I, and many others still prefer to look at matte screens and have far less problems with them in real world situations.

appleiigs7 anni fa

I downvoted you. He’s stating facts/info and answering a question. He’s not telling you what you should prefer. Unnecessarily argumentative.

mbrumlow7 anni fa

The problem is some times things look good on paper, but those good attributes don't translate into user satisfaction.

tinco7 anni fa

I don't even know any developers that work on matte screens. What problems are we supposed to have in the real world?

jenscow7 anni fa

I'm a developer and I prefer matte screens. Here's why:

Comfort: I don't need to adjust myself or the screen's position depending on the light.

Power saving: My brightness can be lower, because it's not competing with reflection.

To me, these greatly outweigh any advantages of a glossy screen.

On thing which may be important: I require a dark desktop theme.

mbrumlow7 anni fa

Are they all using Apple?

- Glare for one, never had a glossy screen not be horrid with glare.

mixmastamyk7 anni fa

Maybe you're on Macs. Those have glossy screens with a "secret recipe" coating to avoid glare. Consider then half glossy/matte.

wwweston7 anni fa

> Even when reflections show up on glass displays, it's easy to see past them, because they're full optical reflections with correct depth in stereo vision, meaning that you can correctly focus on the screen without focusing on the reflection.

This... just doesn't track my experience, at least with MBPs up through 2015. "easy to see past [reflections]" is a subjective point even if what you're saying about the optics is 100% correct.

Retina displays are great in some ways but for me a typical open office plan lighting will do the job of providing distracting light reflections on any glossy display, and depth of reflection has never made them any less distracting than, say, someone standing behind me -- sure, you can focus on something else but it doesn't mean they're not a distraction. Not a problem with matte screens unless there's sun-bright direct light. And for outdoor use, sure, that can be a problem, but if I'm picking between any retina model and my mid-2012 non-retina antiglare/matte MBP, the latter has won every time. Which is one of the reasons I'm typing this on that same model and dreading the day it outright breaks or falls out of OS update.

Now if you're more worried about any subpixel smudginess, it's never bothered me, but OK, that's a fair personal preference. And as for scatter through matte from light sources degrading images, outside of bright daylight, I've never even noticed on-screen quality being compromised.

But who knows, maybe your perceptual wetware works differently. And if you like glass/glossy displays, congratulations, you have plenty of options, and that's great. None of that is enough reason to assume it's a global experience.

ploxiln7 anni fa

> Even when reflections show up on glass displays, it's easy to see past them because they're full optical reflections with correct depth in stereo vision, meaning that you can correctly focus on the screen without focusing on the reflection.

That does not work for a laptop - the glass surface is too close to the pixels for the "focus past the glass" to make a difference.

The light which is not "at high angles" reflects into your eyes from the surface you are focusing on (+/- 0.5 mm).

LeoPanthera7 anni fa

> That does not work for a laptop - the glass surface is too close to the pixels for the "focus past the glass" to make a difference.

You have misunderstood. You are focusing past the reflection, which will appear to be many meters "past" the glass.

ploxiln7 anni fa

You're right, that makes sense.

But still glossy displays seem to have plenty to reflect right into your eyes.

coldtea7 anni fa

>Why does a "developer edition" notebook come with a glossy screen?

Because developers like sharp text (as opposed to smudged due to the diffusion filter) and better color and saturation too.

Not all of us work under back lights we cannot avoid...

I mean, it might be a personal preference, but it's not like some objective law that developer === matte screen (like eg. 3D artist === discreet GPU).

mixmastamyk7 anni fa

Well, this is an ultra-portable, not a workstation screen in a darkened studio. Color saturation might matter for developers at a vfx house, the vast majority are looking at text.

A matte screen should be default for this one.

h3throw7 anni fa

> People that stare at the screen all day long are sophisticated enough to know that a matte screen is just better.

I always enjoy it when someone arrogantly poses a subjective statement as fact from a position of arbitrary authority. I like it especially so when there are a plethora of reasons against their position as in this case.

TomVDB7 anni fa

You’re obvious not sophisticated enough. /s

rifung7 anni fa

> But in a laptop that is aimed at professionals? People that stare at the screen all day long are sophisticated enough to know that a matte screen is just better.

Way to stereotype..? I guess I am not sophisticated enough because I prefer a glossy screen.

> I'm often on the train and I do not envy the poor souls that work on an enterprise-bought laptop with a glossy screen and that have to swing their heads the whole time to avoid reflections from the train window.

We unsophisticated commoners work from desks and where I don't seem to have this problem.

mixmastamyk7 anni fa

> work from desks and where I don't seem to have this problem.

Depends where you work and if you have control over the lighting. I used to have a horrible time with overhead fluorescent tubes, glare and flickering. To the point where I'd have to climb up and disable them. Thankfully they've gone out of style.

eropple7 anni fa

I used to have this reaction, but these days I go between matte and gloss screens without really noticing. Apple's got the best one, and a backlight on the ones I've got doesn't bother me at all. Dell's are also okay (though there are other reasons I don't like the XPS line).

sliken7 anni fa

I can somewhat understand glossy on a desktop display where you at least have a decent chance of some control over the lighting.

However on a laptop it seems silly. Last thing I want to see in my new expensive screen is my ugly mug reflected back at me.

coldtea7 anni fa

Most laptops are sitting in either desktops or places like airports coffee shops.

In all three places you can move it easily (and it being a laptop makes moving it even easier).

Hundreds of thousands of developers have MBPr's which are glossy only.

mbrumlow7 anni fa

> Hundreds of thousands of developers have MBPr's which are glossy only.

The number of people doing something does not strengthen your argument. Even more so given that Apple does not offer matte displays.

coldtea7 anni fa

>The number of people doing something does not strengthen your argument.

Actually it very much does, it just depends on the nature of the argument.

Here it's very relevant. It's not silly to put a glossy screen on a laptop if tons of people buy it -- and even prefer it.

mbrumlow7 anni fa

You can only develop IOS apps on Apple products, apple does not offer a matte display. The argument only holds true if Apple offered a matte display and developers still chose glossy.

No for sure there are people who want MacOS -- but again those people don't have a choice if they want a Apple they get gloss. So the argument does not hold.

People buy apple despite glossy screens, not because of glossy screens.

coldtea7 anni fa

>You can only develop IOS apps on Apple products, apple does not offer a matte display. The argument only holds true if Apple offered a matte display and developers still chose glossy.

Or if the iOS thing is a red herring, and tons of developers still buy Apple products regardless.

I'm not an iOS/macOS developer and still use Apple products (and just about everybody else in my company). And in most dev conferences for totally unrelated stuff (Golang, Rust, Java, etc.) the number of MBP yielding devs is 50% or most (and most of the speakers even more so).

mbrumlow7 anni fa

But you are missing the Apple does not offer a matte. So if you decide you like the rest of the hardware and OS you have no choice.

If apple offered a matte MBP then you would have numbers that could mean something. You have many users using glossy displays because that is all that apple offers. It does not mean they actually prefer glossy screens.

I remember when apple stopped offering matte and TONS of people were outraged.

coldtea7 anni fa

>If apple offered a matte MBP then you would have numbers that could mean something.

They did offer a matte and glossy option and some point, and moved on to glossy only. Safe to assume the buyers have spoken?

mbrumlow7 anni fa

It's cute that you think that is how apple works.

There was a huge backlash. People hates it. Apple pushed forward anyways. They knew they had a monopoly on Apple hardware and the iPhone would ensure they could make silly decisions without backlash.

Has the market spoken about removing evey single port from their laptops ? Donglegate ? There are many other things apple did that people have been very vocal about.

[deleted]7 anni fa

rlonstein7 anni fa

> Hundreds of thousands of developers have MBPr's which are glossy only.

also billions of flies can't be wrong about dung.

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/tools/lp/Bo/LogicalFalla...

coldtea7 anni fa

>also billions of flies can't be wrong about dung.

And they aren't: dang is nutricious and very beneficial to flies, they are right to consume it.

>https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/tools/lp/Bo/LogicalFalla...

That's irrelevant, as what matters here is what makes sense for a company to offer -- not what someone thinks is "better" for themselves. And that's a popularity metric.

mixmastamyk7 anni fa

> Hundreds of thousands of developers have MBPr's which are glossy only.

