French court finds Monsanto guilty of poisoning farmer(theguardian.com)
theguardian.com
French court finds Monsanto guilty of poisoning farmer
https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/apr/11/french-court-finds-monsanto-guilty-of-poisoning-farmer
26 comments
Note: you have seen one of the better organic farms.
In most countries the requirements for what constitutes as organic are so loose, that you are not going to see differences similar to this one.
I feel like sourcing from places that you trust is the best way to proceed. I would not trust a label, just because they claim to have organic produce.
In most countries the requirements for what constitutes as organic are so loose, that you are not going to see differences similar to this one.
I feel like sourcing from places that you trust is the best way to proceed. I would not trust a label, just because they claim to have organic produce.
Ironically, organic wine is one of the organic products that’s least sustainable, because of the widespread use of copper sulfate (conventional vineyards use it too, but also have other more sustainable options). It builds up in the soil and in the vineyard workers. https://geneticliteracyproject.org/2017/06/09/winemakers-aba...
While your sentiment is noble, please be aware that "organic" is often used as a very broad (read: marketing) term and that you have to research individual producers, products and country laws to be sure that "organic" means the latter and not the former.
In USA organic has a very strict definition. Natural on the otherhand doesn't actually mean anything
Right, but that strict definition is often broader than people expect. Many people don't realize that organic production normally allows for significant pesticide use, courtesy of natural pesticides that could in some cases be worse than their better-targeted synthetic counterparts.
> ...dead brown grass a foot either side of every row of vines, from insecticide which is applied every 6 weeks.
You must be talking about herbicide, not insecticide. Herbicide kills unwanted plants, that's the whole point. It generally doesn't kill insects or "everything around it". Numerous unsuccessful attempts were made to show that Roundup/Glyphosate was harmful to bees, for example.
> I do not want to eat fruit or plant byproducts from roots which are constantly exposed to weedkiller or insecticide so strong that it kills all around it (except the root itself).
You should be aware then that there is such a thing as organic pesticides/herbicides which are no less "harmful" than their non-organic counterparts. The difference between organic/non-organic is generally whether a compound is synthetic or not, which is a completely nonsensical distinction from a health/environmental standpoint.
Herbicides/Pesticides are indispensable tools for modern agriculture. They generally have been tested to be safe to use on produce for human consumption. You should probably be more worried about the natural chemicals that some of these plants contain.
You must be talking about herbicide, not insecticide. Herbicide kills unwanted plants, that's the whole point. It generally doesn't kill insects or "everything around it". Numerous unsuccessful attempts were made to show that Roundup/Glyphosate was harmful to bees, for example.
> I do not want to eat fruit or plant byproducts from roots which are constantly exposed to weedkiller or insecticide so strong that it kills all around it (except the root itself).
You should be aware then that there is such a thing as organic pesticides/herbicides which are no less "harmful" than their non-organic counterparts. The difference between organic/non-organic is generally whether a compound is synthetic or not, which is a completely nonsensical distinction from a health/environmental standpoint.
Herbicides/Pesticides are indispensable tools for modern agriculture. They generally have been tested to be safe to use on produce for human consumption. You should probably be more worried about the natural chemicals that some of these plants contain.
> Numerous unsuccessful attempts were made to show that Roundup/Glyphosate was harmful to bees
Yes, but there were also successful attempts. https://www.pnas.org/content/115/41/10305 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acs.jafc.8b02212
1000 people not finding the right reason does not mean it does not exist, it just means they didn't find it. When somebody does find it, we don't say "we'll only listen to you when 1001 papers agree with you".
Yes, but there were also successful attempts. https://www.pnas.org/content/115/41/10305 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acs.jafc.8b02212
1000 people not finding the right reason does not mean it does not exist, it just means they didn't find it. When somebody does find it, we don't say "we'll only listen to you when 1001 papers agree with you".
I'm sorry, but your experience seems to me to just scream of a fallacious appeal to nature. While there are certainly issues with herbicides and insecticides, just because something looks nice doesn't mean its the better option.
Why do you think that dead grass surrounding a vineyard is harmful? The only conditions under which this would be a bad thing are: a) there is a wider environmental impact; b) there is a risk to consumers. Neither of which you could see by casually strolling by.
This type of anecdotal feelings based decision making is how we ended up with widespread anti-vaccine, anti-gluten, anti-GMO sentiment, etc.
This type of anecdotal feelings based decision making is how we ended up with widespread anti-vaccine, anti-gluten, anti-GMO sentiment, etc.
I would not put antibiotics, GMO or gluten in the same basket, however even if (imo) pretty valid concerns arise from the population, these are still used widely.
I don't understand this sentiment, why is organic so quickly associated why unscientific bullshit like anti-vaccine? Maybe it's specific to the US, but here in France even if historically there is a lot of snake-oil products associated with "natural" things, organic is a strict regulated label, and apart for some products (like wine), does not cause much debate in the "scientific-minded" crowd (except for GMO) for environmental and health benefits.
Why would you think dead grass is harmful? It's not dead grass that is harmful. The poison that kills the grass is harmful.
Chocolate is toxic to dogs, but that doesn't mean it's dangerous to us. Again, you can't just rely on your gut feeling for this kind of stuff.
Roundup is toxic to humans as are most if not all herbicides. I think it would be better to assume anything that can kill grass is toxic to humans unless there is significant research proving this to not be true. I would rather see people err on the side of caution in this area.
My parents own a small vineyard near bordeaux. We don't use weedkiller so there is grass all over (see http://montjon.com/). But no grass or brown grass doesn't necessarily mean that the owner uses a lot weed killer or insecticides, there are other ways to remove the grass mechanically. e.g. this type of tools https://youtu.be/gmaIugbRPDI?t=227
The video is convincing, but in practice it takes a lot of time and breaks many roots, so it's not ideal.
The video is convincing, but in practice it takes a lot of time and breaks many roots, so it's not ideal.
I wonder if they'll also change ways, or just names.
https://www.theguardian.com/business/2018/jun/04/monsanto-to...
https://www.theguardian.com/business/2018/jun/04/monsanto-to...
They won't change anything while they spend the next 10 years in legal maneuvers to draw out the case, then, probably after they've made another billion euros on other shitty, dangerous products, they will settle out of court for a pittance compared to the profit they made off of this and other discontinued and dangerous chemicals.
ftr45(2)
Before this "organic" to me meant: expensive, nice idea, faddish and definitely not something I sought out.
This trip has been life-changing. I've become an organic convert overnight. I do not want to eat fruit or plant byproducts from roots which are constantly exposed to weedkiller or insecticide so strong that it kills all around it (except the root itself).
[1]- https://www.amazon.com/s?k=caro+feely&ref=nb_sb_noss_2