They have a coating to reduce glare. Consider them half glossy/matte.

humblebee7 anni fa

I see it in the opposite way. A laptop with a glossy screen can be re-positioned to avoid strange lighting. While my desk, and my monitor have little mobility. When the sun comes down I like my matte desktop screen because it does not reflect any sun that might be coming in from the windows.

TomVDB7 anni fa

I like glossy screens much more than matte, even though I use my laptop almost exclusively for development.

I just love how good it looks. That makes it better for me.

Suggesting that people who like glossy screens are unsophisticated is just unwarranted gatekeeping.

baybal27 anni fa

> Why does a "developer edition" notebook come with a glossy screen?

Not all glossy screens are bad, just the ones released relatively recently are.

Sony was making near perfect high end LCDs with glossy screen, glass surface, AND real AR coating.

In comparison, later design panels simply had glossy polycarbonate with poor still poor surface finish.

Laminated and "one glass" screen also do come in varying quality levels. One glass screens with AR coatings are very, very good, but ones with poor lamination, and mismatched refraction indexes are horrid.

mikestew7 anni fa

People that stare at the screen all day long are sophisticated enough to know that a matte screen is just better.

"The group I'm conveniently in is more sophisticated." Mmm, hmm. Matte screens suck because everything is blurry and smeared. I mean, if your work/life balance is out of whack and you have to work in moving vehicles, I could see the need. But professionals that work someplace other than sweatshops prefer glossy screens with sharp pixels.

feanaro7 anni fa

Please don't counter an elitist argument with an elitist argument.

mikestew7 anni fa

What, irony is no longer allowed on HN? Lighten up, Francis.

feanaro7 anni fa

Irony is famously hard to communicate reliably over the internet. If I've misjudged your comment, and it appears I have, I apologise.

robocat7 anni fa

Touch-screen models are glossy.

Non-touch-screen models are matte.

At least that was the case for my XPS 15, and I was told it is a fairly general rule that touch screen laptops are glossy.

mixmastamyk7 anni fa

Last year they didn't offer a high-res version without touch.

ClassyJacket7 anni fa

"People that stare at the screen all day long are sophisticated enough to know that a matte screen is just better."

A matte screen isn't just better. You get that weird prism-like diffraction of light, that turns a white pixel into coloured dots. Personally I much prefer to maybe have to move my machine occasionally to avoid a reflection than to have that weird fuzziness. For a laptop screen, anyway.

pc867 anni fa

I've been looking at a screen for probably 8-9 hours a day on average since I graduated college 11 years ago and I can honestly say I've never once thought about glossy v. matte screens.

jcadam7 anni fa

Glossy vs. matte LCDs? Pfft, I remember what it was like staring at a fuzzy CRT all day.

beanjammin7 anni fa

Green or amber?

jcadam7 anni fa

green

NightlyDev7 anni fa

You can pick the matte one if that's what you want. I agree that glossy screens are very annoying.

no_gravity7 anni fa

There is a lot to of good to be said about the XPS series. I love them for all my coding tasks.

The only problem is that you cannot open the display up fully. They block at 160° or so.

In many situations it would be super useful to have the laptop opened up 180°. In a plane for example. Or when it sits on a desk in a laptop stand and you use an external keyboard.

Running a laptop comparison site myself (https://www.productchart.com), I wonder if we should add '180°' to the filter list. It seems like an odd feature. It's super useful to me. Never heard anybody else talk about it though.

dsfyu404ed7 anni fa

I personally can't think of the last time I wanted to open a laptop 180* or more.

Obviously both our experience is anecdotal but if it was driving purchasing decisions you'd see more laptops that can open 180 since the design trade-offs are relatively minor in the overwhelming majority of cases.

jandrese7 anni fa

On a plane is pretty much the only time for me. I've been on planes where my intention to get work done on the trip was shot because with the keyboard on the tray I wasn't able to open the screen far enough to get a good view.

But typing on a vertical keyboard is probably not awesome.

wongarsu7 anni fa

If 180° opening angle is an important feature for you it might be worth it to go towards the XPS 2-in-1 series which features a 360° opening angle. In a car, on a plane or on foot that can be an awesome feature to have.

no_gravity7 anni fa

I would love a 2-in-1! Especially if the keyboard could be disconnected.

But then you don't have the option of a matte screen. And that is essential for me.

I am waiting for the day we have matte touchscreens.

Shorel7 anni fa

You can search for "Antiglare Touch Screen Protector" in Amazon and some suitable products will appear.

Why would you do such atrocity and how can you really keep clean a non-smooth surface which you constantly touch with your fingers are two issues that I better not think too much about.

blurbleblurble7 anni fa

I'm waiting for the 2-in-1 with the camera on top

Shorel7 anni fa

On top of the screen?

I am typing this comment using one of these.

blurbleblurble7 anni fa

A 2-in-1 xps with the camera on top? What's the model number?

ti_ranger7 anni fa

> Running a laptop comparison site myself (https://www.productchart.com), I wonder if we should add '180°' to the filter list.

Taking into account the context of this story, does it make sense to add "Linux" to the OS list?

With that, your site would be very useful to me, without it, not so much.

no_gravity7 anni fa

Yes, we hopefully get there at some point. I have categorized over 1600 feature requests so far. A 'Comes with Linux preinstalled filter' is not yet at the top, but it is in the top 5% of requested features.

limeblack7 anni fa

In addition to 180 I would add Thinkpad as a separate option to Lenovo. The security issues have been separate between the 2 systems and frankly I would never consider another lenovo but certainly a Thinkpad.

JadeNB7 anni fa

Lenovo also makes Thinkpads …?

limeblack7 anni fa

They are currently listed under Lenovo on the site. They own them now not sure who is the technical manufacturer.

marcus_holmes7 anni fa

I bought an XPS15, and have had nothing but trouble with it. Every time there's a Windows update, the hard drive "can't be found" and it wipes GRUB on every reboot. I've been spending half an hour every morning getting it to a state where I can use it again, and had to mess around with firmware downgrades to get it usable (until the next Windows update).

Never buying a Dell again. Their support were worse than useless, insisting that somehow installing Linux had caused the problem.

I'm eagerly waiting for my first Purism laptop, then I can get 30 mins of my day back.

wbkang7 anni fa

That's a cool website! Anyway, as a owner of an XPS, my question to you is what would you do with the 180 degree hinge on an airplane?

SteveCoast7 anni fa

I have an XPS 2-in-1 and I open to 180 degrees sometimes when laying down and using the touchscreen. It sometimes works in economy seats as you can rest the laptop on your lap and then the screen is kind of like a seatback IFE. But if you opened it flat on your lap, the screen can't open that far because of the restrictions of the seat in front of you. I also will put it in "tent mode" e.g. over 270 degrees open and the screen upside down on the tray table to watch a movie.

About the only thing I don't do much is use it as a tablet as its kind of heavy, even though I have the Dell pen for it.

sbuk7 anni fa

I thought that, but on the near vertical laptop stands its increadibly useful.

berbec7 anni fa

Great looking site! Add trackpoint as an option.

equalunique7 anni fa

I second the motion to add TrackPoint/PointStick/TrackStick as a filterable attribute.

amptorn7 anni fa

"...please."

berbec7 anni fa

Pretty please!!

felix_nagaand7 anni fa

Great idea for your site. Though im disappointed by how many laptops you're missing

no_gravity7 anni fa

My email is on the site. Feel free to get in contact and let me know which ones are missing!

laumars7 anni fa

In fairness, there are literally an infinite number of laptops out there (if you take into account the never ending cycle of new laptops being released). Cataloguing every make and model for a hobby project is simply not going to be possible.

mscrivo7 anni fa

Why are they still using Killer WiFi NIC's on these things. They are absolutely terrible. We have a bunch of XPS 13 and 15's at our office (9360's up to 9570's) and every single one of them has random connectivity problems on our office WiFi and people's home networks.

We've had to replace all of them with Intel 9260's and the problems instantly disappear. I don't know how this is not a customer support nightmare for them, and why they continue using them given the relatively low cost of the Intel cards.

robocat7 anni fa

It is a real shame they use the Killer (Atheros) WiFi. The developer edition used to have an Intel WiFi - have they changed that?

That said, I haven't seen any issues with Killer WiFi (XPS 15 9570 with Ubuntu 18.04.01), but I do have an Intel WiFi card if the Killer needs to be replaced.

Also I do use a USB3 to Ethernet adapter at work (I have always prefered a wired connection for work when available).

Macha7 anni fa

The Killer WiFi issues to me seem to have been related to the Windows driver. Never had any issues on Arch, and an update last year (not suggested by the Dell update tool, check the website) fixed it for Windows.

colemickens7 anni fa

The card in the 9370 is not replaceable, and despite having bought a card and opened it with the intention of replacing it after I bought it, it hasn't actually been an issue for me in my apartment or dozens of wifi networks across Seattle.

jhasse7 anni fa

I have a 9370 and never had any problems with the WiFi. I've connected it to lots of home networks, coffee chops, etc.

Reception is perfect, even better than the Intel card my previous latptop had.

(running Fedora Linux out-of-the-box btw)

HankB997 anni fa

Maybe I should try Fedora. The Killer WiFi continues to be a problem for me. (Debian Buster with 4.19 kernel and firmware downloaded from the Killer github account.) My uptime is 25 minutes right now because I had to reboot. I restored WiFi when it dropped earlier but the next time the restore process locked up the machine solid (as in hold the power button until it shuts down. Occasionally the Bluetooth disappears and requires a complete power down to restore. BT is on the same Killer module.

I don't know if it is drivers, firmware or my AP but it truly sucks. One really annoying aspect in an otherwise very nice machine. (9370, BTW.)

killjoywashere7 anni fa

how's the trackpad?

jhasse7 anni fa

The best I ever had. Me previous laptop was a VAIO and a MacBook Air (no Force Touch yet) before that one. The trackpad is a little bit better than the MBA's and a lot better than the one from the VAIO.

ariod7 anni fa

My thoughts exactly. With such a premium laptop I would expect WiFi to work flawlessly. Instead, I consistently had connection issues with Killer's NIC until I eventually replaced it with an Intel card.

bwat497 anni fa

yeah on my 9360 I replaced the killer wifi with an intel 8265. The killer chip was giving me issues in both windows and linux.

Otherwise it's been a great machine though

terhechte7 anni fa

Maybe somebody on here knows. Is there a (mostly) Linux compatible laptop that offers the following?

- 10-11 inch (preferably the size of the 11" Macbook Air or 10.5 inch iPad)

- Good touchscreen (with Linux support)

- Good keyboard with hinged display (2-in-one would be awesome, but I doubt that's possible given the other constraints I already have)

- Solid CPU options (i.e. no Atom)

I bought a Chuwi Surbook Mini and installed Linux on it but while the Hardware works fine, the touchscreen is so-so and the attached keyboard cover is awful. I'd buy a Microsoft Surface 10" but Linux on there doesn't support hibernation and that's a must for me (and I won't go with Windows. I tried that with the Chuwi, that OS is just not for me, I loathe it). I'd also maybe go with a Pixel Slate but 12.3 inch sounds too big for me and Google doesn't sell it here so I can't even preview it.

PascLeRasc7 anni fa

This model of XPS is only 0.18 inches wider than the 11" MBA, so it might be perfect for you.

rwmj7 anni fa

I have the old Asus Zenbook, although it's a little larger than what you're looking for, plus apparently Asus stopped making the good version. It's fast with excellent touchscreen and fully works under Linux.

It's a real shame that Sony stopped making the original Vaio (the one which was the size of a large paperback book). The GDP Pocket is supposed to be equivalent and may be more like what you're looking for - I have not tried one.

opencl7 anni fa

The 12" Chromebook models (Pixel Slate, Pixelbook, Samsung Chromebook Pro) are not any larger than the 11" MBA. They're narrower and slightly taller. The MBA just has enormous bezels and also a different aspect ratio.

terhechte7 anni fa

Thanks, I haven't had a chance to try them out because the few Google products I'm actually interested are apparently only for the US marked. I'll look at some comparison pictures and make up my mind.

devereaux7 anni fa

This is factually wrong.

Linux does support suspend2ram on the Microsoft Go.

Hibernation is just mixing suspend2ram with resume from swap.

The display is not hinged, but the inclinable stand provides a similar functionality.

terhechte7 anni fa

Sorry. I just briefly read the repo. So you're saying when I put the cover on the device it will suspend to ram (consuming very little energy) and when I open it again it will come back immediately?

devereaux7 anni fa

You will have to configure this behavior, as by default that would require pressing the power button instead of using the Hall effect sensors and the magnets from the cover.

But yes, you are correct: it will consume very little power while suspended if you use s2ram (resuming immediately) or hibernate (slower ersume, but consumes nothing)

Only s2idle consumes a lot of power.

IE67 anni fa

You mentioned the Slate - I have a Pixelbook and it meets your criteria above (although the i5-7Y57 might not be enough depending on your workload).

terhechte7 anni fa

Thanks, yeah I was tempted by the Pixelbook, but it is not being sold here so I can't just try it out in a store or try it out and send it back. I'll try to research it some more.

RomanPushkin7 anni fa

> Up to 16GB of LPDDR3 memory at 2133MHz

"Up to 16GB" in 2019 means it's not upgradable, and not worth buying, because developers like hardware that they can upgrade in 2-5 years if needed.

Flip-per7 anni fa

Absolutely. My more than 7 year old X220 now has 12GB RAM and would support up to 16GB afaik. Moreover it has a non-glossy screen, and a replaceable battery.

dmix7 anni fa

Anyone know why this is the case? Using a limited motherboard or something? 16gb should be standard these days for a developer laptop... with expansion to 32gb.

mixmastamyk7 anni fa

Ultraportable limits are generally courtesy of the Intel chipset.

Latteland7 anni fa

This would be a way for amd to make headway into the laptop market, if they made it easy to get 32+ gb.

tomp7 anni fa

Indeed. Not supporting 32GB is a disgrace for both Dell (“developer edition” LOL) and Apple. The main reason I’m skipping laptop upgrades this year...

alexott7 anni fa

For developers it should be 32 out of box, plus upgrade to 64... And they have already models with 32Gb in 2017th

JoshuaRLi7 anni fa

Agreed, and it's unfortunately still soldered. Talk about planned obsolescence...

mikenew7 anni fa

I really want to buy a "Linux laptop" like this because I want to vote with my money and I don't want to be paying for a Windows license that I'm not going to use. But why don't they sell an XPS 15 Developer Edition? Surely there's a lot of professional types wanting a bigger laptop right? Is there some hardware difference between the two that causes problems? What's the deal?

anuragsoni7 anni fa

Their Precision 5530 is the developer edition XPS 15. The same chassis with a different GPU and intel wireless instead of killer.

Although those tend to be a lot pricier than the regular XPS 15's

mikenew7 anni fa

Did not know that. Honestly I would pay a bit more for Intel wireless vs. Killer. Thanks.

anuragsoni7 anni fa

I think some of the price increase is also because of the different CPU options. In general their Precision line should be a lot more configurable.

robocat7 anni fa

The price difference was an extra 50% when I looked - and only came with 16.04 when I looked in December.

mixmastamyk7 anni fa

Wait a bit, the new 15 should be announced shortly.

rhodysurf7 anni fa

Businesses just buy Precisions instead... same chassis and better internals

samcday7 anni fa

InfinityEdge display with top camera placement
I wonder how many human-years of effort went into this improvement?

daenz7 anni fa

You mean you don't like the webcam at the bottom left of the display so your typing fingers occupy 50% of the image when you're typing and broadcasting? :)

freedomben7 anni fa

We had an office joke where those of us in this situation were called "Spidey fingers." It sounds dumb but once you see somebody typing on their laptop during a video conference, it becomes hilarious.

sliken7 anni fa

Heh, around here we call them nostril cams.

rbanffy7 anni fa

OTOH, they are a plus if your hair is getting thin.

buckminster7 anni fa

Unfortunately it moved into my nose.

dnautics7 anni fa

I mean it's not like looking at someone from below, about 45 degree angle is just about the creepiest view you can get.

ovi2567 anni fa

When aliens will invade with ships equipped with CRTs, they'll appreciate the fact that their new slaves are able to make them nice flatscreens, for sure.

sp3327 anni fa

According to https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/01/the-best-pcs-gadgets... the new camera is 2.25mm and they removed the IR camera for Windows Hello.

satysin7 anni fa

Tempting but how is the coil whine on the new model? I had a 9370 for two days last year but the coil whine was irksome to the point of returning it.

Also what is the point of 4K on a 13" laptop? Honestly the 1080p model needs scaling to at least 1.25 as 1.0 is just painful even with perfect vision. Am I missing something obvious or is it just so Dell can tick the 4K marketing check box?

Providing it has no coil whine the only potential issue I see is the crappy SOLDERED(!) Killer wifi card. Damn shame you can't get it with an Intel one.

kevinherron7 anni fa

4K has got to be marketing driven.

The ideal high DPI resolution for a screen of this size would be 3200x1800, allowing an effective resolution of 1600x900 with even 2x integer scaling.

eikenberry7 anni fa

I'm curious about the Killer wifi cards as I've never heard of them and I've always had issues with the Intel wifi cards in my Thinkpads. I went so far as to buy USB wifi for those times when the Intel one wouldn't work. Basically I'm saying that when I first saw it I was happy to see it wasn't Intel, but you are saying it's worse?

[edit] Oh... and you can get the 16G model without the 4K display. Just select the i7/8G model and upgrade it.

tamrix7 anni fa

The coil whine is per device not per model. You can get lucky and have no coil whine or unlucky and have it loud af on the same model laptops produced at the same time.

craftyguy7 anni fa

I must be incredibly unlucky for having owned several XPS 13 systems over the last 5 years, each with the coil whine.

mixmastamyk7 anni fa

What exactly is coil whine? Mine makes a light chatter sound when scrolling or animation happens onscreen. Is that the same?

craftyguy7 anni fa

Yep, that's it.

https://youtube/watch?v=blyswNKEPEY

satysin7 anni fa

True but it seems that Dell's XPS models seem to suffer from coil whine much more than I have ever experienced with other makes using the same primary components (CPU, RAM make, SSD make, etc.) so it is clearly something Dell does (or doesn't do) that makes the matter worse.

kowdermeister7 anni fa

> Also what is the point of 4K on a 13" laptop?

Nothing, that's pointless, I have the 1080 version and luckily no coil whine.

jhasse7 anni fa

I have a 9370 and no coil whine at all.

(also no problems with WiFi either)

nwlieb7 anni fa

Why is the 16GB RAM + FHD screen (1080p) variant not available in the US and Canada? It seems like this has been a long-standing issue since at least the 9360.

This is very frustrating since I don't need the 4k panel (in fact I don't want it for resolution scaling reasons) however I absolutely do need the 16GB of RAM.

Mind boggling.

sliken7 anni fa

What's worse is the 4k screen is a touch screen and very power intensive. When I looked a few months ago it took the expected battery lifetime from 20 hours to 12 hours. What's worse is that also meant you got a glossy screen instead of a matte. I passed.

nmstoker7 anni fa

A non-touch screen 4k would be my preference, but I suspect they won't ever offer it, despite the power implications you mention.

zihaoyu7 anni fa

FHD + 8GB model can be upgraded to 16GB for $100 more.

sowbug7 anni fa

EDIT: ignore everything below. Here's the link that parent is referring to: https://www.dell.com/en-us/work/shop/dell-laptops-and-notebo...

======

I hope you're right, because I've tried and failed to create such a configuration on the website. Would you mind providing a link to a RAM-configurable 1080 model?

For example, this one allows an i5/i7 choice as well as a 1080/2160 choice, but that's it -- no RAM/storage modifications: https://www.dell.com/en-us/work/shop/dell-laptops-and-notebo...

EDIT: Found it, and you're right! You have to start with the i7 rather than the i5 on the product home page, but yes, it's there! This is awesome -- never really used the 4K or touch, and could definitely use the extra battery life. https://www.dell.com/en-us/work/shop/dell-laptops-and-notebo...

mamon7 anni fa

But for whatever reason you cannot choose 1 TB SSD, capped at 512GB

klardotsh7 anni fa

I believe it's configurable. The all-Type-C 9370 was also configurable to that spec (and I have one with it)

kaaie7 anni fa

Maybe this is just a Canadian thing, but it seems like the 8gb RAM does not offer any upgrade options:

https://i.imgur.com/oI81Gt7.png

mediocrejoker7 anni fa

I think that's the 2018 version. As far as I can tell the 2019 is not posted yet. 8550 is a Kaby Lake process, not Whiskey Lake

Tehchops7 anni fa

What's the generally hold-up with 32GB RAM being a standard option(or even possibility) in this form factor?

anuragsoni7 anni fa

It might be their use of LPDDR3 memory. I haven't seen anyone with a 16GB LPDDR3 memory stick.

Edit: Looking at the specs it looks like whiskey lake did not add support for LPDDR4. [1] [2]

[1] https://ark.intel.com/products/149091/Intel-Core-i7-8565U-Pr...

[2] https://www.anandtech.com/show/13275/intel-launches-whiskey-...

jandrese7 anni fa

Intel's memory controller on their -U (Ultrabook) chips had a 16GB limitation last generation (or was it the one before?) but I think that's been lifted in Whiskey Lake.

But in general if you're doing heavy processing Intel doesn't usually recommend the Ultrabook class chips. They are optimized for battery life and low thermal load, not performance.

jsjohnst7 anni fa

> Intel's memory controller on their -U (Ultrabook) chips had a 16GB limitation

To be more specific, they don’t support LP-DDR3 with over 16gb. All laptops which support 32gb use regular DDR memory, not the low power variant. DDR4 is about the same as LP-DDR3 in power consumption under heavy load, but when not, LP-DDR3 is significantly less power usage. So while Intel is to blame for the cause of forcing a choice, ultimately the decision to prioritize battery life numbers is the reason you don’t see more 32gb laptops.

chx7 anni fa

Intel Ark claims 32GB limit in the first place for Kaby Lake Refresh chips but Campuspoint tested 32GB sticks (64GB) with the T480 and it worked. Indeed, it seems every Intel chip supporting DDR4 SO-DIMM supports 32GB sticks.

dajohnson897 anni fa

Seriously. This Dell would be perfect if we could get 32GB of ram.

fwiw: I have a System76 ubuntu laptop with 32gb of ram. It's bulky, but the performance is good. I can't imagine making space for 32gb of ram would compromise the XPS form factor much.

nrclark7 anni fa

which System76 laptop? I've been toying with the idea of getting an Oryx during the next round of upgrades at work.

lovehashbrowns7 anni fa

I have the Galago Pro with 32gb of ram. Bad battery life, terrible speakers and trackpad. But overall decent. I like the build and PopOS makes me happy as pie as to how well it all works out-of-the-box. Great price, too. But I think I picked up a few Christmas discounts.

dajohnson897 anni fa

Yeah I got the Oryx Pro 15". Default options, except 32G of ram.

I'm generally happy with it because I do data-intensive java development, and it handles that well (+ multitasking with chrome etc).

There are two cons you should be aware of: It's heavy, and the battery life isn't great at all. but if you use it like a desktop, or minimal carrying, it's good.

ambulancechaser7 anni fa

Totally agree. This is why I'm going to get a T480 thinkpad with 32GB for my next linux laptop next week rather than this.

ahnick7 anni fa

That's what I've been rocking for 7 months now and it is my best laptop ever. Highly recommend it!

storrgie7 anni fa

beware (if planning to do linux):

- only the thunderbolt dock works, all other docks have complications

- the LTE card will not work (exposed wrong, needs to be on usb)

- the webcam will not work (IR based)

otherwise it seems like a nice laptop

bdcravens7 anni fa

The XPS 15 also supports 32gb.

wongarsu7 anni fa

It's available on the (still current but older) XPS 15, so I guess it's some sort of space limitation?

ramenmeal7 anni fa

Back in 2012 I got a maxed out macbook air w/ 8gb of ram, and waking from sleep was noticeably slower than the other machines I've had. Never did any testing to see if that was actually the cause, but I'm curious if large amounts of memory can be hard for quick sleep/wake actions.

jsjohnst7 anni fa

> I'm curious if large amounts of memory can be hard for quick sleep/wake actions

No, because sleep mode keeps the memory powered (albeit in idle mode which with LP-DDR3 is less than 10% of the power draw normally).

Hibernate is where the ram gets flushed to disk and the ram is powered down, which could impact startup times with more RAM, but that isn’t the issue in your case I believe. I’m guessing your case is due to an app you have running.

blunte7 anni fa

Never again a Dell. XPS 15 was such a huge disappointment, not the least of which was capped by the near constant CPU voltage throttling down to 0.8GHz despite reasonable temperatures.

Specs are awesome. Reality over 1.5 years was way below according expectations. Apple may make really annoying decisions regarding function keys, RAM limitations, ports, etc., but their stuff largely works as promised (ok, keyboard aside).

jhack7 anni fa

If only they'd release a version of the XPS with a 16:10 or 3:2 ratio display. Getting work done on 16:9 is just so narrow and cramped.

I_am_tiberius7 anni fa

I currently have a 9350 and the 3-4 centimeters of potential screen real estate below the display which is unused, is more or less the only thing that bothers me. Plus, kernel 4.19 causes some wifi issues currently. But the hardware has been very reliable so far.

wildmindwriting7 anni fa

I have a 2017 13" XPS running Solus Linux. I have come to abhor this machine. I can't tell you the amount of times I've had to reboot the computer due to frozen or halting apps. I only have 8GB of RAM so that might be it but I can't run Slack app or the Google Play app at the same time without definitely causing problems.

I have a desktop with Solus and 16GB at home and never run into any issues with it.

I don't recommend this laptop anymore to anyone.

rashkov7 anni fa

Do you have a swap partition? If you don't have a swap partition enabled, then your computer will freeze when your RAM fills up.

I have the XPS 16" and this happens to me under Arch Linux, but thankfully not very often because I have 16GB of RAM. If you really have to break out of the freeze, then you can try switching to another terminal window (eg. ctrl-alt-F3 or some other function key), then try to kill the offending process. It might take a minute for your keyboard inputs to take effect, but it generally can be done.

bscphil7 anni fa

Tip: I have the exact same setup, and I use earlyoom (https://github.com/rfjakob/earlyoom) to prevent this. Previously, I was frequently unable to break out of the freeze no matter how long I waited, forcing a hard reboot, but with earlyoom just a single memory-heavy app gets killed instead.

rehemiau7 anni fa

I am guessing here but Solus Linux isn't probably officially supported by Dell on the Developer Edition of this laptop (you have the Developer Edition, don't you?)

wildmindwriting7 anni fa

I do have the Developer Edition. It may not be officially supported but everything works out of the box. I've got a personal IdeaPad laptop from years ago that has a worse configuration but doesn't freeze like this Dell.

sowbug7 anni fa

It sounds like not everything works out of the box.

zepearl7 anni fa

I had a (first version?) XPS 13 running first Gentoo and then later Linux Mint and I never had problems with it. Once I even let it run for 2 months without rebooting and making it go into suspend-to-RAM from time to time and it never crashed.

But then I still sold it because I could never get used to its cursor keys and absolutely hated the impossible-to-deactivate-embedded-automatic-brightness-control.

rlpb7 anni fa

I have a 2017 13" XPS running Ubuntu. It's a 9360 and I made sure to order one that actually shipped Ubuntu. It works perfectly and I'm very happy with it. I also have 8GB of RAM. I recommend this laptop to everyone, though of course I haven't tried the newer ones that are available today.

Perhaps OS support is your problem? Did you order it with Ubuntu or with Windows?

jhasse7 anni fa

> I don't recommend this laptop anymore to anyone.

Wouldn't this happen with any 8 GB laptop? Not sure what you blame the XPS 13 for that.

wildmindwriting7 anni fa

No, not all. My IdeaPad works just fine with similar specs and it's older than the XPS.

jeffmcjunkin7 anni fa

I was recently affected by my an aftermarket NVMe SSD: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux/+bug/1678184

tl;dr -- add `nvme_core.default_ps_max_latency_us=0` to /etc/default/grub in the GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX_DEFAULT parameter, run `update-grub`, reboot. Verify with `sudo nvme get-feature -f 0x0c -H /dev/nvme0`.

Totally agreed that this shouldn't happen. I hope that's your issue.

gao8a7 anni fa

I was looking at purchasing laptop but then I saw this: https://www.notebookcheck.net/Dell-briefly-teases-new-XPS-13....

Does this mean a newer version of this will be out in a few months?

davidw7 anni fa

I've been using these for years and love them. I've had to use a MBP for work for the last few months and boy is it ever torture to use. You know why? Mostly it's just about what you're used to. The quality of both computers is pretty good, but the Linux computer is set up exactly the way I want.

markstos7 anni fa

I've switched to a Pixelbook and like it for many tasks. The Pixelbook is lighter and has a taller 3:2 screen, both positives. The Chrome OS security model seems stronger than Ubuntu out of the box. My development environment now runs in the safety of a VM.

I had the XPS 13 9333 and later replaced it with the XPS 13 9730. It's about a year old now and is currently back with Dell to repair two USB-C ports that stopped working about the same time-- around the time I got the Pixelbook.

The Crostini software and integration on the Pixelbook still needs polish, but overall I'm happy with the Pixelbook as an XPS 13 alternative for a Linux development environment.

krn7 anni fa

I hope that Pixelbook 2 will be released soon with smaller bezels and more up-to-date hardware. Then switching from a Thinkpad running Fedora / Ubuntu to a Pixelbook will be a no-brainer to me. I think that ChromeOS is the most secure OS at the moment, and a Pixelbook is like an iPad Pro and a Macbook Air combined. Which is exactly what I want for work and leisure.

sowbug7 anni fa

Anyone know whether this model will work with USB-C phone chargers (or at least any chargers that provide less than 45 watts)?

And does anyone have first-hand knowledge whether the Killer wifi card is non-replaceable, as was the case with the 9370?

jhasse7 anni fa

I have a 9370 and charge it with a 45 watts phone charger from Inateck, works perfectly :)

sowbug7 anni fa

Same here (9350). I'm looking for info about chargers designed for phones or otherwise advertising less than 45 watts, as they're substantially smaller and more prevalent than the ones providing 20V @ 2.25A and above.

arccy7 anni fa

I have a 9350, it charges with 30w from an Anker one (that apparently only comes included with the 26800 pd battery pack) and 30w/45w (not sure) with an Innergie 60c

40acres7 anni fa

...but did they fix the coil wine? I was very interested in an XPS in 2017, my main criteria for a new laptop was a Linux machine, and yet during all my research quality concerns continued to rise up regarding to XPS, either it was coil wine, an icky track pad, poor keyboard, bad finishes.. you name it.

I ended up snagging a non touch bar MBP and haven't looked back. The elite cell manufacturers have been able to bridge the gap between their hardware quality and the iPhone.. why hasn't Dell?

adorton7 anni fa

I have a pretty new one (9370 I think) and I love it. No coil whine, the build feels great, and I have no complaints about that keyboard or trackpad. My only real complaint so far is the bluetooth is flaky.

bamboozled7 anni fa

Does the Bluetooth connection just drop out between suspensions? I’ve have this issue across both XPS 13’s I’ve owned. It’s incredibly frustrating and seems to be a long running issue [1]. If you care about Bluetooth I wouldn’t recommend an XPS 13

1.https://www.dell.com/community/Linux-Developer-Systems/XPS-1...

adorton7 anni fa

Yeah, mine drops after suspending. Sometimes it shows the device is disconnected and I need to re-pair it. Not sure if that is a problem with the system or my MX Ergo, but it never has problems on my Windows machine. Occasionally the whole bluetooth system dies and I need to reset.

Boulth7 anni fa

Haha, I was just going to ask about Bluetooth. I've got 9350 and while single device Bluetooth works quite well (okay, today it broke but it usually works) connecting Bluetooth headphones and a Bluetooth mouse at the same time makes the connection super unstable. That's with the proprietary firmware.

There are all kinds of issues in XPSes as far as I've seen. But generally it works well on Linux. I mean the same issues plague Windows too (I compared).

johnchristopher7 anni fa

I have given up on bluetooth ever being sane. If I don't connect my JBL, my xbox remote or anything bluetooth for more than a week then the connection is kapput and I have to delete and re-add the device. Windows, Linux, doesn't matter. It magically stops working when not used enough.

darkerside7 anni fa

Camera's moved to the top! That addresses what's been a common complaint over the years.

guntars7 anni fa

That was probably the main reason why I recently got a Precision instead of an XPS as a daily driver.

nofunsir7 anni fa

ThinkPad X1 Extreme (15.6") is light and powerful for its size. (Small bezels) I was worried that I'd have buyer's remorse reading this article, but I don't. It supports up to 64GB RAM, 2x Thunderbolt (with PD), 2x USB A 3.1. Fast charging. Bluetooth 5. 4K touch w/ wacom pen support. Infrared camera. Folds flat. Mouse nub. Sweet, sweet ThinkPad keys. Look for discounts through your work.

I should add:

DDR4 RAM and TWO (2) m.2 NVMe/PCIe slots!

mixmastamyk7 anni fa

Should be compared with the XPS 15, the 13 has a lot more compromises.

colemickens7 anni fa

Heads up, after I installed the 1.6.x BIOS update on my 9370, it takes multiple minutes to POST, every (re)boot. After the initial update, the first boot took nearly 15 minutes, I thought it had been bricked. I've reinstalled firmware, I've downgraded, I've factory reset and it still does this. They've offered to service it (I contacted them a week before my warranty expired) but it's not quite annoying enough to be without it for days.

Just a heads up, I have a lot more to complain about the XPS13, but it's basically exclusively BIOS issues [1]. I think they also need to improve the heatsink/paste, but maybe they have for the 9380 model.

[1] The BIOS releases are not always in increasing version numbers. They're repeatedly re-released versions, or released versions from different old servicing branches, etc. Someone commented that they thought Dell was sort of doing wide-scale A/B testing by releasing different versions and collecting feedback. Seems a bit presumptive but it's been in my head.

colemickens7 anni fa

Funny coincidence, as I was writing this post, someone else was sharing a Dell anecdote. https://www.reddit.com/r/Dell/comments/aj46fz/xps_9570_not_c... I partially do this to hopefully raise awareness -- if Dell would bring their BIOS in house, I would be a very, very vocal advocate of the XPS 13 for any non-Chromebook-level user.

edit: wow, Dell's BIOS vendor must have really butchered the last batch, here's another one: https://www.reddit.com/r/Dell/comments/aiwj7u/do_not_use_del...

sowbug7 anni fa

This is a long shot, but have you tried disconnecting the battery for a few minutes? My son's XPS 13 got into a situation where it was permanently throttled at 400MHz, and a random angel on the internet had tracked it down to a hardware safety that had triggered and could be reset only by disconnecting the power to let some low-level thing clear itself out.

Since you have a newer model, they might have BIOS-level throttling that the OS knows how to override, which would mean that booting would be super slow.

Worth a try -- good luck.

devereaux7 anni fa

Looks like a raminit problem. In the bios, there is often a module to do that. Your [1] comment raise the possibility that some mixup happened. I would suggest trying some "re released" version, ideally the same one as you had initially.

robocat7 anni fa

Pluses and minuses of the 9570 (XPS 15, bought Dec 2018) - some of the following apply to XPS 13 too (use common sense).

Pluses: - Linux works well (needs some tweaks, but they are easily findable) - Fast laptop CPU (i9-8950HK) and 32GB (for VMs) - 4k screen has great readability (need some tweaks) - USB-A 3 on both sides - I've had two firmware updates through Ubuntu (great Linux support by HP). - I haven't had any problems with the drivers (for the hardware I use - I haven't yet tried video and I don't use the fingerprint sensor)

Minuses: - No DisplayPort - Glossy (all the touch-screen models are glossy, the non-touch models are matte) - Killer WiFi (works, but I've read it is unreliable. Hopefully can replace if I have to) - No hard PgDn/PgUp/Home/End keys (very very annoying) - Linux is not "officially" supported (Windows tax) although I think the Linux support is good for a laptop. - No Ethernet port (I prefer a hard wire) - Screen colours are too orange

okl7 anni fa

> Screen colours are too orange

Here are some pointers on how to change that: https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/ICC_profiles

jcastro7 anni fa

Anyone have real-world experience with this killer 1435 wifi card in Linux? I'm hesitant to give up intel wifi's linux support.

umvi7 anni fa

Can't speak for Linux but on Windows the killer wifi card in my XPS 13 gave me nothing but grief. Internet connectivity problems, issues bringing laptop out of sleep, etc. Just a huge headache. Dell would never acknowledge the problem or provide anything but worthless scripted help involving running diagnostic tools even though I told them flat out to please replace the WiFi card. I eventually caved and bought an Intel WiFi card. While removing the killer card, killer's antenna connection ball broke off and got stuck inside the connector socket. I had to use a needle and magnifying glass to get it out. After installing the Intel WiFi card, ALL of the problems went away. Best $20 I ever spent.

It always amazes me when "premium" laptops use the same penny-pinching techniques as lower tier ones. I'm already paying $1000+, where the heck is it going if not quality parts??

dan6787 anni fa

I've got a 9560 with killer wifi card, running 16.04 with no problems. Additionally it's not that tough to swap out the killer for an intel wifi card if you really find the need to.

karavelov7 anni fa

I replaced intel wifi with Killer's, not sure if it's exactly the same model but it uses the same chip QCA6174. IMHO Atheros provides the best support under Linux.

bubblethink7 anni fa

You are thinking of the old ath9k cards. Newer ath10k cards, while still supported, do a lot of the stuff in the firmware. So they aren't that different from others.

karavelov7 anni fa

The killer cards in question, both mine and the one in the Dell laptop, use the ath10k driver. I had some problems with other cards (e.g. QCA988X as AP) but not with this chip specifically.

jhasse7 anni fa

I have a 9370 with killer 1435 and it works perfectly out-of-the-box. I'm running Fedora Linux.

shmerl7 anni fa

You can just replace it with Intel one.

AdmiralAsshat7 anni fa

I tried to do that on my 9343 and pretty sure I ended up breaking one of the clips on the aluminum case. I got it back on and after reseating it a couple of times there's no longer a visible gap once I get all the screws it, but there's a spot on the back of the laptop where I can press down and here a slight clicking noise, like a latch is trying to catch somewhere but can't.

Just saying, removing some of these things can be more difficult than the Youtube videos or internet guides would have you believe.

shmerl7 anni fa

I haven't used Dell really, but in many laptops, it's usually quite straightforward.

wyldfire7 anni fa

FWIW I changed the broadcom wifi on my 9343 for Intel and did not have this problem.

anuragsoni7 anni fa

with the newer XPS 13s the wireless chip is soldered on.

shmerl7 anni fa

Ah, that's too bad. But it might have some mPCIe extension slots? So you can just plug in an additional card.

klardotsh7 anni fa

Nah. The 9370 is basically fully soldered down with no expansion - the only exception (if I recall) is the SSD, which I think can still be swapped for now.

shmerl7 anni fa

That's bad, especially for developer oriented laptop.

chrismaeda7 anni fa

I've had a Dell Precision M7520 for about a year. It can have up to 64GB ram and runs Ubuntu 16 LTS. I think it came with a Windows 10 license but I threw it away. The only downside is that the standard power brick draws too much current to work on airplane power outlets. It also makes you stronger because it's so heavy (~7 lbs).

snazz7 anni fa

The “laptop workout” works better with a messenger bag or briefcase than a backpack in my experience since it puts more weight on your arms than your back.

jupp0r7 anni fa

16GB RAM? That's not going to work for many developers three years from now (I replace laptops every three years usually).

pjmlp7 anni fa

The large majority of laptops I have to deal with are still maxed at 8 GB, now if one needs to run the whole backend stack on the laptop, then it is another matter.

nickthemagicman7 anni fa

Yeah I use 8 gigs in chrome tabs alone.

ericabiz7 anni fa

This is a MacBook Air competitor. The Dell XPS 15 supports 32GB RAM.

bunderbunder7 anni fa

But also lacks a developer edition.

There's at least some value in that guarantee that you won't run into any driver issues.

bunderbunder7 anni fa

Can anyone recommend a comparable notebook that supports more than 16GB of RAM?

As great as this computer looks, I find myself doing doing more and more data crunching work that would benefit hugely from having more memory. But I also travel enough that a desktop (or desktop replacement laptop) just won't cut the mustard.

chx7 anni fa

If this laptop has SO-DIMM slots then it supports more than 16GB RAM. 32GB RAM sticks are available and compatible even if Intel doesn't claim they are. Campuspoint tested them with the Lenovo ThinkPad T480, for example.

erikdared7 anni fa

This is an ultrabook so chances are the memory modules are soldered on.

eikenberry7 anni fa

You can buy a T480 from Lenovo with 32GB of RAM.

chx7 anni fa

Yes but it works with 64gb.

tbronchain7 anni fa

I know that it's not exactly the same type of product (13vs15"), but I've been myself highly considering this xps13 previously and switched off primarily because of this 16gb issue.

I went for the Thinkpad X1E instead, and I have to say the experience has been nearly perfect so far (small minus for the battery performing far from what they announced).

It's fairly light for a 15", has plenty of ports, good screen (I'm using the mate screen), has 2 ram and pcie ssd slots, supports up to 64gb ram - future proof I'd say), and overall performances are just great.

ehmish7 anni fa

The Dell precision 5520 supports 32 GB of RAM, I'm presently running it in that configuration at the moment, it has an nvidia graphics card unfortunately which I had a couple of issues with until I uninstalled the nvidia drivers and just ran it off the Intel GPU

nofunsir7 anni fa

ThinkPad X1 Extreme. See my other comment.

warp_factor7 anni fa

I have a XPS 13 9370 with the 4K screen. I installed Linux on it and it is the best experience I have had in a long long time for a developer product.

I was on a mac for two years before that (and Linux even before) and I would not go back to Mac. If you are a developer, you have a lot to win to fully embrace Linux!

sfkdjf9j3j7 anni fa

Does anyone know if they fixed the automatic brightness adjustment that you can't turn off? I have 5th and 6th gen XPS 13s and they both have this awful "feature" where the display readjusts brightness based on how dark/light the colors on the screen are. It's really obnoxious to scroll over a gif on twitter and have your brightness start cycling up and down with the image. Or to highlight a line of code in a text editor and see the screen noticeably dim.

Everything else about these machines is great, but this is a complete show stopper for me. I would happily upgrade to a brand new $2500+ machine, but only if this is fixed.

Absor7 anni fa

On xps 13 9360 you can disable adaptive brigthness with an update that is available for windows. On xps 13 9370 you can disable adaptive brightness through bios if your bios is new enough.

beilabs7 anni fa

I bought a Dell XPS 13" back in 2008 and had nothing but problems with it. The graphics card was known to overheat and melt on the board. Dell instead of implementing a recall ended up figuring it was cheaper to send a repair man to replace the entire motherboard each time. It happened to me three times.

On top of that, the screen failed, the trackpad failed and the keyboard failed. The charger burned a hole in my carpet and the motherboard running only Linux and an IDE burned my table.

I haven't bought a Dell laptop since. Has things improved with the XPS 13 developer editions?

sudden7 anni fa

leibnitz277 anni fa

I seriously considered an XPS13 for a month or so (9370), but coil whine was an issue on 3 of the 4 examples I looked at. Pity, as it's a lovely notebook.

Instead, I went with a Samsung Notebook 9 13", and ... it's amazing. https://www.samsung.com/us/computing/windows-laptops/noteboo...

2.2lbs, and I've gone from charging every day to once a week.

berbec7 anni fa

I would totally buy one if it came with the pointy-stick (whatever Dell calls Track Point). The main reason I stay with Lenovo is eraser mouse. There's a nice HP (830 I think) but not much else.

ericfrederich7 anni fa

Is the hardware exactly the same as the non-developer version?

... meaning, could you order one with Windows 10 and then later down the line decide to run Linux on it and not have any issues?

sliken7 anni fa

In the past dell has changed the wifi chip and GPU on the linux variants they sell. I'd check for those differences whenever you buy. In particular the intel wifi has a much better linux driver than anything else dell sells in laptops.

[deleted]7 anni fa

jhasse7 anni fa

No, AFAIK they remove the fingerprint sensor on the developer edition (as there's no Linux support for it).

throw20167 anni fa

The deal of the year, or last 5 years, for a nice Linux laptop has to be the Huawei Matebook D Ryzen edition [1]. It is at $620 and was going as low as $420 a month ago, and Ubuntu works out of the box.

Don't let that price fool you, its sleek and the build quality and performance is up there with expensive ultrabooks.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=exLg45Up5b4

tmpfs7 anni fa

For what it is worth, I purchased an XPS13 and have had terrible problems with the touchpad and keyboard. The touchpad likes to jump around every once in a while and the keyboard sticks from time to time. I only found reports of this after the purchase and it is clear others have had the same problem.

I think it is a hardware problem and as such would not recommend buying into the XPS ecosystem. Bad quality control, will never buy a Dell again.

dnautics7 anni fa

Does anyone know if the linux-can't-handle-multiple-displays-when-one-of-them-is-4k-and-the-others-aren't issue has been resolved, either formally or informally? I've heard this from several folks, (and seen it firsthand once) and it's keeping me from upgrading my linux laptop for now (I don't have 4k monitors as a part of my work setup).

klardotsh7 anni fa

On Wayland it's generally a solved problem (at work I use Sway, with my internal panel - 13" 1080p, at 1.25x scale, and my external panel - 34" 3440x1440 - at 1x). Especially with Firefox nightlies bringing native Wayland support, it's only going to get better from here, but it's already pretty good.

In Xorg, it's as bad as it ever was, mostly for tech debt / protocol reasons. It can be alleviated somewhat with xrandr hacks, but they're gnarly.

neals7 anni fa

Running latest Ubuntu on a 4k and a 1280x1920 screen. Not ideal, but I can work with it. Some apps still have issues, either to large on the small screen, or to small on the big one... I feel like they're 1 or 2 version away from it being good.

Fractional scaling (125%) is not available. There is a workaround, but I couldn't get it to work.

paulie_a7 anni fa

I had plenty of issues with going back and forth. Finally I just got a Dell 4k monitor. I think it was 700 at the time but I am pretty sure they are closer to 350 now or less. That solved docking and so many other issues like restarting applications, etc.

wmf7 anni fa

All you people asking for matte and USB-A (and Ethernet), this just popped up from Japan: https://www.anandtech.com/show/13890/dynabooks-g-series-lapt... Too bad about the 8 GB RAM though.

throwawayXPSke7 anni fa

Is the keyboard still wrong? Lenovo and Apple are the only companies that I know of that get Fn/Ctrl placement correct.

Older XPS13 wouldn't let them be remapped (Fn is handled in hardware / Linux kernel doesn't see it). If they fix this I'd buy one.

But as it is, the control key is further away from C, D keys than on a desktop keyboard. Unacceptable to me.

lunchbreak7 anni fa

>Not only that but the 8th generation developer edition supports Suspend-to-idle natively which allows the system to resume much more quickly from sleep.

What's different about this from before? I have an xps9350 with fedora - and have noticed sometimes buggy suspending (it shuts down instead of suspending) - but it usually got fixed with kernel update

wil4217 anni fa

>In the 9370 the camera is located directly below the screen. In the new 9380 the camera has been moved to the top, providing a much more flattering view of the user while still maintaining the system’s sleek, compact design.

They put the camera below the screen? Am I understanding this right? Why on earth would someone let this fly.

jhasse7 anni fa

Because there's not much space left with a bezel-less design.

I never actually use the webcam, so I don't mind for example and appreciate the thinner top bezel instead.

rishabhsagar7 anni fa

I have the (now) older model XPS and this has been the best laptop I have owned in a long time. Very reliable, nice keyboard with backlight, good battery life, lightweight and came with almost no bloatware. My only slight issue was the camera placement and looks like that has been resolved now too. Very pleased.

cfstras7 anni fa

I had an 9360 for a few months and found it awful. Firmware bugs (some with Windows, a lot with Linux), maddening coil whine, flimsy power plug.

The Linux TB3 support was sadly not really „ready“ (mainline Kernels April~July 2018) in that there were constant panics when hotplugging/unplugging monitors or the docking station.

bubblethink7 anni fa

Any word on various performance/throttling issues that have plagued recent laptops due to Intel's DPTF ? My impression from what I read was that it's some kludge that only works on windows (and chromeos possibly) causing standard linux's performance to suffer unless you patch things.

AnabeeKnox7 anni fa

"Non-vPro processor".

Can someone help with a (dumb) question?

Does this mean that you can't run VirtualBox on this laptop?

kralos7 anni fa

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_vPro

Intel vPro technology is an umbrella marketing term used by Intel for a large collection of computer hardware technologies, including Hyperthreading, Turbo Boost 3.0, VT-x, VT-d, Trusted Execution Technology (TXT), and Intel Active Management Technology (AMT).

~~It means it doesn't have VTd / VTx hardware acceleration on the CPU. You can run VirtualBox however it will be slower. When I first saw "Developer edition" I thought; that must just mean it's got Virtualization hardware acceleration and loads of RAM for running VM's etc... This branding makes no sense to me.~~

I just looked up the 15W parts on Intel ark (i7-8565U, i5-8265U, i3-8145U) and they say they do have VT-d and VT-x...

jhasse7 anni fa

No, you can. For running VirtualBox you only need Intel VT-x.

cellover7 anni fa

1 year and a half after I bought my Dell XPS13 9360 developer edition, issues started: trackpad seems to be unsticking the underlying surface, plus some strong hiss noise appeared.

This is so disappointing when you invest around 2'000 USD in a laptop.

Hopefully this edition fixes those issues for good!

schmrz7 anni fa

I would offer another anecdote because I really believe this to be a very high quality laptop. I have bought my Dell XPS13 9360 around the same time and have never been happier with a laptop (running Fedora flawlessly, 10 hours of battery). And it cost me around 1250€ (~1420 USD).

jopsen7 anni fa

Lost me at 16G of ram... I use chrome + vscode and is regularly out-of-memory on my X1 Carbon.

Give me 64G, why not?

Also last I tried XPS I had to send it back due to electrical noise.. particularly under Linux (didn't really try Windows). Has Dell gotten better at this over the past 3 years?

DougBTX7 anni fa

Are you having problems due to running out of memory? If memory isn’t full then the OS isn’t putting it to best use, so overall memory usage isn’t a great metric.

jopsen7 anni fa

You could possibly blame chrome and vscode... And modern web apps in general..

But yes, I run my swap full and can't launch apps because I'm out of memory.

jbredeche7 anni fa

I literally just got a new Dell 9380 today, running Windows. My plan was to wipe and install Ubuntu. After I do that, will there be any functional differences between my laptop and this newly announced developer edition?

jsiepkes7 anni fa

Does it come without LoJack ( https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LoJack_for_Laptops ) ?

lwhi7 anni fa

'Easier to open' .. should this really need to be an improvement?

sowbug7 anni fa

If it's identical to consumer hardware, then there's no reason to design it to be easy to open. But a developer laptop will be opened.

(I might be attacking a strawman, but I detect in your question a suggestion that more consumer hardware should be user-serviceable. There's a difference between being hostile toward serviceability and simply optimizing the design for manufacturability, aesthetics, cost, and reliability, any of which can conflict with other metrics such as serviceability.)

mixmastamyk7 anni fa

Believe it is about opening the lid, not the case.

sowbug7 anni fa

Oh, duh. Yes, I totally misinterpreted that. Thanks.

jypepin7 anni fa

Any reason why they'd still be using Thunderbolt and only put 1 usb-c instead of full usb-c like macbooks? With even apple dropping thunderbolt, isn't it a sign of death for those ports?

ken7 anni fa

"Apple dropping Thunderbolt"? Out of their 7 different Mac models, there's only 2 that don't have full 40Gbps Thunderbolt 3 on every USB-C port -- and they're the two that have been the longest since an update (2017 MacBook, 2013 Mac Pro).

What does "full USB-C" mean?

jypepin7 anni fa

oh my bad, I thought Thunderbolt meant the dongle type, as in, the shape of the plug. My macbook only has 4 USB-C plugs.

TacticalTable7 anni fa

The vast vast majority of laptop users still have USB A peripherals. Apple was a decade too early (to their detriment) going full USB C. They're helping the USB C ecosystem, at the cost of dongle hell for their users.

alexeiz7 anni fa

So what's the difference between the normal XPS 13 and the developer edition, except for the preinstalled Ubuntu? Can I buy the normal XPS 13 and then put the same Ubuntu image on it?

equalunique7 anni fa

I appreciate being able to get Ubuntu GNU/Linux on a sleek Dell laptop, but without a TrackStick/TrackPoint/PointStick, it's no "developer laptop" for me.

agrippanux7 anni fa

I love the Dell XPS 13 developer edition I bought over the summer, and it has been a better value store than the Bitcoin I sold to buy it with.

Klonoar7 anni fa

Anyone have any idea why these dev-focused machines top out at 16GB of RAM? Even Apple finally caved and bumped it on newer MBPs to 32GB max...

mixmastamyk7 anni fa

13" ultraportable limits from Intel.

bonestamp27 anni fa

The $739 starting price is really nice... I was tempted to pick one up just for fun, but then I saw upgrading to 8gb of RAM is another $300.

rubicon337 anni fa

UHG. I just wish you could make iOS apps on non-mac devices. I really want to move to an XPS 13, but I need to be able to develop for iOS.

mancerayder7 anni fa

I'm torn between this and the X1 and the T4xx to dual-boot Linux and Windows. How's Linux and its drivers on the latest Lenovos?

CasperTol7 anni fa

What does NT and T after the resolution refer to?

anuragsoni7 anni fa

My guess would be NT => Non Touch, T => Touch

CasperTol7 anni fa

That makes sense, thanks!

bhaisaab7 anni fa

Has anybody seen/used the new HP spectre x360 gem-cut? Any feedback on spectre x360 vs XPS13 for developers?

jbk7 anni fa

Is there a matte display option this time?

ausjke7 anni fa

anyone develop on the little 13" screen these days? I assume it will always be hooked to a few monitors(2) for any coding tasks?

also what about the power consumption for linux, i bought a XPS13 for a family member and have not turned it to ubuntu for him as linux always eats up batter faster.

sbov7 anni fa

Its not so bad if you make good use of your hotkeys. E.g. on Ubuntu the "windows key" + number will switch to that program in your dock. I have it setup like this: win+1 = IDE, win+2 = terminal, win+3 = test browser, win+4 = documentation, win+5=notes.

Then you can easily run everything on fullscreen and not worry about alt-tab-hell.

pjmlp7 anni fa

I do on a EEE PC 1215B, the last of the netbook's generation, but only when travelling, or weekend coding at some coffe shop, nothing serious.

Basically do the same as I always did since fvwm days, a couple of virtual screens, with each one having a maximized application and then I just switch among them.

saagarjha7 anni fa

> anyone develop on the little 13" screen these days

I almost exclusively prefer 13" displays for development. I feel lost on larger displays.

IloveHN847 anni fa

It's a pity there's no 32/64 GB RAM configuration.

pandemic_region7 anni fa

meanwhile, i'm still waiting for Ubuntu 18 on my 9370....

nmstoker7 anni fa

What's the hold up? YMMV but on my earliest XPS13 it came with 14.04 LTS I think and 16.04 LTS was just out, so I just installed fresh and it was fine with absolutely no issues: everything just worked.

pandemic_region7 anni fa

As far as I understand it's a customized version of Ubuntu with some special drivers for the hardware. I was kind of expecting a system upgrade like Android or iPhone does, totally managed by the hardware provider.

mediocrejoker7 anni fa

Has anyone been able to find the link on the Canadian site?

Double_a_927 anni fa

How is this different from blatant advertising?

jordache7 anni fa

how is the trackpad on the xps w/ ubuntu? Is the dell + linux combo equivalent to Apple's trackpad in performance?

usaphp7 anni fa

I would rather get same priced new MacBook Air, better touch pad, better screen, better OS and better battery life.

Schnitz7 anni fa

No 32GB RAM option?

oweiler7 anni fa

Only 16GB RAM max?

rettori7 anni fa

yeah, that's a bummer. 2019 notebooks with the same max memory of 3-4 years ago.

funkythings7 anni fa

I never understood, why Dell only offers a FHD and UHD model. FHD just looks shitty after using more high def displays, and UHD sucks the life out of this thing. Otherwise, perfect laptop.

charliebrownau7 anni fa

[deleted]7 anni fa

chrisfinazzo7 anni fa

(Puts on old man hat)

XPS is a gaming machine. Save the No BS hardware for the Latitude line - which has subsequently gone to shit, last I checked.

kkarakk7 anni fa

hey old man, devs can have hobbies outside of learning more about development so i don't know why you're making a dig at gaming. a quick 15minute session of fortnite in the middle of the day is quite nice

chrisfinazzo7 anni fa

Truth be told, I'm in my early 30's, but for the longest time, XPS was gaming oriented (probably b/c of the Alienware acquisition) and Latitude was for the business crowd.

Seeing the roles reversed - esp. as Latitude H/W has seemingly gone downhill, because keyboards - is quite strange.